Hollywood loves a good "based on a true story" tag. It sells tickets. It makes you check under the bed. But when it comes to the conjuring based on a real story, the line between 1970s paranormal investigation and cinematic flair is basically a mile wide. You've seen the movie. You remember the clapping game and the terrifying cellar. But the Perron family lived in that Rhode Island farmhouse for a decade, not just a few weeks of jump-scares.
It wasn't a clean, three-act narrative. It was messy.
The real Perron family—Roger, Carolyn, and their five daughters—moved into the Arnold Estate in Harrisville in 1971. They knew the house had some "character," but they didn't know the local legends. They didn't know about the generations of deaths associated with the property. Almost immediately, things got weird. It started with small stuff. Piles of dirt appearing on a freshly swept floor. Spirits that seemed more like curious ghosts than demons. But then, as Andrea Perron, the eldest daughter, has detailed in her extensive writings, the energy shifted. It got dark.
The Reality of Bathsheba Sherman
In the film, Bathsheba is a terrifying, stringy-haired entity hanging from a tree. In history? She was a real person. Bathsheba Sherman lived in the 1800s and, honestly, her reputation took a massive beating after she died.
The legends say she was a practicing Satanist who sacrificed a baby. There was even a court case. She was charged with the death of an infant in her care, but she was acquitted due to a lack of evidence. People in town still whispered. They called her a witch. But if you look at the historical record, Bathsheba died of old age, not by her own hand in a dramatic display of demonic devotion. Ed and Lorraine Warren, the famous paranormal investigators, were the ones who pegged her as the "villain" of the house.
🔗 Read more: Did Mac Miller Like Donald Trump? What Really Happened Between the Rapper and the President
Whether she was actually haunting the Perrons is a point of massive debate. The family felt a presence that was jealous and hateful toward Carolyn, the mother. This entity apparently wanted Carolyn gone so it could have Roger and the girls. It’s a classic haunting trope, but for the Perrons, it felt like a daily psychological war.
What the Warrens Found (and What They Didn't)
Ed and Lorraine Warren are household names now, thanks to the franchise. Back in the 70s, they were polarizing figures. Some saw them as selfless protectors; others thought they were brilliant self-promoters. When they arrived at the Perron house, they didn't bring a camera crew. They brought a sense of dread.
Lorraine, a self-proclaimed clairvoyant, felt the presence of something malevolent immediately. She didn't need a cold spot to tell her that.
The movie shows a dramatic exorcism in the basement. That never happened. In fact, the Warrens never performed an exorcism at the Harrisville house. They conducted a séance. It went horribly wrong. According to Andrea Perron, she was hidden in a corner watching her mother. She claims her mother became possessed, speaking in a language not of this world and being thrown across the room in her chair. Roger Perron, terrified for his wife’s life, eventually kicked the Warrens out. He thought their presence was making the spirits more aggressive.
💡 You might also like: Despicable Me 2 Edith: Why the Middle Child is Secretly the Best Part of the Movie
Imagine that. You call for help, things get worse, and you have to tell the "experts" to hit the road.
Living with the Haunted
Most people ask: "Why didn't they just leave?"
Money. It’s always money. The Perrons weren't wealthy. They had sunk everything into this farm. They stayed for ten years. You read that right. Ten years of living with spirits they named based on their personalities. Some were "sweet," like the spirit that used to tuck the girls in at night or smell like flowers. Others were "the grey lady."
It wasn’t a constant barrage of terror. It was a slow burn of normalized abnormality. You get used to the floorboards creaking. You get used to the doors opening. You don't get used to your mother being levitated or the smell of rotting flesh in the hallway. That's the part of the conjuring based on a real story that usually gets lost in the Hollywood polish. The sheer endurance required to live in a "house of darkness" because you literally have nowhere else to go.
📖 Related: Death Wish II: Why This Sleazy Sequel Still Triggers People Today
Fact-Checking the Scares
- The Clock: In the movie, all the clocks stop at 3:07 AM. This is a classic horror trope (the Mockery of the Trinity). While the family reported weird mechanical issues, the synchronized clock-stopping was largely a cinematic invention.
- The Cellar: The real house did have a creepy basement, but the whole "hidden room" aspect was beefed up for the screen.
- The Annabelle Doll: Annabelle had nothing to do with the Perron case. The real doll is a Raggedy Ann, not the terrifying porcelain figure from the film. The Warrens kept it in their museum, but it's a completely different investigation.
- The Dog: In the movie, the family dog, Sadie, refuses to enter the house and meets a grim end. In reality, the family did have pets, and while animals are often sensitive to "vibes," the dramatic death of the dog was added for emotional stakes.
The Long-Term Impact
The Perrons finally left in 1980. They moved to Georgia. You’d think they’d want to forget the whole thing, but Andrea Perron spent years writing a three-volume memoir titled House of Darkness House of Light. She wanted to set the record straight because she felt the movie, while good, missed the spiritual nuance of their experience.
She doesn't hate the spirits. She views them as part of her history.
The house still stands. It’s become a destination for paranormal investigators and fans of the franchise. The current owners have reported their own share of activity, though nothing quite as explosive as the séance of 1974. It seems the "energy" of the Arnold Estate is baked into the soil.
Actionable Insights for the Curious
If you're fascinated by the history behind the film, don't just stop at the credits. There's a lot of ground to cover if you want to understand the 1970s paranormal boom.
- Read the primary source: Andrea Perron’s House of Darkness House of Light is a dense, deeply personal account. It’s less "horror movie" and more "familial trauma and spiritual exploration."
- Research the Arnold Estate: Look into the land records of Harrisville, Rhode Island. The history of the property involves several suicides and accidental deaths over two centuries, which provides more context than a "witch's curse" ever could.
- Evaluate the Warrens critically: Look into the work of skeptical investigators like Joe Nickell or the late James Randi. They provide a necessary counter-balance to the supernatural claims, looking for environmental factors like infrasound or carbon monoxide that can cause hallucinations.
- Visit the location responsibly: If you decide to go to Rhode Island, remember that the house is often private property or a ticketed venue. Respect the owners and the neighbors. Don't be that person trespassing at 3 AM with a flashlight.
The Perron case remains one of the most documented hauntings in American history. Whether you believe in demons or just think it was a case of mass hysteria fueled by a drafty old house, the story of what happened in that farmhouse continues to fascinate because it taps into a universal fear: that the places where we should feel safest are the places where we are most vulnerable.