You’re walking down Clarendon Road in Brooklyn, and honestly, it looks like any other neighborhood. There are auto repair shops, a car wash, and the general hum of East Flatbush. But then, tucked away behind a fence, stands a small wooden house with a weirdly long, sloping roof.
It looks out of place. It looks like it belongs in a storybook or a museum in Amsterdam.
That’s because it basically does. This is the Wyckoff House, and it is officially the oldest building in NY. Not just the city, but the entire state.
The Oldest Building in NY and Why It's Still Standing
Most people assume the oldest thing in New York must be a stone fort upstate or maybe a tavern in Lower Manhattan where George Washington once had a drink.
Nope.
It’s a "saltbox" frame house in Brooklyn. Built around 1652, it has survived almost 400 years of urban sprawl, fires, and the sheer chaos of New York's development.
The story of the Wyckoff House isn't just about old wood and nails. It’s about a guy named Pieter Claesen, an illiterate teenage farmhand who arrived in New Netherland (now New York) in 1637. He was an indentured servant. He worked off his debt, married a woman named Grietje van Nes, and eventually became a successful farmer and magistrate.
When he moved into this house, he was basically living the 17th-century version of the American Dream.
It wasn't always this big
When Pieter first built the place, it was tiny. One room. A packed dirt floor. An open hearth for cooking and heat.
The family grew. Fast.
Pieter and Grietje had eleven children. Eventually, those children had children, and today, there are an estimated 50,000 descendants of the Wyckoff family across America. If your last name is Wyckoff, or Wicoff, or any of those variations, there is a very high chance your ancestors slept in this exact house.
What Makes the Architecture So Weird?
If you look at the house, the roof is the first thing you notice. It’s a style called Flemish Medieval Survival.
The eaves curve outward, almost like a bell. This wasn't just for looks; it helped keep water away from the foundation, which was pretty important back when "waterproofing" meant "hope the mud stays dry."
Inside, the house uses an H-bent frame.
📖 Related: Why Four Seasons Hotel New York on East 57th Street Took So Long to Reopen
Think of it like a giant ribcage made of heavy timber. This is why the house hasn't collapsed. These beams are held together by mortise and tenon joints—basically wooden pegs—that have stayed tight since before the United States was even a country.
The "Other" Contenders
You might hear people talk about Old Fort Niagara up in Youngstown. Their "French Castle" was built in 1726. It’s incredibly old and made of stone, but the Wyckoff House still beats it by about 74 years.
Then there’s the Riker-Lent-Smith Homestead in Queens (1654) and the Billiou-Stillwell-Perine House on Staten Island (1662).
They are all ancient in "American years," but the Wyckoff House remains the king of the mountain.
How It Almost Became a Sewer
It's kinda miraculous that we can even visit the oldest building in NY today.
In the 1950s, the city wanted to put a new street and a sewer line right through the property. The house was in rough shape. It was deteriorating, and developers were circling like sharks.
Luckily, the Wyckoff descendants weren't having it.
They formed an association in 1937 and spent decades fighting to save the property. In 1965, the New York City Landmarks Preservation Commission was formed, and the Wyckoff House was the very first building they designated as a landmark.
It was #1.
That designation stopped the bulldozers. By 1982, the house was fully restored and opened as a museum.
Realities of Visiting Today
If you go today, don't expect a massive estate. It sits on 1.5 acres of parkland, which is a tiny fraction of the original 400-acre farm.
It feels small.
You can see the original 1650s wood in the kitchen hearth. You can see the "carpenter's marks" on the attic beams—notches that helped 17th-century builders match the right pieces of timber together like a giant LEGO set.
Misconceptions to Clear Up
- It’s not in Manhattan: Most "historic" New York tours stay in Manhattan. You have to go to Brooklyn for this one.
- It’s not a reconstruction: While it has been restored, the core "skeleton" of the house is the original 1650s frame.
- It wasn't always a museum: For a long time, it was just a regular farmhouse. Eight generations of Wyckoffs lived there until 1901.
Why You Should Care
Old buildings in New York usually get torn down for glass towers. We’re a city that loves the "new."
But there’s something grounding about standing in a room that existed before the Revolutionary War. Before the subway. Before the lightbulb.
It’s a reminder that New York started as a collection of muddy farms and immigrants looking for a better life. Pieter Claesen couldn't read or write, but he built something that outlasted almost everything else in the state.
📖 Related: The St Regis The Palm Dubai Is Not Just Another Fancy Hotel
Actionable Steps for Your Visit
If you want to see the oldest building in NY for yourself, here is how to do it right:
- Check the Schedule: The museum isn't open every day. Usually, it's open for public tours on Saturdays from 11 AM to 3 PM, but you should always check the official Wyckoff Museum website before trekking out there.
- Take the Sub: Take the 2 or 5 train to Newkirk Avenue-Little Haiti and then catch the B8 bus. It’s a bit of a journey from Manhattan, but worth it for the history.
- Look for the "Dutch Door": One of the coolest features is the split door. You can keep the bottom closed to keep the farm animals out while leaving the top open for light and air.
- Bring $5: The admission is incredibly cheap for NYC standards. It’s $5 for adults and even less for students and seniors.
- Don't skip the garden: They still maintain a colonial-style kitchen garden on the grounds. It gives you a much better sense of what "farming in Brooklyn" actually looked like.
The Wyckoff House isn't just a pile of old wood. It is the literal foundation of the state's architectural history. Whether you're a history nerd or just someone who likes seeing weird, old things in the middle of a modern city, it's a spot that deserves a spot on your New York bucket list.