Music is basically a giant game of telephone. You hear a melody, you hum it, and eventually, someone else records it with a fuzzier guitar or a slower tempo. That’s the simplest definition of a cover, but honestly, the legal and cultural layers underneath are way messier than most people realize.
It isn't just "doing someone else's song."
If you go to a karaoke bar and belt out "I Will Always Love You," you’re performing a cover, sure. But in the industry sense, a cover is a new commercial recording or performance of a song that was previously released by another artist. It’s about the composition—the lyrics and the melody—staying the same while the recording—the "master"—is brand new.
The Legal Nut You Have to Crack
Most people think you need a signed permission slip from Taylor Swift or Mick Jagger to cover their music. You don't. That’s the wild part about US copyright law. Thanks to something called a "compulsory license," once a song has been publicly released, anyone can record their own version of it as long as they pay the statutory royalty rate.
Currently, that’s usually around 12.4 cents per physical copy or permanent download.
Streaming makes it even more granular. You’re looking at fractions of a penny. But the point is, the original songwriter can't actually tell you "no" unless you’re changing the fundamental structure of the song. If you want to change the lyrics or the melody significantly, you’re no longer in "cover" territory. Now you’re making a "derivative work." That requires a specific contract. It’s why Weird Al Yankovic always asks for permission even though he technically might not have to for a parody—he wants to stay on the right side of the creators.
A Definition of a Cover vs. The Original
There is a weird psychological thing that happens with covers. We tend to think the version we heard first is the "real" one. Take "Tainted Love." Most Gen Xers and Millennials would swear on a stack of Bibles that Soft Cell owns that song. Nope. It was originally recorded by Gloria Jones in 1964. It was a Northern Soul flop before it became an 80s synth-pop anthem.
The definition of a cover often gets blurred when the new version becomes the definitive one.
🔗 Read more: Blink-182 Mark Hoppus: What Most People Get Wrong About His 2026 Comeback
- Cyndi Lauper’s "Girls Just Want to Have Fun": Originally by Robert Hazard. He wrote it from a guy’s perspective about, well, girls wanting to have fun. Lauper flipped the script, changed the "vibe," and turned it into a feminist anthem.
- Respect: Aretha Franklin didn't write it. Otis Redding did. He wrote it as a man coming home demanding respect from his wife. Aretha added the "R-E-S-P-E-C-T" and the "sock it to me" backup vocals. She essentially stole the song's soul and kept it.
- Hurt: Johnny Cash. Trent Reznor of Nine Inch Nails famously said that after he saw Cash’s music video, the song didn't belong to him anymore.
It’s about ownership of the moment, not the paper.
Why Do Artists Even Bother?
Labels love covers. They’re safe. They’re "pre-sold" to the audience. If people loved "Fast Car" in 1988, there’s a high statistical probability they’ll dig a country version in 2023. Luke Combs proved that. But for the artist, a cover is often a bridge. It’s a way to show your influences without having to write a masterpiece from scratch during a sophomore slump.
Sometimes, it’s just about the craft.
Think about jazz. The entire genre is built on the definition of a cover. They call them "standards." If you’re a jazz trumpeter, you play "Autumn Leaves." You aren't trying to replace the original; you’re trying to see what you can find inside the notes that nobody else found yet. It’s an exploration.
The YouTube and TikTok Era Shift
The internet changed the "definition of a cover" from a professional milestone to a daily commodity. Back in the day, you needed a studio. Now, you need a ring light and a smartphone. This has created a "Cover-to-Cloud" pipeline.
Artists like Justin Bieber or Shawn Mendes didn't start with original hits. They started by fulfilling the search intent of people looking for their favorite songs. If you search for a Top 40 hit, and a talented kid is singing it in their bedroom, you might click. That’s the modern discovery engine.
But there’s a dark side.
💡 You might also like: Why Grand Funk’s Bad Time is Secretly the Best Pop Song of the 1970s
Content ID systems on YouTube are aggressive. If you upload a cover, the automated bots will catch the melody and redirect the ad revenue to the publisher. You get the views, but they get the money. It’s a fair trade for many, but it’s a shock to newcomers who think they’re going to get rich off a Harry Styles tribute.
The "Tribute" vs. The "Reimagining"
There are two ways to approach the definition of a cover.
First, the Tribute. This is when a wedding band plays "Don't Stop Believin'" exactly like Journey. The goal is mimesis. You want the audience to feel the nostalgia of the original.
Second, the Reimagining. This is where the real art happens. Think of Joe Cocker doing "With a Little Help from My Friends." He slowed it down, added a gospel grit, and made it sound like a desperate plea for survival rather than a catchy Beatles ditty. If you aren't bringing something new—a new tempo, a different gender perspective, a genre flip—you’re basically just doing high-end karaoke.
Common Misconceptions About Covers
"I can't make money off a cover." You can. You just have to share. Services like DistroKid or TuneCore have systems built-in where you check a box saying "this is a cover," they take a small annual fee, and they handle the royalties. You keep the rest of your mechanicals.
"If I change the lyrics, it’s still a cover." Strictly speaking, no. That’s a derivative work. If you change "Friday I'm in Love" to "Friday I'm in Debt," The Cure’s publishers can sue you into oblivion or, more likely, just take the video down.
"Covers are for people who can't write." Tell that to Jimi Hendrix. His version of "All Along the Watchtower" is so good that Bob Dylan eventually started playing it Jimi’s way.
📖 Related: Why La Mera Mera Radio is Actually Dominating Local Airwaves Right Now
Technical Insights for Musicians
If you’re planning on releasing a cover, you need to understand the Mechanical License. This is what allows you to distribute the audio.
However, if you want to put that cover in a YouTube video, you technically need a Sync License (synchronization). This is where things get murky. Most publishers allow covers on YouTube because of the revenue-share agreements mentioned earlier. But if you want to put your cover of a song in an indie film or a commercial? You better have a deep pocket and a good lawyer. You have to negotiate that directly with the publisher. There is no "compulsory" rule for film. They can absolutely say no.
How to Make a Cover "Work"
Don't be boring.
If you're a heavy metal band, don't cover a Metallica song. Cover a Dolly Parton song. The friction between the original genre and your style is where the magic (and the virality) lives. The definition of a cover is ultimately an act of translation. You are translating someone else’s emotions into your own musical language.
Specific steps to take if you’re recording one:
- Identify the Publisher: Look up the song on ASCAP or BMI databases to see who owns the rights.
- Secure a Mechanical License: Use a service like Harry Fox Agency or your distributor.
- Find the "Hook": What part of the song are you going to change? The rhythm? The key? The instrumentation?
- Credit the Original: Always. Not just for legal reasons, but for respect.
Music is a lineage. When you record a cover, you’re stepping into a timeline that stretches back decades. You’re adding your voice to a conversation that started long before you and will keep going long after.
Actionable Next Steps
If you’re an artist looking to leverage covers for growth, start by identifying "adjacent" songs. Find tracks that fit your vocal range but sit outside your genre. Use a distribution service that automates the licensing process so you don't get bogged down in paperwork. Focus on the first 10 seconds of your version; if it sounds exactly like the original, people will skip. If it sounds hauntingly different, they'll stay.
For the casual listener, next time you hear a hit, look up the writing credits. You might be surprised to find that the definition of a cover applies to more of your playlist than you ever imagined. Check the liner notes on Spotify—look for the "written by" section. It's the quickest way to see the DNA of the music you love.