You probably remember the rhythm. You stood up, hand over your heart, facing a flag in a dusty classroom, and droned out the words along with thirty other kids. It’s a foundational American memory. But if you look at the history of the Pledge of Allegiance and Under God, it’s actually way more chaotic than your third-grade teacher probably let on. Most people think these words have been there since the beginning of the Republic. They haven't. Not even close.
The Pledge wasn't written by a Founding Father. It was written by a socialist minister named Francis Bellamy in 1892. He wanted something that would help unify a country still feeling the tremors of the Civil War. He didn't include "Under God." That part came much later, during a time when the United States was terrified of something else entirely: Communism.
How the Cold War changed everything
The 1950s were a weird time for American identity. The "Red Scare" was in full swing. President Dwight D. Eisenhower had just been baptized as a Presbyterian, and there was this massive push to distinguish "God-fearing Americans" from "godless Communists" in the Soviet Union. This is where the Pledge of Allegiance and Under God truly intersected.
It wasn't a grassroots movement of schoolteachers. It was a push from the Knights of Columbus, a Catholic fraternal organization. They started lobbing the idea at Congress. Eventually, after hearing a sermon by Reverend George Docherty—who basically told Eisenhower that a pledge without a reference to the Creator could just as easily be used by the Soviets—the President was sold. On Flag Day in 1954, he signed the bill into law.
Think about that for a second. For over 60 years, Americans said the Pledge without those two words.
Then, suddenly, the cadence changed.
✨ Don't miss: Green Emerald Day Massage: Why Your Body Actually Needs This Specific Therapy
The legal battles you probably forgot
If you think the controversy started recently, you’re mistaken. People have been suing over this for decades. The most famous case is probably Elk Grove Unified School District v. Newdow in 2004. Michael Newdow, an attorney and an atheist, argued that his daughter shouldn't have to listen to a religious statement in a public school. He actually won at the appellate level.
The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals basically said, "Yeah, this is an endorsement of religion."
The country freaked out.
The Senate passed a resolution reaffirming the Pledge. The Supreme Court eventually took the case but dodged the actual religious question. They ruled that Newdow didn't have "standing" because he didn't have legal custody of his daughter at the time. It was a total legal sidestep. They didn't say "Under God" was constitutional; they just said Newdow wasn't the guy to bring the suit.
Since then, various state courts have weighed in. In Massachusetts, the Supreme Judicial Court ruled in 2014 that the words were more about "patriotic exercise" than "religious exercise." They called it "ceremonial deism."
🔗 Read more: The Recipe Marble Pound Cake Secrets Professional Bakers Don't Usually Share
It's a fancy term. It basically means the words have been said so many times they've lost their specific religious sting and just become part of the furniture of American life.
The "Under God" addition wasn't just about religion
Bellamy, the original author, was a complicated guy. He was a Christian Socialist who had been pushed out of his pulpit for his views on the rights of working men. When he wrote the original 1892 version, he carefully chose words like "liberty and justice for all" because he believed those were the core American values. He actually considered putting the word "equality" in there too, but he knew the state superintendents of education (who were mostly white men in a segregated era) would hate it.
He died in 1931. He never saw the 1954 change.
His granddaughter later said he probably would have hated the addition. He was a stickler for the "alliterative and rhythmic" flow of the prose. Adding two extra syllables right in the middle of a cadence he meticulously crafted would have driven him nuts from a purely editorial perspective.
We also have to talk about the salute.
💡 You might also like: Why the Man Black Hair Blue Eyes Combo is So Rare (and the Genetics Behind It)
Before World War II, Americans didn't put their hands over their hearts. They used the "Bellamy Salute." You’d extend your arm toward the flag, palm up or down. But then the Nazis started using a salute that looked almost identical. By 1942, Congress decided, "Okay, we need to change this immediately," and they switched it to the hand-over-heart gesture we use today.
Why does this keep coming up?
The friction over the Pledge of Allegiance and Under God exists because America is constantly trying to figure out where the line is between "national identity" and "personal belief."
For some, the phrase is a vital acknowledgment of a higher power that grants us our rights. They point to the Declaration of Independence. They see it as a historical fact. For others, it’s a violation of the Establishment Clause of the First Amendment. They argue that the government has no business telling a six-year-old to profess a belief in a deity every morning at 8:00 AM.
The reality is that the Pledge has always been a tool for assimilation. In the 1890s, it was used to turn the children of immigrants into "Americans." In the 1950s, it was used to unify the country against a foreign ideology. Today, it’s a cultural touchstone that reveals our deepest divides.
Actionable insights for the curious
If you want to really understand the weight of these words, don't just take a side. Look at the primary sources.
- Read the 1954 Congressional Record. Look at the speeches given by the sponsors of the bill. You’ll see clearly that the intent was religious, which makes the "ceremonial deism" argument by modern courts feel a bit like a historical rewrite.
- Compare the versions. Read the 1892 version, the 1923 version (which changed "my flag" to "the flag of the United States of America"), and the 1954 version side-by-side. You can feel the rhythm change.
- Check your state laws. Did you know that in most states, students cannot be forced to say the Pledge? This was decided back in 1943 in West Virginia State Board of Education v. Barnette. Even if the school leads the Pledge, a student can stay seated or remain silent. This is a crucial bit of First Amendment protection that people often forget.
- Acknowledge the nuance. You can love the flag and the country while still questioning the specific wording of the Pledge. Patriotism isn't a monolith.
The history of the Pledge of Allegiance and Under God isn't a straight line. It’s a messy, politically charged, and deeply human story about a country trying to define itself one sentence at a time. Whether you see the 1954 addition as a necessary correction or a constitutional overreach, understanding the timeline is the only way to have an honest conversation about it.
The next time you’re at a ballgame or a school board meeting and those words start, you'll know you're not just reciting a poem. You're reciting a Cold War relic, a socialist's dream, and a century of legal battles, all wrapped up in a few seconds of tradition.