It was opening day. July 26, 2017. The air in Columbus was thick with that specific mid-summer humidity and the smell of fried dough. People were laughing. Then, everything changed in a split second. A row of seats on the Fireball ride—a massive, swinging aggressive pendulum—simply broke away. It didn’t just malfunction. It disintegrated while in motion.
Eighteen-year-old Tyler Jarrell lost his life. Seven others were hurt, some with injuries so severe they’d never truly be the same.
When we talk about the Ohio State Fair accident, it’s easy to get lost in the sensationalist headlines or the grainy cell phone footage that went viral almost instantly. But the reality is much grittier. It’s a story about metal fatigue, a "perfect storm" of corrosion, and a regulatory system that many experts argue was—and in some ways, still is—woefully underfunded.
👉 See also: how much snow is expected in kansas city: What Most People Get Wrong
Honestly, it’s a miracle it hasn’t happened more often.
What actually went wrong with the Fireball?
KMG, the Dutch manufacturer of the ride, didn’t dodge the blame. They were pretty blunt about it after their investigators got on the ground. The culprit? Internal corrosion.
Think about that for a second.
The ride looked fine on the outside. It had been inspected. It had its permits. But inside one of the hollow support arms, water had been sitting. For years. This wasn't a sudden snap caused by a heavy passenger or a gust of wind. It was a slow, invisible decay that ate away at the steel from the inside out. By the time the Fireball swung high into the air that Wednesday night, the metal was thin as a wafer.
It just gave up.
The scary part is that the inspectors didn't see it because they couldn't see it. Standard visual inspections involve looking for cracks, loose bolts, or weird noises. You can't see through steel with the naked eye. This realization sent shockwaves through the outdoor amusement industry. If a ride that passed a visual check could fail so catastrophically, was any ride actually safe?
The "Tyler" Law and the push for real change
For a long time, Ohio’s ride inspection laws were... let's call them "dated." Following the tragedy, the Jarrell family and survivors pushed hard for legislative action. They didn't want another family to get that phone call.
In 2019, Governor Mike DeWine signed "Tyler’s Law."
🔗 Read more: How Many Children Have Died in School Shootings 2025: The Numbers and the Stories Behind Them
It wasn't just a symbolic gesture. It fundamentally changed how Ohio handles amusement rides. For starters, it increased the number of inspectors. Before the Ohio State Fair accident, the Department of Agriculture was stretched thin. You had a handful of people trying to look at thousands of pieces of equipment across the state. Now, the law requires more rigorous structural testing, especially for rides that have been in service for years or those that are moved frequently—like the ones you see at traveling carnivals and county fairs.
One of the biggest shifts was the requirement for manufacturers to provide detailed service "bulletins." If a company discovers a flaw in a ride in Germany, they have to tell the owners in Ohio immediately. It sounds like common sense, but the communication pipeline used to be surprisingly clogged.
The problem with "Road Rides"
There is a massive difference between a roller coaster at Cedar Point and a ride at your local fair.
The big parks have permanent installations. Those rides stay put. They have year-round maintenance crews who know every bolt. But "road rides"—the kind involved in the Ohio State Fair accident—are different beasts entirely. They are designed to be folded up, put on a truck, driven 200 miles, and bolted back together in a parking lot.
That constant assembly and disassembly creates "stress cycles."
Every time you wrench a bolt tight or vibrate a trailer down a highway, you're adding wear and tear. When you add the Ohio weather—rain, humidity, freezing winters—to a hollow steel tube, you get the exact conditions that led to the Fireball failure. Experts like Bill Avery, a veteran safety consultant, have often pointed out that traveling rides require a level of scrutiny that many state budgets simply don't support.
Can you actually trust the midway?
So, you're standing in front of a spinning neon contraption. Should you get on?
Look, the odds are still technically in your favor. Millions of people ride these things every year without a scratch. But the Ohio State Fair accident taught us that "it looks okay" isn't an engineering standard.
If you're worried, look for the inspection tag. In Ohio, every ride must have a visible permit issued by the Department of Agriculture. If you don't see one, or if it's expired, walk away. Honestly, just walk away. Also, pay attention to the operators. Are they focused? Are they checking every single restraint? If the person running the ride looks like they’d rather be literally anywhere else, that's a red flag. Safety isn't just about the metal; it's about the humans supervising the metal.
The 2017 tragedy was a wake-up call that cost a young man his life. It forced the industry to move toward "non-destructive testing"—things like ultrasound and X-rays—to find the rot inside the steel.
✨ Don't miss: North Las Vegas Shooting: Why the June 2024 Tragedy Still Weighs on the Community
Actionable steps for fairgoers
While the state has beefed up its oversight, your own eyes are your first line of defense. Here is how you should approach your next trip to the fairgrounds:
- Check the Permit: Every ride in Ohio must display a current-year inspection sticker. It’s usually near the operator’s booth or the entrance ramp. No sticker? No ride.
- Listen to the Machine: Modern rides shouldn't sound like a bucket of nails in a dryer. If you hear metal-on-metal grinding or rhythmic "clunks" that seem out of place, report it to the fair office.
- Watch the Setup: Traveling rides should be level. Check the "cribbing"—the wooden blocks under the ride's frame. If the blocks look splintered, unstable, or are sinking into the mud, it’s a sign of a sloppy setup.
- Report Concerns Immediately: Don't just tell your friends. Find a fair official or a law enforcement officer on-site. The Ohio Department of Agriculture has a specific division for amusement ride safety that takes public complaints seriously.
- Follow the Rules: It sounds boring, but height and weight requirements exist for a reason. Restraints are engineered for specific body types. Don't try to "squeeze" a kid onto a ride they aren't ready for.
The legacy of the Ohio State Fair accident shouldn't be fear, but rather a demand for higher standards. We enjoy these spectacles because they provide a controlled thrill. When the "controlled" part of that equation fails, the consequences are permanent. Demand transparency from your local fair organizers and support funding for the inspectors who keep the "invisible rot" at bay.