Edmonton and Dallas. McDavid and Heiskanen. It was always going to be a heavy-weight fight, but nobody expected the goaltending clinic we got in Texas last night. If you missed it, honestly, you missed the kind of game that defines the mid-season grind. The Edmonton Oilers walked away with a 3-2 victory in a shootout, but that score doesn't even begin to tell the story of the chaotic third period or the absolute robbery Stuart Skinner committed in the dying seconds of regulation.
Why the Oilers vs Stars Result Matters More Than the Score
People look at the box score and see a "W" for Edmonton. Simple, right? Not really. Dallas dominated the high-danger scoring chances. According to Natural Stat Trick, the Stars had an expected goals-for (xGF) of $4.2$ compared to Edmonton's $2.1$. They doubled them up. In a vacuum, Dallas wins that game nine times out of ten. But hockey isn't played in a vacuum; it’s played in the crease.
Stuart Skinner was the difference. Period.
He stopped 38 of 40 shots. He looked calm, which is a weird thing to say about a guy who had Jason Robertson staring him down from the slot every five minutes. The Stars’ power play, which has been clicking at over 25% lately, went 0-for-4. That is where the game was won. If Edmonton's penalty kill doesn't hold firm against that Dallas movement, the Oilers are flying to their next city with zero points and a lot of questions about their defensive structure.
The Turning Point Nobody Noticed
Everyone is talking about the shootout winner by Leon Draisaitl. It was a classic "Leon move"—slow approach, wait for the goalie to blink, then snap it five-hole. But the real turning point happened midway through the second period. Mattias Janmark laid a hit on Roope Hintz that seemed to wake up the Dallas bench. For the next ten minutes, the Oilers couldn't even get the puck out of their own zone.
They were hemmed in. Gassed.
Usually, that’s when the Oilers collapse. We’ve seen it for years. This time, they didn't. They played "winning hockey," which basically means they ate pucks and cleared the porch. Darnell Nurse had three blocks in a single shift. It wasn't pretty. It was actually kind of gross to watch if you like flow and finesse. But it worked.
📖 Related: The Truth About the Memphis Grizzlies Record 2025: Why the Standings Don't Tell the Whole Story
Breakdown: Who Won the Hockey Game and How
To understand why the Oilers took the two points, you have to look at the matchups. Pete DeBoer tried to hard-match Esa Lindell against Connor McDavid all night. It worked for about fifty minutes. McDavid was held to just one assist. However, when you focus that much energy on 97, you leave gaps elsewhere.
Evan Bouchard took advantage of those gaps.
His goal from the point was a seeing-eye shot. No screen? No problem. He just has a knack for finding the lane. On the Dallas side, Tyler Seguin looked like his 2019 self. He was flying. He scored the opening goal on a beautiful redirection that left Skinner waving at air. It felt like Dallas had the momentum, but they just couldn't solve the "Skinner Puzzle" once the Oilers retreated into their 1-3-1 neutral zone trap in the third.
The Physicality Factor
This wasn't just a skating contest. It was physical. Corey Perry was doing Corey Perry things—being a nuisance in the blue paint and getting under Jake Oettinger’s skin. You can see why Edmonton brought him in. In a tight game where the ref's whistle goes into their pocket, you need a guy who can play in the mud.
- Edmonton’s Top Six: They were quiet but efficient.
- Dallas’s Depth: The Marchment-Duchene-Seguin line was the best line on the ice, even in a losing effort.
- Special Teams: Edmonton’s PK was the MVP.
The Goaltending Duel: Skinner vs Oettinger
We have to talk about Jake Oettinger. It’s easy to overlook the losing goalie, but "Otter" was fantastic. He made a glove save on Zach Hyman in the first period that defied physics. He kept Dallas in it when their defense had a few characteristic lapses.
But Skinner was just better.
