The Real Belle Gibson: Why Australia Still Can't Move On

The Real Belle Gibson: Why Australia Still Can't Move On

She didn't just lie. She became a movement.

In the early 2010s, Belle Gibson was the golden girl of the Instagram wellness explosion. She was young, glowing, and allegedly terminal. According to her, she’d been given four months to live after a 2009 brain cancer diagnosis. But then, the miracle: she supposedly cured herself with nothing more than lemons, exercise, and a "clean" lifestyle. It was the ultimate digital fairytale until the floor fell out.

Honestly, the sheer scale of the deception is still hard to wrap your head around. It wasn't just a white lie to a few friends. This was a global brand.

The Empire Built on a Ghost

By 2013, her app, The Whole Pantry, was winning Apple awards. It was pre-installed on the very first Apple Watch. Think about that. One of the biggest tech companies on the planet was essentially endorsing a medical miracle that never happened. Penguin Books jumped on board too, publishing a cookbook that sat on kitchen counters across the globe, promising health through recipes while the author was secretly fine.

She wasn't fine, though. Not really.

While she was posting photos of vibrant salads, real people were dying. They were following her lead, skipping chemo because "Belle did it." That’s the part that still stings. It’s the reason the name Belle Gibson is basically a curse word in Melbourne circles today.

Where is Belle Gibson now?

Fast forward to 2026. You’d think she’d be long gone or at least living a quiet, repentant life. Not quite.

🔗 Read more: The Fifth Wheel Kim Kardashian: What Really Happened with the Netflix Comedy

As of early 2026, the real Belle Gibson is still a fixture of Australian legal frustration. The Federal Court hit her with a $410,000 fine back in 2017 for breaching consumer law. Add on years of interest and penalties, and that debt is now estimated to be well over $500,000.

Has she paid it? Nope.

Instead, we’ve seen bizarre headlines. In 2020 and 2021, authorities raided her home in Northcote. They were looking for assets to seize—anything to chip away at that massive debt. Then there was the 2020 video that went viral where she appeared to have "adopted" a new identity within Melbourne’s Ethiopian Oromia community. She was calling herself Sabontu, speaking in broken English, and claiming she’d been taken in by the community.

It was another "chapter" that felt, to many, like just another layer of performance.

The Netflix Effect: Apple Cider Vinegar

The fascination hasn't faded. It’s actually spiked recently because of the Netflix series Apple Cider Vinegar. Released in early 2025 and sweeping awards through late 2025 and into 2026, the show stars Kaitlyn Dever as a fictionalized Belle.

It’s been described as "true-ish," which is a polite way of saying the producers had to be careful with the facts because the reality is so messy. The show doesn't just focus on Belle; it looks at the victims. The people who actually had cancer. The families who watched their loved ones trade their last chance at medicine for a wellness dream.

💡 You might also like: Erik Menendez Height: What Most People Get Wrong

Why she was never jailed

This is the question everyone asks: Why isn't she in prison?

Basically, Belle Gibson was prosecuted under civil law, not criminal law. Consumer Affairs Victoria (CAV) went after her for "misleading and deceptive conduct." In the eyes of the law, she was a business owner who lied to customers. While the judge, Justice Debra Mortimer, was scathing—calling her conduct "unconscionable"—the court didn't have the power to hand down a jail sentence in that specific case.

She cried in court. She claimed she was broke.

Yet, forensic accountants found she’d spent roughly $91,000 on clothes, cosmetics, and holidays to Bali and Africa between 2017 and 2019. It’s that disconnect between her "poverty" and her lifestyle that keeps the public's blood boiling.

The Psychological Puzzle

Is she a master manipulator or is there something else going on?

Journalists Beau Donelly and Nick Toscano, who broke the story in The Age, suggested she might suffer from factitious disorder (Münchausen syndrome). Specifically, "Münchausen by Internet." It’s a condition where someone fakes illness to get attention, sympathy, and a sense of belonging.

📖 Related: Old pics of Lady Gaga: Why we’re still obsessed with Stefani Germanotta

It doesn't excuse the money. It doesn't excuse the lives lost. But it might explain why she didn't stop even when the walls were closing in.

What we can learn from the "Belle Era"

If there’s any silver lining, it’s that the rules changed. Australia’s Therapeutic Goods Advertising Code was tightened up in 2022. Now, influencers can’t just make wild health claims without massive legal risk.

Here is what you should take away if you're following the real Belle Gibson story today:

  • Audit your influencers: If someone is claiming a "cure" for a terminal illness via diet alone, run.
  • Vetting matters: The Gibson case proved that even massive corporations like Apple and Penguin can fail to fact-check when a story is "too good to check."
  • The internet never forgets: Belle’s attempts to reinvent herself as "Sabontu" were spotted within hours. In 2026, there is no such thing as a clean slate.

The debt remains. The victims' families are still waiting for justice. And the real Belle Gibson remains a cautionary tale about the dangers of the "glow-up" culture and the dark side of the digital age.

To stay informed on this case, you can monitor the official announcements from Consumer Affairs Victoria or follow the ongoing reporting from The Age and The Guardian Australia, which continue to track the enforcement of her unpaid fines. If you’re interested in the psychology behind the scam, the book The Woman Who Fooled the World remains the definitive deep-dive into the evidence gathered by the original investigative team.