The Red and the Black: Why Stendhal’s Julien Sorel Still Annoys and Fascinates Us

The Red and the Black: Why Stendhal’s Julien Sorel Still Annoys and Fascinates Us

If you’ve ever felt like a total fraud while trying to climb the social ladder, you’ve basically lived a page out of The Red and the Black. It’s a 19th-century French novel. Sounds dry? Honestly, it’s the opposite. Marie-Henri Beyle, who wrote under the pen name Stendhal, published this thing in 1830, and it’s essentially the original "hustle culture" manifesto, except it ends in a literal execution.

Julien Sorel is our guy. He’s a carpenter's son with high cheekbones and a photographic memory for Latin Bible verses. He hates his family. He hates his class. Most of all, he hates the fact that he missed out on the Napoleonic era, where a nobody could become a general through sheer grit. Instead, he’s stuck in the Restoration, a time of stifling boredom and rigid social hierarchies where you either wear the "Red" (the military) or the "Black" (the clergy). Since the army isn't an option for a poor kid anymore, he chooses the black robe. Not because he loves God. He just wants power.

Why The Red and the Black is the Ultimate Social Satire

Stendhal wasn't just writing a story; he was taking a scalpel to French society. The book is subtitled Chronique de 1830, and it’s a terrifyingly accurate snapshot of a country in transition. People often get bogged down in the politics of the Bourbons and the Liberals, but the core of the book is psychological. It’s about ambition.

Julien is a "dark horse." He’s smart, but he’s also incredibly prickly and sensitive. When he becomes a tutor for the Mayor of Verrières, M. de Rênal, he doesn't just want a salary. He wants to conquer. He sees seducing the Mayor’s wife, Madame de Rênal, as a duty to his pride. It’s almost painful to read. He’s so focused on "playing the game" that he often misses out on actual happiness. This is the "Stendhalian" hero in a nutshell: someone who is constantly watching themselves live, rather than just living.

Think about how we use social media today. We curate. We perform. Julien Sorel was performing for an audience of aristocrats he secretly despised. He memorized texts just to shock them. He wore the black cassock like a costume. If he had a TikTok in 1830, he’d be the guy posting cryptic "success" quotes while secretly living in a cramped attic.

The Psychology of the "Happy Few"

Stendhal famously dedicated his books to "The Happy Few." He knew he wouldn't be popular in his own time. He was right. People found his style too clinical, too detached. But that’s exactly why it works now. He doesn't tell you how to feel. He shows you the gears turning in Julien's head.

📖 Related: Kiko Japanese Restaurant Plantation: Why This Local Spot Still Wins the Sushi Game

There’s this famous scene where Julien is sitting in the dark with Madame de Rênal, and he decides he must hold her hand by the time the clock strikes ten. It’s not romantic. It’s a tactical maneuver. He’s sweating. He’s terrified. When he finally does it, he doesn't feel love; he feels a sense of "duty accomplished." It’s bizarre. It’s deeply human. We’ve all been there—setting weird internal goals just to prove we can do something, even if we’re not sure we even want the prize.

Mathilde de la Mole and the Boredom of the Elite

The second half of the book shifts to Paris. Julien gets a job working for the Marquis de la Mole, a high-ranking aristocrat. This is where he meets Mathilde. If Madame de Rênal represented soft, maternal, sincere love, Mathilde is the exact opposite. She’s bored. She’s brilliant. She’s obsessed with her ancestors who got their heads chopped off during the wars of religion.

Mathilde falls for Julien specifically because he’s "dangerous" and "low-born." It’s a twisted power dynamic. They spend the whole time trying to out-manipulate each other. It’s the original "toxic relationship." She wants a hero from a history book; he wants a title that makes people forget his father was a carpenter.

What Stendhal captures so well here is the emptiness of the elite. Everyone in the Parisian salons is terrified of saying something "inappropriate" or "boring." They live in a gilded cage of etiquette. Julien, with his raw intensity and secret Napoleonic worship, is like a grenade thrown into a tea party.

