Imagine being the most powerful man in the world, literally building a city out of a swamp and dragging a medieval empire into the modern age with your bare hands. Now, imagine your only heir—the kid who is supposed to keep all that progress alive—is a quiet, devout guy who basically wants to undo every single thing you’ve ever done. That’s the nightmare Peter the Great lived through. Honestly, the story of Peter the Great son, Alexei Petrovich, is one of the most brutal family dramas in human history. It’s not just about a dad who was disappointed in his son’s grades or career choices; it’s a story that ended in a cold stone cell with a prince being whipped to death.
Who Was the Peter the Great Son Nobody Understood?
Alexei Petrovich was born in 1690 to Peter’s first wife, Eudoxia Lopukhina. Here’s the thing: Peter hated Eudoxia. She was "Old Russia"—conservative, religious, and totally resistant to Peter’s obsession with Western ships and European haircuts. When Peter eventually dumped her and forced her into a convent, Alexei was left in this weird limbo. He was raised by aunts and priests who whispered in his ear that his father was a monster.
You’ve got to feel for the kid. While Peter was out traveling Europe and learning how to build boats, Alexei was stuck in Moscow with people who hated everything Peter stood for.
By the time he was a teenager, the divide was massive. Peter wanted a warrior-king. He wanted a son who would sweat in a shipyard and lead a cavalry charge. Alexei? He liked reading theology books and chatting with monks. He was physically frail and, quite frankly, terrified of his father. There’s this famous story where Peter asked Alexei to show him his progress in drafting and mechanics. Alexei was so panicked and desperate to avoid the test that he actually shot himself in the right hand to get out of it.
That’s not exactly the "brave new leader" energy Peter was looking for.
The Great Escape That Sealed His Fate
The tension finally snapped in 1715. Peter’s second wife, Catherine, gave birth to another son (also named Peter). Suddenly, Alexei wasn't the only option anymore. Peter sent Alexei a letter that was basically an ultimatum: "Change your ways and care about the state, or I’m cutting you off like a gangrenous limb."
✨ Don't miss: Am I Gay Buzzfeed Quizzes and the Quest for Identity Online
Alexei’s response was kind of pathetic. He offered to renounce the throne and let his baby half-brother take over. Peter didn't buy it. He knew that as long as Alexei was alive, the "Old Russia" crowd would use him as a figurehead to start a civil war once Peter died. He told Alexei to either shape up or become a monk.
Instead of choosing the monastery, Alexei chose the run. In 1716, he fled to Vienna to seek protection from his brother-in-law, the Holy Roman Emperor Charles VI.
This was the point of no return. To Peter, this wasn't just a family spat; it was high treason. Having the Peter the Great son seeking asylum with a foreign power made Russia look weak and Peter look like a failure. Peter sent his best "fixer," Count Peter Tolstoy (yep, an ancestor of the War and Peace guy), to hunt him down. Tolstoy was a master manipulator. He promised Alexei that if he just came home, Peter would forgive everything, let him marry his mistress Afrosinya, and let them live quietly on a country estate.
Alexei fell for it.
The Investigation and the Knout
When Alexei got back to Moscow in 1718, the "forgiveness" lasted about five minutes. Peter forced him to name every single person who had helped him escape. This turned into a full-blown purge. Anyone associated with the prince was arrested, broken on the wheel, or beheaded.
🔗 Read more: Easy recipes dinner for two: Why you are probably overcomplicating date night
Peter then turned his attention to his son. He didn't believe Alexei was just a "lazy kid" anymore; he convinced himself there was a massive conspiracy to overthrow him. A special court of 127 officials—all of whom were terrified of Peter—was formed to judge the Tsarevich.
Then came the torture.
In the Peter and Paul Fortress, the Peter the Great son was subjected to the "knout." This wasn't just a whip. It was a heavy leather lash reinforced with metal wire that could literally tear pieces of flesh off a person’s back. Historians like Robert K. Massie have documented that Alexei received 25 lashes on June 19, and another 15 on June 24.
Think about that. A father watched (or at least authorized) his own son being flayed. On June 26, 1718, the court officially sentenced Alexei to death. But the executioner never got to him. Alexei died in his cell that evening, likely from the shock and trauma of the torture.
What Most People Get Wrong About the Tragedy
There’s a common myth that Peter killed his son in a fit of rage, sort of like Ivan the Terrible did with his own heir. But that’s not really how it happened. Peter was actually quite systematic about it. He felt that the survival of the Russian Empire was more important than the life of one "unworthy" person—even if that person was his son.
💡 You might also like: How is gum made? The sticky truth about what you are actually chewing
- The "Old Russia" Factor: Alexei wasn't just lazy. He was the hope of a massive underground movement that wanted to move the capital back to Moscow and burn the navy.
- The Promise: Peter did promise to forgive him, but in his mind, that promise was void once he "discovered" (through more torture of others) that Alexei had supposedly wished for his father's death.
- The Remorse: Did Peter feel bad? Hard to say. The day after Alexei died was the anniversary of the Battle of Poltava, Peter's greatest victory. He celebrated with a massive party. He didn't even cancel the fireworks.
Why the Peter the Great Son Story Matters Today
This wasn't just a dark moment in a dusty history book. It changed the course of Russia forever. Because Alexei died, and his younger half-brother died shortly after, Peter was left with no male heir. This led to a "succession crisis" that lasted for decades, where the throne was basically grabbed by whoever had the strongest guards.
It also highlights the brutal reality of the "Great" label in history. To be "Great" in the 18th century usually meant being willing to sacrifice everything—and everyone—for the state.
Actionable Insights for History Buffs
If you’re interested in seeing the physical remnants of this tragedy, here is how you can actually engage with this history:
- Visit the Peter and Paul Fortress: Located in St. Petersburg, you can visit the Trubetskoy Bastion where Alexei was held. It’s a somber place that makes the history feel very real.
- Look for Nikolai Ge’s Painting: "Peter the Great Interrogating the Tsarevich Alexei Petrovich at Peterhof" is one of the most famous Russian paintings. It perfectly captures the psychological tension—Peter looking like a lion and Alexei looking like a trapped bird.
- Read the Letters: Many of the letters between father and son have been translated into English. Reading Peter’s cold, logical threats alongside Alexei’s desperate, pleading replies is a chilling experience.
The story of the Peter the Great son serves as a grim reminder that power often comes at a human cost that most of us can't even imagine. Peter built a modern Russia, but he had to break his own heart—and his son’s body—to do it.