Politics in San Francisco isn't just a job; it's a full-contact sport played in a fishbowl. London Breed knows this better than anyone. For years, she was the face of a city that became a global punching bag for everything from the "fentanyl crisis" to the "doom loop." People love to talk about her. They love to blame her. But honestly, if you actually look at the trajectory of San Francisco Mayor London Breed, the reality is way more complicated than a simple "success" or "failure" narrative you see on cable news.
She grew up in Plaza East public housing in the Western Addition. That matters. It’s not just a talking point; it’s the core of her identity. Imagine being raised by your grandmother in a neighborhood where the sirens never stopped, then eventually running the entire city from a massive wood-paneled office in City Hall. That’s a wild arc. It gave her a certain kind of toughness—a "city kid" vibe—that defined her tenure. She wasn't some ivory tower academic. She was someone who actually understood what it meant to struggle in a city that was becoming impossibly expensive for the people who grew up there.
The COVID-19 Pivot That Changed Everything
When the pandemic hit in early 2020, Breed didn't hesitate. She was the first mayor in the United States to issue a formal stay-at-home order. That was a massive gamble. Economically, it was terrifying. But the data from the San Francisco Department of Public Health shows it saved thousands of lives. The city’s death rate remained among the lowest of any major American metro area for a long time.
She leaned hard into the science. She listened to experts like Dr. Grant Colfax. For a while, she was the darling of the national media—the decisive leader who took charge while others wavered. But that political capital started to burn off pretty fast as the lockdowns dragged on and the economic fallout hit the Tenderloin and South of Market areas.
Then came the French Laundry incident.
It was a huge mistake. Dining at an incredibly expensive, three-Michelin-star restaurant in Napa while the city was under strict restrictions looked terrible. It felt hypocritical. Even though it was technically "outdoors" and met the letter of the law at the time, the optics were a disaster. It became the first real crack in her armor, and her critics never let her forget it.
✨ Don't miss: The CIA Stars on the Wall: What the Memorial Really Represents
The Housing Battle and the "YIMBY" Transformation
If you want to understand San Francisco Mayor London Breed, you have to understand her relationship with housing. For decades, the city has been paralyzed by "NIMBY" (Not In My Backyard) politics. People who owned their homes didn't want anything new built. Breed flipped the script. She became the champion of the "YIMBY" movement.
She pushed for denser zoning. She fought the Board of Supervisors—which is basically a daily cage match in SF—to make it easier to build. She famously supported "Cars to Campuses" and tried to streamline the glacial permitting process.
- She pushed for more modular housing.
- This was about speed.
- It was about cutting costs.
- It didn't always work as fast as people wanted, but it was a start.
Building stuff in SF is a nightmare. You've got shadow studies, historical preservationists, and a million neighborhood groups that can sue to stop a project. Breed tried to bulldoze through that. Did she solve the housing crisis? No. Prices are still astronomical. But she fundamentally shifted the conversation toward "we need to build more," which was a huge departure from the city’s previous stance of "let’s study this for ten years."
Public Safety and the Tenderloin Emergency
The most controversial part of her legacy is definitely the Tenderloin. In late 2021, she declared a state of emergency there. Her rhetoric shifted. She talked about "the end of the reign of criminals" and called for more aggressive policing to stop open-air drug dealing. This was a massive pivot for a progressive mayor in a progressive city.
Left-leaning activists felt betrayed. They argued that her approach was a return to the failed "War on Drugs." Meanwhile, business owners and residents were screaming for order. The fentanyl crisis was—and is—truly horrific. Walking down Turk or Eddy Street, you see things that look like a dystopian movie. Breed was caught in the middle. She tried to balance "harm reduction" (like the Tenderloin Linkage Center) with increased arrests. Honestly, it was a mess. The Linkage Center closed after less than a year, leaving a lot of people wondering what the actual plan was.
🔗 Read more: Passive Resistance Explained: Why It Is Way More Than Just Standing Still
The 2024 Shift and the Election Reality
By the time the 2024 election rolled around, the vibe in the city had soured. People were frustrated with the "doom loop" narrative—the idea that downtown was dead because of remote work and retail theft. Big names like Nordstrom and Whole Foods were closing doors.
Breed tried to fight back. She launched initiatives to revitalize Union Square and tried to lure biotech companies into empty office towers. She even suggested turning empty malls into soccer stadiums. It was creative, sure, but it felt a bit like "too little, too late" for a lot of voters.
Her opponents—Daniel Lurie, Mark Farrell, and Aaron Peskin—each attacked her from different angles. Farrell and Lurie went after her on crime and homelessness. Peskin, the progressive veteran, attacked her from the left. It was a brutal campaign. In the end, the voters wanted change. The "incumbency fatigue" was real. San Franciscans were tired of seeing the same problems on their doorsteps every morning.
Lessons From the Breed Era
Looking back, London Breed’s time in office was defined by two massive, unforeseen crises: a global pandemic and a fentanyl epidemic. No mayor is ever really prepared for that. She was a leader who wasn't afraid to be loud, wasn't afraid to fight, and wasn't afraid to change her mind—even if that made her look inconsistent to some.
She proved that a kid from the projects could run one of the most powerful cities in the world. That’s a win for representation, regardless of what you think of her policies. But she also proved that in a city with a $14 billion budget, money doesn't solve everything. You need bureaucracy that works. You need a Board of Supervisors that isn't constantly at war with the Mayor’s office. You need more than just "vibe shifts."
💡 You might also like: What Really Happened With the Women's Orchestra of Auschwitz
What We Can Learn from the Breed Years
- Housing is the root of all evil (politically): Until the supply-demand imbalance is fixed, every other problem in SF—homelessness, retail flight, worker shortages—will keep getting worse. Breed was right to focus on it, but the "city process" is a beast that’s hard to tame.
- Optics are everything: You can save a thousand lives with a health order, but if you're seen at a fancy dinner while your citizens are stuck at home, that's what people remember.
- The "Middle Way" is lonely: By trying to be tough on crime while maintaining social safety nets, she often ended up with no allies. The far-left hated her for the police sweeps; the right hated her for not doing enough.
The Realities of Modern San Francisco
If you're looking at the city today, it’s not the wasteland that some news outlets portray. The AI boom is bringing a ton of new energy to SOMA. Neighborhoods like the Richmond and the Sunset are thriving. But the core issues of inequality and addiction haven't gone away.
Breed’s departure doesn't magically fix the Tenderloin. It doesn't instantly make rent $2,000 for a two-bedroom. It just passes the baton to someone else who has to deal with the same structural nightmares.
Actionable Insights for Following SF Politics
If you want to actually understand what's happening in San Francisco post-Breed, don't just read the headlines. Look at the data.
- Track the "Housing Element": California state law now requires SF to plan for 82,000 new units by 2031. Watch how the city council handles this. That’s the real battlefield.
- Follow the Controller’s Reports: San Francisco’s Controller’s Office puts out incredibly detailed reports on city spending and performance. It's the best way to see if the money is actually doing anything.
- Watch the "AI Gold Rush": See if the new administration can actually convert tech interest into tax revenue and foot traffic downtown.
- Local Journalism Matters: Read the San Francisco Chronicle or Mission Local. They cover the granular, boring stuff—like committee meetings—where the real power is exercised.
The Breed era is over, but the questions she grappled with are still the most important ones in urban America. How do you keep a city safe without being cruel? How do you grow without pushing out the people who make the city worth living in? There are no easy answers, just a lot of hard work.
The next few years will show if the changes she started—especially on the housing front—actually bear fruit, or if the city just keeps spinning its wheels in the same old ruts.