It’s been over two decades since Peter Jackson stood on that stage at the Kodak Theatre, sweeping all eleven categories the movie was nominated for. Eleven for eleven. That’s a clean sweep. Honestly, looking back at The Lord of the Rings 3, better known to everyone as The Return of the King, it’s hard to fathom how a high-fantasy epic about hobbits and jewelry managed to convince the Academy to treat it with the same reverence as Ben-Hur or Titanic. Usually, the Oscars ignore wizards. But this was different.
The scale was just too big to ignore.
You’ve probably seen the memes about the "multiple endings." People joke that the movie finishes four times before the credits finally roll. But there's a reason for that. Jackson wasn't just finishing a movie; he was concluding a decade-long production process that changed how movies are made. Most people forget that the entire trilogy was shot simultaneously in New Zealand. By the time the third installment hit theaters in 2003, the cast and crew were basically living in Middle-earth. It wasn't just a film; it was a cultural shift.
The Battle of Pelennor Fields and the CGI Revolution
When we talk about The Lord of the Rings 3, we have to talk about the scale of the conflict. The Battle of Pelennor Fields remains, for many, the high-water mark of cinematic warfare. It’s massive. Thousands of combatants. Giant elephants—mûmakil—stomping through the ranks. What made it work wasn't just the sheer number of pixels, but the "Massive" software developed by Stephen Regelous at Weta Digital.
Before this, digital crowds were just clusters of clones moving in unison. It looked fake. "Massive" gave every individual orc and soldier an "AI brain." They could see the terrain. They knew who to hit. This created a sense of organic chaos that had never been seen on screen.
But here is the thing: the tech was only half the battle. Jackson used real people too. Big ones. The production famously scouted for the tallest men in New Zealand to play the Uruk-hai, and the most skilled horse riders for the Rohirrim. When you see the Charge of the Rohirrim, those are real horses. That’s real dust. You can feel the weight of it. Digital effects are great, but they only age well when they are anchored by something tangible. That's why the movie still looks better than most Marvel films released last year.
Why the Ending of The Lord of the Rings 3 is Actually Perfect
Okay, let's address the elephant in the room. The ending. Or endings.
Critics love to point out that the movie has several "fade to blacks" that lead into more scenes. You have the coronation. You have the return to the Shire. You have the Grey Havens. To a casual viewer, it feels long. To a fan of J.R.R. Tolkien’s work, it’s necessary. Tolkien’s The Return of the King wasn't just about blowing up a ring in a volcano. It was about the "Scouring of the Shire" and the lingering trauma of war.
💡 You might also like: Not the Nine O'Clock News: Why the Satirical Giant Still Matters
While Jackson famously cut the "Scouring" subplot (where Saruman takes over the Shire), he kept the emotional resonance. Frodo Baggins, played with a sort of wide-eyed PTSD by Elijah Wood, can't just go back to gardening. He’s changed. "How do you pick up the threads of an old life?" That line hits hard because it treats the journey with respect. If the movie had ended at the coronation, it would have been a fairy tale. By showing the departure at the Grey Havens, it becomes a myth.
The bittersweet nature of the ending is what gives the trilogy its staying power. It isn't a "happily ever after" in the traditional sense. It’s a "we survived, but we are different now." That’s sophisticated storytelling for a blockbuster.
Gollum and the Birth of Modern Performance Capture
We can’t discuss the impact of The Lord of the Rings 3 without mentioning Andy Serkis. He’s the pioneer. Before Gollum, digital characters were mostly things like Jar Jar Binks—characters that felt "pasted" onto the scene.
Serkis changed the game by insisting on being on set. He wasn't just a voice actor in a booth; he was in the dirt with Wood and Sean Astin. The "Schizophrenia" scene in the third film, where Gollum and Sméagol argue over their plan to lead the hobbits to Shelob, is a masterclass in acting. Not just "voice acting." Acting.
The Academy actually had to debate whether Serkis was eligible for an Oscar nomination. They ultimately decided no, which sparked a conversation that is still happening today in the age of Avatar and Planet of the Apes. Can a digital skin hide a legendary performance? Most people who watch the scene where Gollum realizes he's been "betrayed" by Frodo would argue that the emotion is as real as any human performance on film.
The Production Reality: Chaos Behind the Scenes
It wasn't all Oscars and glory. The making of the third film was a logistical nightmare. Howard Shore was composing the score at a breakneck pace, sometimes writing music for scenes that were still being edited.
There’s a famous story about the "Black Gate" sequence. They filmed it on an army training range in New Zealand that was still littered with unexploded landmines. The crew had to bring in experts to clear paths so the actors wouldn't, you know, actually blow up.
📖 Related: New Movies in Theatre: What Most People Get Wrong About This Month's Picks
Also, the sheer volume of props was staggering:
- 48,000 pieces of armor.
