Hollywood loves a good "based on a true story" tag. It sells tickets. It makes you check under the bed. But when it comes to the real story of the Conjuring, the distance between a James Wan jump-scare and what actually happened in a drafty Rhode Island farmhouse in the 1970s is pretty vast.
It was 1971. Roger and Carolyn Perron moved their five daughters—Andrea, Nancy, Christine, Cindy, and April—into the Old Arnold Estate in Harrisville. They thought they were buying a dream home. Instead, they walked into a decade-long nightmare that would eventually make Ed and Lorraine Warren famous. Honestly, if you ask the eldest daughter, Andrea Perron, the movie barely scratched the surface of the psychological toll.
The house had eight and a half acres. It had history. It also had a lot of death.
The Perron Family and the House of Darkness
The Perrons weren't looking for ghosts. They were a normal family. But almost immediately, things got weird. It started small. A broom would go missing. Dirt would appear on a freshly mopped floor. Then, the smells started—the stench of rotting flesh wafting through the halls.
You’ve probably seen the movie's depiction of Bathsheba Sherman as a screeching, taloned witch. The reality is more complicated, and perhaps more tragic. Local legends claimed Bathsheba was a mid-19th-century woman who lived on the neighboring farm. Rumors whispered she was a satanist who killed a child with a knitting needle. However, historical records don't really back that up. Public records show a woman named Bathsheba Sherman lived and died in the area, but there’s no evidence she was a murderer.
Still, the Perrons were convinced something was there.
📖 Related: Why American Beauty by the Grateful Dead is Still the Gold Standard of Americana
Andrea Perron has spent years writing about this. She wrote a massive three-volume series called House of Darkness House of Light. In her account, the spirits weren't just one "boss" ghost. There were many. Some were harmless, even protective. Others were malevolent. There was a spirit they called "Manny" who would watch the kids. Then there was the entity that supposedly possessed Carolyn.
Did Ed and Lorraine Warren Actually Help?
This is where things get controversial. In the film, the Warrens are the heroes who swoop in and save the day with an unsanctioned exorcism. In the real story of the Conjuring, their arrival might have actually made things worse.
The Warrens were already becoming "celebrity" paranormal investigators by the time they reached Harrisville in 1973. They weren't invited by the church; they were called in by a local paranormal group. When they arrived, they didn't perform a cinematic exorcism in the basement. Instead, they conducted a séance.
Roger Perron was skeptical. He didn't like the Warrens. According to family accounts, during the séance, Carolyn Perron began to speak in a language not her own and was thrown across the room in her chair. Roger was so horrified and angry that he supposedly punched Ed Warren and kicked the investigators out of the house.
He felt they had opened a door they couldn't close.
👉 See also: Why October London Make Me Wanna Is the Soul Revival We Actually Needed
The family didn't leave after the Warrens left. They couldn't. They were broke. They stayed in that house until 1980. Think about that for a second. Ten years of living with whatever was in those walls. That’s the part the movie misses—the sheer, grinding exhaustion of living in fear because you have no financial exit strategy.
Separating Legend from Fact
We have to talk about the "witch" Bathsheba.
Skeptics, including investigators like Joe Nickell, point out that the lore surrounding Bathsheba Sherman is largely folklore. There’s no court record of a murder trial. She was a real person buried in a local cemetery, but the "satanist" label likely came from local gossip that the Warrens and the Perrons leaned into.
Here are some specific details from the real case that differ from the film:
- The Ending: In the movie, the demon is cast out and the family is happy. In real life, the Perrons just lived with the hauntings for years until they could afford to move to Georgia.
- The Deaths: The movie implies a string of horrific suicides on the property. While deaths did occur over the centuries (including a drowning and a few natural deaths), the "curse" narrative was heavily amplified for the script.
- The Physical Violence: The Perrons claim they were physically assaulted by unseen forces, but it wasn't a constant battle for their souls like a superhero movie. It was sporadic, terrifying, and deeply personal.
Is the house still haunted? The current owners, and the ones before them, have had varying experiences. Some say it's quiet. Others have turned it into a paranormal tourism destination. You can actually book a stay there now.
✨ Don't miss: How to Watch The Wolf and the Lion Without Getting Lost in the Wild
The Psychological Impact of the Harrisville Haunting
Why does this story stick with us? It’s not just the jumpscares. It’s the idea of the home—the one place you should be safe—becoming a predator.
The Perron girls are all grown up now. They don't back down from their stories. They don't care if people call them crazy. When you listen to Andrea Perron speak, she doesn't sound like a con artist. She sounds like someone who is still processing a childhood trauma that happens to involve the supernatural.
Whether you believe in ghosts or not, the "real" story is a study in how a family survives under extreme pressure. The Warrens, for better or worse, codified the haunting into a narrative of good vs. evil. But for the Perrons, it was just their life.
How to Evaluate Paranormal Claims
If you're looking into the history of famous hauntings, you've got to be a bit of a detective. Don't just take the movie's word for it.
- Check Property Records: Most "cursed" houses have mundane histories. Look for actual death certificates, not just local campfire stories.
- Look for Multiple Perspectives: The Warrens were known for embellishing. Read the family's books and then read the skeptical rebuttals. The truth is usually somewhere in the middle.
- Understand the Context: The 1970s were a boom time for the "Satanic Panic" and interest in the occult. This cultural backdrop influenced how people interpreted strange noises in their old houses.
The real story of the Conjuring isn't a 100-minute thriller. It’s a decade-long saga of a family trapped in a house they didn't understand, dealing with investigators they didn't entirely trust. It’s messier than Hollywood, and in many ways, much sadder.
Next Steps for Research
To get the full picture beyond the screen, look into the following resources:
- Read House of Darkness House of Light by Andrea Perron for the most detailed family perspective.
- Research the work of Tony Spera, the Warrens' son-in-law, who maintains their archives.
- Compare the Perron case to the Enfield Poltergeist (the basis for the sequel) to see the "Warren pattern" of investigation.
By looking at the primary accounts and the historical skepticism side-by-side, you'll find a story that is less about demons and more about the enduring power of family—and the mysteries that old houses keep.