Oklahoma State football is weird. It’s a program defined by long stretches of "what if" followed by sudden, violent bursts of excellence. If you look back at the Oklahoma State football coaches history, you aren’t just looking at a list of names; you’re looking at a 120-year-old struggle to find an identity in the shadow of that school down in Norman.
It started with a guy named Boyd Hill in 1901. Back then, they weren't even the Cowboys. They were the Oklahoma A&M Farmers. Hill went 2-3, and honestly, the program basically spent the next few decades rotating through guys who were just trying to figure out if football was even going to stick in Stillwater.
The Early Architects and the Pringle Factor
Most people forget that before the modern era, Oklahoma State actually had some real innovators. Look at George Pringle. In 1923, he took over a program that was basically directionless. He didn't stay long, but he started the process of making Stillwater a place where you could actually win.
Then came Pappy Waldorf.
Lynn "Pappy" Waldorf is a legend for a reason. He’s one of the few guys in the Oklahoma State football coaches history who actually left the program better than he found it before jumping to a "bigger" job. He went 34-10-7. He won three consecutive Southwest Conference titles (yeah, OSU was in the SWC back then). He proved that if you had the right scheme and a little bit of grit, you could beat anybody. When he left for Northwestern, it felt like the air went out of the stadium.
Success in Stillwater has always been cyclical. Jim Lookabaugh followed Waldorf and managed to capture the school's only "national title" (retroactively awarded by the AFCA for the 1945 season). That 1945 team was a juggernaut. Bob Fenimore—the "Blond Bomber"—was a two-way terror. They went 9-0 and crushed St. Mary’s in the Sugar Bowl. It was the peak. And then, as is tradition in Stillwater, the slide began.
👉 See also: Tottenham vs FC Barcelona: Why This Matchup Still Matters in 2026
The Dry Spells and the Jimmy Johnson Spark
The 1950s and 60s were, frankly, brutal. Coaches like Cliff Speegle and Phil Cutchin struggled. Cutchin, a Bear Bryant disciple, tried to bring that Junction Boys mentality to Oklahoma A&M (which became Oklahoma State University in 1957). It didn't go well. He finished his tenure with a 19-38-2 record.
You can’t talk about the Oklahoma State football coaches history without talking about the 1970s and 80s turnaround.
Jim Stanley brought some respectability back, but the real shift happened when a charismatic guy with a thick Texas accent named Jimmy Johnson rolled into town in 1979. Jimmy didn’t just coach; he recruited. He brought an edge. He realized that to win in Stillwater, you had to be faster and meaner than the guys in the Big 8. He went 29-25-3, which doesn't look like a Hall of Fame record, but he laid the foundation.
When Jimmy left for Miami, Pat Jones took over.
Pat Jones is a fascinating character. He presided over the Thurman Thomas and Barry Sanders era. Think about that. You had two of the greatest running backs in the history of the sport back-to-back. Jones went 62-59-3. He won the Bluebonnet Bowl and the Gator Bowl. But then the NCAA came knocking. Violations hit the program hard in the late 80s, leading to a decade of wandering in the wilderness under Bob Simmons.
✨ Don't miss: Buddy Hield Sacramento Kings: What Really Happened Behind the Scenes
The Les Miles Pivot
By the time 2001 rolled around, Oklahoma State was a basement dweller in the Big 12. Enter Les Miles.
Les was... Les. He was quirky, he ate grass, and he talked in riddles. But man, could he recruit. He beat Oklahoma in 2001 and 2002. Those "Bedlam" wins changed the trajectory of the entire university. He brought in talent like Rashaun Woods and Tatum Bell. He made it "cool" to wear orange again.
When Les headed to LSU in 2005, the school made a choice that would define the next two decades. They hired the local kid. The quarterback from the 80s.
The Mike Gundy Era: Stability or Ceiling?
Mike Gundy is the Oklahoma State football coaches history. Period.
He has been the head coach since 2005. That is an eternity in modern college football. He’s the winningest coach in school history by a massive margin. He gave us the "I'm a man, I'm 40" speech. He gave us the mullet. He gave us the 2011 season where the Pokes were a field goal away from playing for a National Championship.
🔗 Read more: Why the March Madness 2022 Bracket Still Haunts Your Sports Betting Group Chat
Under Gundy, OSU transformed from a team that hoped to go to a bowl game to a team that expects to win 10 games.
- Longevity: Over 160 wins.
- Consistency: A bowl streak that spans nearly his entire tenure.
- Innovation: He embraced the air raid and high-tempo offenses before they were cool.
- The Rivalry: This is the sticking point. His record against Oklahoma is the one major blemish fans argue about over beers at Eskimo Joe's.
Is Gundy the best to ever do it in Stillwater? Statistically, yes. But the history of this program shows that the shadow of the 1945 championship and the 2011 "what if" still looms large.
What the History Teaches Us
Looking at the full timeline, a few patterns emerge. First, Oklahoma State wins when they have a transcendent talent at running back or wide receiver. Second, the coaching staff has to be "all-in" on the Stillwater culture. Outsiders who try to turn it into "Alabama North" or "Texas North" usually fail.
The successful coaches—Waldorf, Johnson, Miles, and Gundy—all embraced the "Cowboy Culture." They leaned into the underdog status.
Actionable Insights for Fans and Analysts
If you're tracking the future of the program based on its past, keep these metrics in mind:
- Recruiting Geography: History shows OSU thrives when they "cherry-pick" Texas talent that UT and A&M overlook. Watch if the current staff maintains that pipeline or shifts too heavily toward the transfer portal.
- The Post-Bedlam Identity: With Oklahoma moving to the SEC, the Oklahoma State football coaches history is entering a new chapter. For the first time, a coach won't be judged primarily on their record against the Sooners. This could either liberate the program or cause it to lose its competitive edge.
- Investigating the "Elite" Jump: Every major coach in OSU history hit a ceiling. Waldorf left. Johnson left. Miles left. Gundy stayed. The next step in the program's evolution is determining if a coach can stay and win a playoff-era national title.
To truly understand where the Cowboys are going, you have to look at the 1980s sanctions and the 2011 BCS snub. Those two events shaped the modern psyche of the coaching staff. The program isn't just playing against the opponent on the field; it's playing against a century of being the "other" school in the state.
The next coach in this long lineage will inherit a program with top-tier facilities and a stable foundation—something Pappy Waldorf or Jimmy Johnson could have only dreamed of.