- 10,000 prosthetic facial appliances.
- Over 2,000 rubber and "hero" swords.
- Roughly 1,600 pairs of hobbit feet.
The hobbit feet were a particular pain. They couldn't be reused. The actors had to get a new pair glued on every single morning. Samwise Gamgee (Sean Astin) once stepped on a piece of glass in the water while filming, and because of the prosthetic, the doctors had to perform a mini-surgery through the rubber foot. The things people do for cinema.
Sound and Music: The Emotional Backbone
While the visuals get the glory, the sound design of The Lord of the Rings 3 is what actually sells the world. The sound of the Nazgûl—those terrifying Ringwraiths—was created using a mix of plastic cups being scraped together and the scream of Peter Jackson's wife, Fran Walsh, who was suffering from a throat infection at the time.
And then there's Howard Shore’s score. By the third film, Shore had developed dozens of "leitmotifs" (specific musical themes for characters or places). When the violins kick in for the lighting of the beacons, it's not just "epic music." It’s a musical callback to the Fellowship theme, signaling hope. It's mathematical in its precision and deeply emotional in its execution. The "Into the West" track by Annie Lennox, which plays over the credits, won the Oscar for Best Original Song for a reason. It perfectly encapsulates the feeling of a long journey finally ending.
Common Misconceptions About the Third Film
A lot of people think The Return of the King is the "longest" version of the movies, but that's actually a bit of a toss-up depending on whether you're watching the Theatrical or Extended Editions.
The Ghost Army is a "Deus Ex Machina": Some critics hate the Army of the Dead. They feel it’s a "cheat code" that wins the battle too easily. In the book, the ghosts don't actually fight at Minas Tirith. They just help Aragorn capture the ships of the Corsairs of Umbar. Jackson changed this for the movie to make the payoff more visual, but it remains one of the more controversial "lore" changes.
Aragorn didn't want to be King: In the movies, Aragorn is a "reluctant hero." He’s afraid of the weakness of his ancestors. In Tolkien's writing, Aragorn is much more certain of his destiny. He carries the shards of Narsil from the very beginning. Jackson made him more "human" for the screen, which honestly works better for a movie arc, even if it bothers the purists.
👉 See also: A Simple Favor Blake Lively: Why Emily Nelson Is Still the Ultimate Screen Mystery
Denethor was just a "crazy" old man: The film portrays the Steward of Gondor as a complete madman. While he definitely lost it at the end, the books explain why. He had a Palantír (a seeing stone) and was essentially having a mental wrestling match with Sauron every night. Sauron showed him only the images that would cause him despair. He wasn't just mean; he was manipulated.
The Legacy of the King
Why are we still talking about this? Because they don't make them like this anymore. In an era of "content" and interconnected universes that never seem to end, The Lord of the Rings 3 represents the finale of a coherent, planned, and passionately executed vision.
It proved that fantasy could be "serious." Without this movie, we don't get Game of Thrones. We don't get the massive budget for Dune. It set the bar for "Epic" so high that most films are still struggling to reach it.
The film's success wasn't just about the box office (though it was only the second movie ever to gross over $1 billion). It was about the fact that a story about friendship, sacrifice, and the corrupting nature of power could resonate across every culture on Earth.
If you're planning a rewatch or introducing someone to Middle-earth for the first time, keep an eye on the smaller moments. The look on Pippin’s face when he sings for Denethor. The way Sam carries Frodo up the slopes of Mount Doom. The technical stuff is cool, but the heart is what makes it a masterpiece.
Actionable Insights for Fans and Viewers
- Watch the Extended Edition: If you've only seen the theatrical cut, you're missing roughly 50 minutes of footage. This includes the fate of Saruman and the "Mouth of Sauron" scene, which are crucial for the plot.
- Listen to the Commentary: The DVD/Blu-ray commentaries with the cast are legendary. You’ll learn more about filmmaking from Dominic Monaghan and Billy Boyd than you will from most film schools.
- Check the Background: Many of the Orcs in the Pelennor Fields battle are actually fans of the series who showed up for a "casting call" and brought their own costumes. See if you can spot the ones that look a little too enthusiastic.
- Visit the Locations: If you ever find yourself in New Zealand, many of the filming locations for the third film, like the Putangirua Pinnacles (The Dimholt Road), are accessible to the public and look exactly like they do in the movie.
- Read the Appendices: If you want the "real" ending, read the appendices at the back of the Return of the King novel. It tells you what happened to every member of the Fellowship until the day they died. It’s heavy, but it’s the ultimate closure.
The journey doesn't have to end just because the credits roll. There is a depth to this world that rewards every bit of attention you give it. This movie wasn't just a peak for the early 2000s; it remains the gold standard for what a blockbuster can and should be.