Honestly, the "sophomore slump" is a real thing in the book world. You’ve probably seen it a thousand times: a brilliant debut, a world-shaking twist, and then a sequel that basically just treads water until the finale. But when Jennifer A. Nielsen dropped The Runaway King, she didn't just tread water. She set the pool on fire.
If you’re coming straight from The False Prince, you’re likely still reeling from the revelation that Sage was King Jaron all along. It was a masterclass in first-person unreliable narration. But The Runaway King Jennifer Nielsen is a different beast entirely. It’s grittier. It’s messier.
And, frankly, Jaron is kind of a jerk in this one.
The Myth of the Perfect King
Most people expect a fantasy sequel to show the new king sitting on a throne, solving problems with a wave of a scepter. Instead, we find Jaron failing. Miserably. He’s been king for a grand total of a month, and the kingdom of Carthya is already a dumpster fire. His regents don’t trust him—probably because he’s a fifteen-year-old with the impulse control of a caffeinated squirrel—and his neighbors in Avenia are basically sharpening their swords on his front porch.
Then comes the funeral.
Imagine trying to mourn your family, only to have your former friend Roden show up with a pirate-backed ultimatum: abdicate in ten days or watch your kingdom burn. Most protagonists would hunker down in the castle. Jaron? He decides to run away.
Why Jaron’s "Plan" is Actually Insane
Let’s talk about the pirate king, Devlin. This isn’t some cartoon villain with a parrot. This is the man who murdered Jaron’s family. Jaron’s "brilliant" strategy is to go undercover as a common thief, infiltrate the pirate camp at Tarblade Bay, and... well, he sort of figures the rest out as he goes.
💡 You might also like: I Know My Calculus: Why That 2gether Song Is Still Stuck in Your Head
Critics often point out that Jaron’s planning in this book feels way less "Batman-level genius" than it did in book one. They’re right. In The False Prince, he was playing a long game he’d practiced for years. In The Runaway King, he’s desperate. He’s a kid who thinks he has to carry the world on his shoulders, so he pushes everyone away—Mott, Tobias, and especially Imogen—to "protect" them.
It’s classic self-sabotage.
The Fink Factor
One of the best things Nielsen did was introduce Fink. This kid is basically a mirror for Jaron. He’s a witty, annoying, street-smart thief who reminds Jaron of who he used to be. Seeing Jaron forced into a "big brother" role is where we see the actual growth. It’s easy to be a king; it’s hard to be responsible for a kid who looks up to you when you’re barely keeping your own head above water.
The Roden Redemption (Sorta)
We have to discuss the duel. The climax at Tarblade Bay is brutal. Jaron gets his leg broken—which, by the way, is a recurring theme in this series; Nielsen loves putting this poor kid through physical therapy—and has to fight Roden.
What most people miss is that Jaron doesn't win by being a better swordsman. He wins because he understands Roden's desperation. By offering Roden a place by his side instead of a grave, Jaron proves he’s finally starting to understand leadership. It isn't about the crown. It's about the people you're willing to forgive.
What You Should Actually Take Away
If you’re looking for a clean, happy-ever-after sequel, this isn't it. The Runaway King is about the cost of identity. Jaron spends the whole book trying to be Sage again, only to realize he can’t go back. He’s marked—literally, by a pirate brand, and figuratively by the weight of Carthya.
A few things to keep in mind if you're analyzing this for a book club or just a deep-dive reread:
- The Pocket Watch: It’s not just jewelry. It’s his last link to his father’s approval. Losing it and regaining it tracks his internal confidence.
- The Imogen/Amarinda Dynamic: Jaron is stuck between a political betrothal to Princess Amarinda and his genuine connection to Imogen. It’s a mess because life is a mess.
- The Ending: That cliffhanger is a gut-punch. Avenia declares war, and Imogen is taken. It resets the stakes for The Shadow Throne.
Next Steps for the Ascendance Obsessed
You've finished the book, you've processed the trauma, now what?
✨ Don't miss: Is Austin Powers Appropriate for Kids? An Austin Powers Parents Guide for the Modern Rewatch
Start by re-reading the first three chapters of The Shadow Throne immediately. The transition is seamless, and you’ll want the context of Jaron’s injury while it’s still fresh. Also, keep a close eye on the character of Gregor—his betrayal in the pirate camp is a huge indicator of how deep the rot in Carthya’s court actually goes. If you’re feeling extra, map out the locations of Libeth and Tarblade Bay; the geography of the Borderlands becomes crucial for the tactical battles in the later books.