The Trial and the Final Choice

Everything falls apart when a letter from Madame de Rênal (sent under duress from her confessor) exposes Julien as a social climber. In a fit of rage, Julien goes back to his hometown, enters a church, and shoots her. She survives, but Julien’s fate is sealed.

👉 See also: Green Emerald Day Massage: Why Your Body Actually Needs This Specific Therapy

The ending is where The Red and the Black becomes truly profound. In prison, Julien finally stops performing. He refuses to appeal his death sentence. For the first time, he’s actually happy. He realizes that the "Black" and the "Red"—the careerism, the titles, the social maneuvering—were all a waste of time. He realizes he actually loved Madame de Rênal, the only person who saw him as a human being rather than a tool or a trophy.

He dies on the guillotine. Mathilde, ever the drama queen, takes his severed head and buries it herself, mimicking a family legend. It’s a grisly, over-the-top ending that reminds us that while Julien found peace, the society around him is still stuck in its macabre, performative loops.

Historical Accuracy and Stendhal's Real-Life Inspiration

A lot of people think Julien Sorel is entirely fictional. He’s not. Stendhal based the story on a real court case he read about in Gazette des Tribunaux.

In 1827, a young man named Antoine Berthet was tried for attempting to murder his former lover in a church. Berthet was a blacksmith's son, a former seminary student, and a tutor who had climbed into the beds of his employers' wives. The parallels are almost 1:1. Stendhal took a tabloid scandal and turned it into a psychological masterpiece.

He didn't want to write a "pretty" book. He wanted to write a "true" one. He famously said he used the Code Civil (the French legal code) as a stylistic model to keep his writing dry and precise. He hated the flowery, emotional prose of his contemporaries like Chateaubriand. He wanted the facts of the human heart, laid bare like an autopsy.

✨ Don't miss: The Recipe Marble Pound Cake Secrets Professional Bakers Don't Usually Share

What You Can Learn from Julien Sorel’s Failures

It’s easy to look at The Red and the Black as just another classic on a dusty shelf. But if you look closer, it’s a warning.

First, impostor syndrome is eternal. Julien spent his life feeling like he didn't belong. Instead of finding a place where he did belong, he tried to conquer a place that hated him. That’s a recipe for burnout—or in his case, the guillotine.

Second, the "grind" can blind you. Julien was so focused on the next promotion, the next conquest, and the next social tier that he ignored his own emotions until he was literally in a jail cell. He mistook "achievement" for "living."

Third, authenticity is a luxury. In 1830, Julien couldn't be himself because his "self" had no legal standing. Today, we have more freedom, but we often trap ourselves in the same mental prisons of status and perception.

Actionable Steps for Navigating Modern Ambition

Reading The Red and the Black should make you uncomfortable. If it doesn't, you aren't paying attention. To avoid the Julien Sorel trap in the 21st century, try these shifts:

  • Audit your "Why": Are you chasing a goal because you want it, or because you want the status that comes with it? Julien wanted the black robe only because it was a ladder. He hated the church itself.
  • Identify your "Audience": Who are you performing for? If you’re making decisions based on what a "Marquis" (or a CEO or a follower count) thinks, you’re losing your autonomy.
  • Value Sincerity Over Strategy: Julien’s moments of genuine connection with Madame de Rênal were the only times he was actually happy. Don't sacrifice real relationships for "networking" opportunities.
  • Read the Room (Literally): Stendhal’s characters are masters of observation. Learn to see the power dynamics in your own life without becoming a slave to them. Use that knowledge to protect yourself, not just to manipulate others.

The Red and the Black isn't just a book about a guy who gets his head cut off. It’s a mirror. When you look into it, you might see a bit of Julien Sorel looking back. The goal is to recognize him before you reach the final chapter.