You think you know what it is. A group of people living in the same neighborhood, right? Or maybe that Facebook group where everyone argues about whether a hot dog is a sandwich. Honestly, the definition of a community has been stretched so thin lately that it’s starting to lose its meaning. We use the word to describe everything from a multinational corporation’s customer base to a few hundred people who all happen to like the same brand of Swedish oatmeal. It's a mess.
Community isn't just a collection of people.
It’s a web of relationships. It’s a feeling of belonging that exists when people share a common interest, a common place, or a common identity, but—and this is the big kicker—they also have to care about each other’s well-being. If there is no mutual accountability, it’s not a community. It’s just a crowd.
Think about it this way. You can stand in a crowded elevator for ten floors. You’re all in the same place. You might even all be wearing the same brand of shoes. But unless the elevator gets stuck and you start working together to survive the next three hours, you aren’t a community. You're just a demographic.
The Four Pillars: What Sociology Actually Says
If we look at the seminal work of social psychologists David McMillan and David Chavis, they broke down the definition of a community into four distinct elements back in 1986. Their study, "Sense of Community: A Definition and Theory," is still the gold standard for understanding why some groups feel like family while others feel like a waiting room at the DMV.
First, there’s membership. This is the feeling of belonging or a sense of personal relatedness. It involves boundaries—knowing who is "in" and who is "out." That sounds a bit harsh, but without boundaries, a group has no identity. It’s why neighborhood associations have signs and why subreddits have moderators. You need to know you belong somewhere specific.
Second, you have influence. It’s a two-way street. For a group to be a community, the individual has to feel like they have some say over what happens in the group. Conversely, the group has to have some influence over the individual. If you don't feel like your voice matters, you’ll eventually check out mentally.
👉 See also: Why People That Died on Their Birthday Are More Common Than You Think
The third pillar is integration and fulfillment of needs. Basically, being part of the group has to give you something you want. This isn’t necessarily selfish. It could be as simple as the "reward" of feeling safe, or the "reward" of sharing a hobby with people who get it. If the group doesn't meet any needs, it dies.
Finally, there’s shared emotional connection. This is the "soul" of the community. It’s built on shared history, common experiences, and high-quality interactions. It’s why veterans who served together forty years ago still feel an unbreakable bond. They didn't just meet; they lived through something.
Physical vs. Digital: Does Geography Still Matter?
For most of human history, your community was whoever lived within walking distance. Geography was the only definition of a community that mattered. You shared a well, you shared a church, and you shared the risk of a bad harvest.
Then the internet happened.
Now, you can live in rural Montana and be part of a vibrant community of Japanese calligraphy enthusiasts. Some people argue these digital spaces aren't "real" communities because you can't see the people or smell the air they breathe. But tell that to the person who found a kidney donor through a gaming forum. Or the person who came out to their online friends before they told their own parents.
Digital communities rely heavily on shared interest rather than shared space. However, they often struggle with the "influence" and "accountability" parts of the definition. It is very easy to "ghost" an online group when things get uncomfortable. In a physical village, you can't just delete your account; you have to see those people at the grocery store the next day. That friction is actually what makes traditional communities so resilient—you're forced to resolve conflict.
✨ Don't miss: Marie Kondo The Life Changing Magic of Tidying Up: What Most People Get Wrong
The Problem with "Community" as a Marketing Term
Lately, every brand on earth wants to "build a community." Your bank wants a community. Your favorite toilet paper brand wants a community. They hire "Community Managers" whose entire job is to keep people talking about the product.
But let’s be real. Most of these aren't communities. They are marketing funnels disguised as social clubs.
A real definition of a community requires that the members interact with each other, not just with the brand. If everyone is just looking at the stage, it’s an audience. If they turn their chairs around to talk to each other, it’s a community. Brands that get this right—like Harley-Davidson or Lego—succeed because they facilitate member-to-member connections. They get out of the way.
Why We Are Lonelier Than Ever
Despite having a thousand "friends" on social media, global loneliness is at an all-time high. A 2023 advisory from the U.S. Surgeon General, Dr. Vivek Murthy, called it an "epidemic of loneliness and isolation."
How is that possible when we are more "connected" than ever?
It’s because we’ve confused connectivity with community. Connectivity is the tech. Community is the relationship. We have the wires, but we’re lacking the current. We’ve traded deep, inconvenient local ties for thin, convenient global ones. We’ve lost the "third places"—the cafes, libraries, and parks where people used to hang out without an appointment. When we lose those spaces, the definition of a community shrinks until it’s just the people inside our own houses.
🔗 Read more: Why Transparent Plus Size Models Are Changing How We Actually Shop
How to Actually Find or Build a Real Community
You can't just buy a community. You have to grow it, and growth takes time. It’s slow. It’s often boring.
If you want to move beyond the dictionary definition of a community and actually experience one, you have to start with proximity and frequency. You need to see the same people repeatedly in a low-stakes environment.
- Volunteer for something specific. Don't just "be a volunteer." Join the specific crew that paints the local theater sets every Tuesday night. The recurring schedule creates the bond.
- Embrace the "Third Place." Find a local spot—a coffee shop, a park, a hobby store—and go there at the same time every week. Become a regular. Recognize the other regulars.
- Lower the bar for entry. Don't wait for a formal invitation to start a community. If you want a book club, ask three people to read one chapter and meet for pizza. That’s it. That’s the seed.
- Show up when it’s hard. Community is proven during the "bad" times. If a neighbor is sick, bring the soup. If someone in your online group loses their job, help them with their resume. This is the "shared emotional connection" McMillan talked about.
The truth is, a community is a living thing. It requires maintenance. It requires you to give more than you take, at least for a while. But the payoff is the one thing humans crave more than anything else: the knowledge that if you disappeared tomorrow, someone outside your immediate family would actually notice.
Stop looking for the perfect group. Stop waiting for a community to find you.
Instead, look at the people already around you. Start there. Be the person who organizes the thing. Be the person who remembers the names. That’s how you define a community in the real world—not by what it says in a book, but by who shows up for you on a rainy Tuesday.
Actionable Steps to Strengthen Your Community Ties
- Audit your "groups." Look at your social circles. Which ones are just audiences (you watching them) and which ones are communities (you interacting with them)? Shift your energy toward the latter.
- Commit to the "Rule of Three." Try to attend the same group event three times before deciding if you like it. The first time is awkward, the second is familiar, the third is where the community starts to form.
- Identify your "Third Place." Pick one physical location outside of work and home. Visit it once a week for a month. Say hello to the staff.
- Offer a "Micro-Contribution." Community doesn't require huge gestures. It’s the small stuff. Share a helpful link, offer a ride, or simply listen without checking your phone.