It was supposed to be a celebration. October 17, 1989, started as one of those perfect Bay Area days where the air is crisp, the sun is hitting the Pacific just right, and everyone—honestly, everyone—was obsessed with the World Series. It was the "Battle of the Bay." The San Francisco Giants versus the Oakland Athletics.
Candlestick Park was packed.
Then, at 5:04 p.m., the earth didn't just shake. It buckled. For about 15 seconds, the October 17 1989 San Francisco earthquake, also known as the Loma Prieta quake, tore through Northern California with a magnitude of 6.9. It wasn't the "Big One" people had been whispering about for decades, but it was close enough to change the region forever.
What Actually Happened Under the Santa Cruz Mountains?
Most people think the epicenter was right under the Transamerica Pyramid or the Golden Gate Bridge. It wasn't. The slip actually happened in the Forest of Nisene Marks State Park, way down in the Santa Cruz Mountains.
The San Andreas Fault shifted.
Basically, the Pacific Plate surged about 6 feet to the northwest and pushed up over the North American Plate by about 4 feet. This wasn't just side-to-side rattling. It was a vertical heave. Because the rupture happened about 11 miles deep, the energy had a lot of ground to travel through before it hit the surface, which is probably why the death toll—though tragic at 63 people—wasn't in the thousands.
Seismologists like those at the USGS (U.S. Geological Survey) later pointed out that the duration was surprisingly short. Had it lasted 30 or 40 seconds instead of 15, the Bay Area might have looked like a war zone.
The World Series Factor
There’s a weird bit of luck here. Or maybe it’s just a strange coincidence. Because the Giants and A's were playing Game 3 of the World Series, the usually nightmare-inducing commute on the I-880 and the Bay Bridge was lighter than normal.
👉 See also: What Really Happened With the Women's Orchestra of Auschwitz
People had left work early.
They were already home, sitting in front of their TVs, or they were already at the stadium. If that game hadn't been happening, thousands more cars would have been on the Cypress Street Viaduct when it pancaked.
The Nightmare at the Cypress Street Viaduct
If you've seen any footage of the October 17 1989 San Francisco earthquake, you've seen the Cypress Street Viaduct in Oakland. This was a double-decker stretch of Interstate 880. It was built in the 1950s, back before we really understood how "soft-story" concrete structures react to high-frequency shaking.
When the waves hit, the upper deck support columns failed.
The top level literally fell onto the lower level. It accounted for 42 of the 63 deaths that day. It's a brutal image, but it led to a massive overhaul in how California retrofits its highways. Today, you won't find many of those older double-decker designs without massive steel jackets around the pillars. We learned the hard way that concrete alone is brittle. It snaps.
The Marina District's Hidden Weakness
San Francisco’s Marina District took a different kind of hit. It wasn't just the shaking; it was the ground itself. You see, much of the Marina is built on "made land"—basically a mix of sand, silt, and rubble from the 1906 earthquake that was dumped into the bay to create space for the 1915 Panama-Pacific International Exposition.
When the 1989 quake hit, the ground turned to soup.
✨ Don't miss: How Much Did Trump Add to the National Debt Explained (Simply)
This is called liquefaction. The water pressure in the soil increases so much during shaking that the ground loses all its strength. Victorian houses tilted at 45-degree angles. Gas lines snapped. Fires broke out. And because the water mains also snapped, the Fire Department had to rely on the "Phoenix" fireboat to pump salt water from the bay to put out the blazes. It was a chaotic, terrifying mess that proved you can't build on trash and expect it to hold during a 6.9 magnitude event.
Why the Bay Bridge Failed
The San Francisco-Oakland Bay Bridge is an icon, but on October 17, 1989, it became a symbol of vulnerability. A 50-foot section of the upper deck crashed onto the lower deck.
One person died.
The failure happened at Pier E9. The bolts sheared off because the bridge wasn't designed to handle the different speeds at which the eastern and western spans were vibrating. It took a month to fix it, but the long-term result was the total replacement of the Eastern Span—that sleek, white self-anchored suspension bridge you see today. It cost over $6 billion and took decades to finish, all because of those 15 seconds in '89.
The Lessons We Actually Learned (and the Ones We Didn't)
After the October 17 1989 San Francisco earthquake, the state of California went on a retrofitting spree. Billions were poured into hospitals, bridges, and schools. We got better at "base isolation," which is basically putting buildings on giant shock absorbers.
But honestly? We’re still behind.
Thousands of "soft-story" apartments—the ones with big garage openings on the first floor—still exist. San Francisco has passed laws forcing owners to fix these, but it's a slow process. If a quake hits at 3:00 a.m. instead of 5:04 p.m., the casualty list for these types of buildings would be staggering.
🔗 Read more: The Galveston Hurricane 1900 Orphanage Story Is More Tragic Than You Realized
Regional Differences in Damage
It's interesting to look at how Santa Cruz and Watsonville fared compared to the city. While the national media focused on the Bay Bridge and the Marina, the towns closest to the epicenter were devastated. The Pacific Garden Mall in Santa Cruz was essentially leveled. Small businesses that had been there for generations vanished in seconds.
It reminds us that the "San Francisco" earthquake was actually a regional catastrophe.
Modern Earthquake Preparedness: Your Action Plan
We can't predict the next one. We can only mitigate the mess. If you live in a seismic zone, there are specific, non-negotiable things you should have done yesterday.
- Secure your furniture. Use L-brackets to bolt tall bookshelves and dressers to the wall studs. In 1989, many injuries weren't from collapsing roofs, but from flying appliances and falling furniture.
- Know your shut-offs. You need to know exactly where your gas shut-off valve is and have a wrench tied to the pipe. Don't wait for the smell of rotten eggs to start looking for it in the dark.
- The "Go-Bag" reality. Forget the fancy pre-made kits. You need 72 hours of water (one gallon per person per day), your specific prescriptions, and cash. After a major quake, the power goes out. When the power goes out, credit card machines don't work. ATMs don't work. Cash is the only thing that buys a gallon of gas or a bag of ice.
- The "Drop, Cover, and Hold On" rule. Don't run outside. People get killed by falling glass and masonry (facades) while trying to exit buildings. Get under a sturdy table and stay there.
The October 17 1989 San Francisco earthquake was a wake-up call that we've partially answered. We have better bridges and better codes, but the fundamental risk remains. The San Andreas isn't going anywhere. It’s just waiting for the next time it needs to move.
Ensure your home's foundation is bolted to the sill plate. If you live in an older home (pre-1980), check your crawlspace. If you see wood resting on concrete without heavy-duty bolts, that’s your first weekend project. A house that slides off its foundation is usually a total loss; a house that stays put is a home you can repair.
Check your emergency supplies every six months when you change your clocks. Replace the water, check the batteries, and make sure your shoes are kept near the bed. In 1989, many people were cut by broken glass because they couldn't find their shoes in the dark. It's a small detail that makes a massive difference when the world starts moving.