👉 See also: The Division 2 National Championship Game: How Ferris State Just Redrew the Record Books
He’s had a rocky road since the Stanley Cup Finals run. Fans in Edmonton are fickle; one bad game and they want to trade him for a bag of pucks. Last night was a statement. He wasn't fighting the puck. He wasn't swimming. He was square to every shot. When the game went to the shootout, he looked massive in the net. He stopped both Dallas shooters with ease, reading Robertson's deke like it was a children's book.
What This Means for the Standings
The Western Conference is a meat grinder. Every point feels like it’s worth ten. With this win, Edmonton inches closer to that top spot in the Pacific, while Dallas stays comfortably in the mix for the Central crown.
But psychological wins matter too.
Dallas is a team that expects to win at home. Losing a game where you clearly outplayed the opponent hurts. It sticks with you. For Edmonton, it’s a confidence builder. It proves they can win games where McDavid isn't the primary engine. It proves they can defend a lead—or at least hang on by their fingernails—against an elite offense.
Key Stats from the Matchup
- Final Score: Edmonton 3, Dallas 2 (SO)
- Shots on Goal: Dallas 40, Edmonton 26
- Hits: Edmonton 22, Dallas 19
- Faceoff %: Dallas 58%, Edmonton 42%
The faceoff discrepancy is actually pretty wild. Dallas dominated the dot. Usually, if you win nearly 60% of the draws, you control the pace. Dallas did control the pace, but they didn't control the scoreboard. That’s the "luck" element of hockey that drives coaches crazy. You do everything right, you win the draws, you outshoot them, and you still lose because a goalie in Alberta decided he wasn't going to let anything past him.
Misconceptions About the Oilers’ Defense
People love to dunk on Edmonton’s blue line. It’s a national pastime at this point. "They can't defend," they say. "They’re too soft," they claim.
✨ Don't miss: Por qué los partidos de Primera B de Chile son más entretenidos que la división de honor
Watch the tape from last night.
Specifically, watch Mattias Ekholm. The guy is a human vacuum. He shuts down lanes before the opposition even realizes they’re there. He played nearly 25 minutes. His pairing with Bouchard is easily one of the top five pairings in the league right now, even if the "advanced stats" crowd occasionally gets grumpy about Bouchard's defensive lapses. When it mattered in the final two minutes, Ekholm was out there blocking shots with his shins. That’s grit.
Next Steps for Both Teams
Dallas heads to St. Louis next. They need to find a way to finish. If I’m Pete DeBoer, I’m not changing much. You can’t get frustrated when you put up 40 shots. You just have to trust the process.
Edmonton stays on the road. They have a date with Vegas coming up, and that’s going to be a bloodbath. If they play like they did in the first forty minutes against Dallas, Vegas will eat them alive. They need to figure out how to generate more than 26 shots. You can't rely on your goalie to make 38 saves every single night. It’s not sustainable.
How to Use This Information
If you’re a bettor or a fantasy manager, take note of Stuart Skinner’s save percentage over his last five starts. He’s trending up significantly. Also, keep an eye on the Stars' second line. Seguin is playing with a chip on his shoulder that makes him a high-value asset right now.
Actionable Takeaways:
- Watch the Penalty Kill: Edmonton's PK is the metric to follow. When it's over 80%, they win. When it's not, they struggle.
- The "Otter" Factor: Don't sell high on Oettinger. He lost, but his fundamental play was elite. He’s going on a tear soon.
- Check the Schedule: Both teams are entering a heavy "three games in four nights" stretch. Fatigue will start showing in the third periods.
The game was a reminder of why we watch. It wasn't a blowout. It wasn't a 1-0 snoozefest. It was high-event, high-stakes hockey between two teams that genuinely don't like each other very much. Edmonton won the hockey game, but the season series is far from over.
Keep an eye on the waiver wire for depth players from these two teams; the physical toll of this game might lead to some "maintenance days" for the stars. Pay attention to the practice lines on Tuesday morning. Often, a win like this leads to a "trap game" next time out because of the emotional letdown.