Edward Nygma is a narcissist. Honestly, that’s the only way to explain why he thought building an underground racing circuit beneath Gotham City was a good use of his time while Scarecrow was literally threatening to liquefy the population with fear gas. If you’ve spent any time with The Riddler Batman Arkham Knight missions, you know exactly what I’m talking about. It’s not just about the puzzles anymore. It’s about the sheer, exhausting scale of it all.
Most people remember the Arkham series for its tight combat or that feeling of being a silent predator in the rafters. But then there’s Nygma. He’s the wall you hit when you want that 100% completion trophy. He’s the reason your map is covered in green icons that look more like a grocery list than a superhero adventure.
Is it overkill? Probably. But there is a weird, twisted logic to why Rocksteady went so heavy on the green question marks for the grand finale of their trilogy.
The 243-Trophy Elephant in the Room
Let's talk numbers. To actually "beat" the game—and I mean see the full Knightfall Protocol ending—you have to collect 243 Riddler trophies, riddles, and breakables. That is a staggering amount of busywork. In Arkham Asylum, the riddles felt like world-building. In Arkham City, they were a fun distraction. In Arkham Knight, they feel like a second job.
Nygma has evolved. Or devolved, depending on how much you value your free time. He’s moved past simple logic puzzles and into the realm of mechanical engineering. He somehow managed to build massive, hydraulic-shifting obstacle courses right under the GCPD’s nose. The logic is thin, but the challenge is real.
The Batmobile is the biggest change here. A huge chunk of the The Riddler Batman Arkham Knight content is tied to that tank. You aren't just scanning wall paintings; you're winching power cells, performing wall-runs in a multi-ton vehicle, and ejecting into mid-air glides to hit pressure plates. It’s a polarizing shift. Some fans love the high-speed precision. Others just want to be the World’s Greatest Detective, not the World’s Greatest Stunt Driver.
👉 See also: Carl? Mr. Cupcake? Solving the Five Nights at Freddy’s Cupcake Name Mystery Once and For All
Why the Final Confrontation Feels So Personal
If you’ve played the previous games, you know the drill: find the trophies, find the hideout, takedown Nygma. But this time, he’s got Catwoman.
This adds a layer of genuine stakes that was missing before. Selina Kyle is trapped in the Orphanage with a bomb collar around her neck. It forces a dynamic that actually works quite well—dual-play combat and puzzles. Switching between Batman and Catwoman to coordinate movements feels like the "definitive" way to experience these challenges. It’s not just Nygma versus Batman; it’s Nygma trying to prove he’s smarter than the "Bat and the Cat" combined.
The boss fight itself? It’s a giant robot.
Specifically, a giant green mech suit fueled by Nygma's pure, unadulterated saltiness. He’s tired of losing. He’s tired of Batman "cheating" by being a better detective. So, he builds a suit. It’s a bit silly, sure. But after 200+ trophies, seeing Nygma’s face through a cockpit window as you prepare to finally punch him is incredibly cathartic.
💡 You might also like: Why a communication error has occurred in Monster Hunter Wilds is driving players crazy
Breaking Down the Challenge Types
It isn't just one type of grind. Rocksteady mixed it up, for better or worse.
- Riddler Trials: These are the big Batmobile race tracks. They require genuine skill and a lot of patience with the "Blockades" that Nygma activates.
- The Orphanage: This is the heart of the Catwoman storyline. These are the "classic" puzzles where you have to think about positioning and timing.
- Grid Puzzles: These are scattered across the islands. Some require the Remote Electrical Charge (which you have to actually go find in the GCPD evidence room—the game doesn't just give it to you!).
- Riddler Informants: You still have to hunt down those glowing green thugs. Pro tip: don't accidentally knock them out in a crowd. It's the worst feeling in the game.
The "True" Ending Controversy
Here is where things get spicy. You cannot see the "Full" Knightfall Protocol ending unless you capture every single villain in Gotham. And Nygma is usually the last one standing.
For a lot of players, this felt like a betrayal. You’ve saved the city from Scarecrow, you’ve dealt with the Arkham Knight’s identity reveal, and you’ve cleaned up the streets. But the game says, "Wait, you didn't find the 243rd tiny green statue? No ending for you."
It’s a bold design choice. On one hand, it rewards the truly dedicated. It makes that final cutscene feel earned. On the other hand, it turns the climax of an epic story into a scavenger hunt. Most people just end up watching the final 10 minutes on YouTube. Honestly? I don't blame them. The leap from "finishing the story" to "completing Nygma's challenges" is a 20-hour gap for most.
📖 Related: World of Warcraft Great Vault: Why You Are Probably Doing Your Weeklies Wrong
Is It Actually Worth Doing?
If you're a lore nerd, yes. The dialogue between Batman and Nygma during these challenges is some of the best in the game. You hear the desperation in Nygma's voice. He isn't just trying to win; he's trying to justify his entire existence. He needs Batman to be his intellectual equal because, without that rivalry, he’s just a man in a green suit with a fragile ego.
Plus, the interaction with Catwoman provides some of the only "human" moments Batman gets in the entire game. Their banter is top-tier. It softens the blow of having to solve yet another pressure plate puzzle.
A Few Tips for the Sane Player
Don't try to do these all at once. You'll lose your mind. The best way to handle The Riddler Batman Arkham Knight content is to weave it into the main story.
- Interrogate everyone. Every time you see a green glow in a group of thugs, make them the last man standing.
- Use the Disruptor. You can actually sabotage some of Nygma's traps before they start.
- Upgrade the Batmobile's Eject. A lot of trophies require you to launch yourself high into the air. If you don't have the max height upgrade, you're going to struggle.
- Listen to the environment. Sometimes the "riddle" is just a landmark. If you see something that looks out of place—like a poster for a circus or a specific building—scan it.
The Legacy of the Arkham Riddler
Looking back, Nygma in Arkham Knight represents the "more is more" philosophy of open-world gaming in the mid-2010s. It’s bloated, it’s frustrating, and it’s occasionally brilliant. It’s the ultimate test of a player's patience.
While some might call it "padding," there’s no denying that finally locking Nygma in a cell at the GCPD is one of the most satisfying moments in the franchise. He rants. He raves. He complains about the lighting. And you just walk away, knowing you’ve finally shut him up.
Actionable Steps for Completionists
If you are determined to clear the map, start by focusing on the Bleake Island trophies first, as they are generally simpler and introduce the core mechanics you'll need for the more complex puzzles on Founders' Island. Ensure you have collected all gadgets, including the Freeze Blast (found in Panessa Studios) and the Remote Electrical Charge (GCPD), or you will hit literal walls you cannot bypass. Map out your informant interrogations early to reveal trophy locations on the HUD, which saves hours of blind searching. Finally, approach the Batmobile trials with the mindset of a racing game—precision and drifting are more important than raw speed. Once the 243rd objective is clear, head back to the Orphanage for the final showdown and your ticket to the 100% ending.