You've probably been there. You just posted a killer photo or a video of your morning coffee, and it strikes you that it belongs in your "Vibes" collection forever. Knowing exactly how to add to a highlight on Instagram is one of those things that seems like it should be one click, but the app has a funny way of hiding the buttons depending on whether the post is live or buried in your archives. It’s kinda frustrating when you're just trying to keep your profile looking sharp.
Instagram Highlights are basically the "Greatest Hits" of your digital life. While regular Stories vanish into the ether after 24 hours, Highlights stay pinned right below your bio. They’re the first thing people see when they’re snooping—I mean, browsing—your profile.
🔗 Read more: Gemini AI: What Most People Get Wrong About How It Actually Works
The Live Story Method: Doing it on the Fly
If your Story is currently active and people are viewing it, adding it to a Highlight is dead simple. Just open your own Story. Look at the bottom right corner. See that little heart icon inside a circle that says "Highlight"? Tap it.
From there, a menu pops up. You can either pick an existing Highlight folder or hit the plus sign to create a brand-new one. It’s instantaneous. Honestly, this is the way most people do it because it’s top of mind. But what happens if you forgot? Or what if you want to curate a bunch of old stuff at once? That’s where things get a little more "choose your own adventure."
Digging Into the Vault: Using the Archive
Most users don't realize that Instagram keeps a massive back-catalogue of everything you’ve ever posted to your Stories, provided you haven't turned off the "Save Story to Archive" setting. To find this, head to your profile. Tap those three horizontal lines (the "hamburger" menu) in the top right. Select Archive.
Usually, it defaults to the "Stories Archive." If it shows "Posts" or "Live" archive, just tap the header to switch it back. Scroll through your history until you find that one specific memory. Tap it. Once it's open, you'll see that same "Highlight" button at the bottom. Tap, select, done.
It's basically digital scrapbooking. You can pull a photo from 2021 and drop it right into a 2026 Highlight if you really want to. Just keep in mind that Highlights appear in chronological order based on when the original Story was posted, not when you added it to the Highlight. If you add an old photo to a new Highlight, it’s going to sit at the very beginning of the reel.
Why Knowing How to Add to a Highlight on Instagram Changes Your Profile Game
Your profile is a storefront. Whether you’re a creator, a small business owner, or just someone who likes organizing their vacation photos, Highlights act as navigation tabs. If you’re a brand, you might have sections for "Shipping FAQ," "New Arrivals," and "Reviews." If you’re a regular person, maybe it’s "Puppy," "Travel," and "Cooking Fails."
Managing Highlights From the Profile Screen
There is actually a third way to do this that’s better for "bulk" editing. If you’re looking at your profile, long-press on an existing Highlight bubble. A menu will slide up. Hit Edit Highlight.
This screen is powerful. You’ll see two tabs: "Selected" and "Stories." The "Selected" tab shows what’s already in there. The "Stories" tab shows your entire Archive. You can go through and checkmark thirty different clips at once and hit "Done."
Boom.
Your Highlight is updated. This is way faster than opening each individual Story one by one. It's also where you can change your cover photo. Don't settle for the messy, zoomed-in default thumbnail. You can upload a custom icon from your camera roll here without ever having to post it to your Story first. That’s a pro tip that keeps your grid looking clean and intentional.
👉 See also: Getting an iPad 9th Generation Case with Screen Protector: What Most People Get Wrong
Common Glitches and "Why Won't It Work?"
Sometimes, the "Highlight" button just... disappears. Or you tap it and nothing happens. Usually, this is a cache issue or a weak Wi-Fi signal. Instagram is a heavy app. It eats data. If you’re in a dead zone, the Archive might not load properly.
Another weird quirk: if you delete a Story from your main feed before the 24-hour mark is up, it usually disappears from your Highlights too. You have to let it live out its full 24-hour life cycle (or stay in the Archive) for it to remain in a Highlight. If you’re the type of person who deletes things because you're shy about views but still want them on your profile later—don't. Just let it expire naturally.
The Strategy of Curation
Don’t overstuff your Highlights. Nobody is going to sit through 100 clips of a concert they weren't at. They just aren't. Limit your Highlights to the best 10-15 moments. If a Highlight gets too long, people stop clicking.
Think about the "Cover." The cover is the circular icon. Most successful accounts use a cohesive color palette or specific icons to make the profile look organized. You can create these in apps like Canva or even just use a solid color background with a single emoji in the middle. It’s simple, it’s effective, and it makes you look like you know what you’re doing.
Actionable Steps for a Better Profile
Now that you've got the technical side down, here is how to actually make those Highlights work for you:
- Audit your current circles. Go to your profile right now. Look at your Highlights. Are there old ones from three years ago that aren't relevant? Delete them. Keep the "Current" stuff front and center.
- Organize by theme, not time. Instead of "June 2025," try "Beach Days" or "Work Life." It makes it easier for new followers to find what they actually care about.
- Update your covers. If your Highlight covers are just random faces, go into the "Edit Highlight" menu and "Edit Cover." Choose a clean image from your gallery.
- Use the Archive for "Themed" drops. Every few months, go into your Archive and see if you have enough content to start a new category. Maybe you've posted a lot of recipes lately—make a "Eats" Highlight.
The beauty of Instagram is that it's fluid. Nothing is permanent unless you want it to be. Using Highlights effectively turns your fleeting moments into a curated portfolio that tells people exactly who you are the second they land on your page. It’s less about the "how" and more about the "what." Now go clean up that grid.