The New York Giants are currently stuck in that weird, uncomfortable purgatory where every Sunday feels like a referendum on the entire front office. Honestly, if you scroll through any recent NY Giants mock draft, you’ll see the same three names over and over again. It’s predictable. It’s safe. But is it actually what Joe Schoen is thinking behind closed doors at 1925 Giants Drive? Probably not.
Draft season in East Rutherford isn't just about picking the best player available anymore; it’s about job security. Brian Daboll and Schoen are staring down a roster that has flashes of high-end talent—think Malik Nabers or Dexter Lawrence—but lacks the structural integrity to survive a full 17-game slate.
People love to argue about the quarterback position. It’s the obvious choice, right? Daniel Jones has become the ultimate lightning rod for fan frustration, but fixing this team requires more than just swapping out the signal-caller. If you drop a rookie into this current setup without addressing the interior defensive line or the secondary depth, you're just setting another young career on fire.
Why Every NY Giants Mock Draft Starts with the Same Problem
The "quarterback or bust" mentality has completely taken over the discourse. You see it on every big board from ESPN to Pro Football Focus. The logic is simple: if you don’t have the guy, nothing else matters. But the Giants are in a unique, and frankly annoying, financial situation.
The dead money hits and the specific structures of recent contracts make moving on from Jones a surgical process rather than a clean break. When you look at a NY Giants mock draft for 2026, you have to account for the "scars" of previous regimes. Dave Gettleman’s ghosts still haunt the hallways, but Schoen’s own picks are now reaching the point where they either sink or swim.
Take the offensive line. It’s improved, sure. But is it "top-ten unit" improved? Not really. Andrew Thomas is a cornerstone, but the revolving door at guards has been a nightmare for consistency. If the Giants find themselves picking in the top five, the temptation to take a generational tackle—even if they have to move someone to the right side—is going to be massive.
The Quarterback Conundrum
Let's be real for a second. If a guy like Arch Manning or a rising superstar from the SEC is sitting there, you take him. You don't overthink it. But most mocks assume the Giants will be picking in that 6-12 range—the "No Man's Land" of the draft.
💡 You might also like: Khamzat Chimaev Robert Whittaker: What Really Happened to Bobby Knuckles' Jaw
In this scenario, do you reach for the third-best QB? History says that's how GMs get fired. Christian Ponder, EJ Manuel, even Daniel Jones himself—the "reach" pick rarely ages well. I’ve talked to scouts who think the 2026 class is top-heavy but thin in the middle. That means if the Giants aren't bad enough to get the "sure thing," they might be better off trading back or loading up on premium defenders.
The Defensive Identity Crisis
While everyone is staring at the QB, the defense is quietly screaming for help. Dexter Lawrence is a god amongst men. He’s the best nose tackle in football, and it isn’t particularly close. But he’s tired. You can see it in the fourth quarter of games where the opposing run game starts picking up four or five yards a clip.
A realistic NY Giants mock draft needs to prioritize a running mate for "Sexy Dexy." You can't ask a 340-pound human to play 80% of the snaps and still expect him to pass-rush like a defensive end. They need a twitchy 3-technique who can exploit the double teams Lawrence draws.
- Interior Pressure: The Giants lack a guy who can win one-on-ones when Lawrence is being triple-teamed.
- Cornerback Depth: Beyond Deonte Banks, it’s a lot of "wait and see."
- The Safety Gap: Ever since Xavier McKinney left, the back end of the defense hasn't had that "eraser" who can fix mistakes.
The secondary is particularly terrifying. In a division with CeeDee Lamb and A.J. Brown, you can’t show up with "just okay" corners. Banks has the physical tools, but he needs a veteran presence or a high-pedigree rookie on the other side to keep offenses from just picking on the "other guy" all afternoon.
Evaluating the 2026 Prospect Pool
When we look at the specific players popping up in NY Giants mock draft cycles, a few names keep surfacing. This isn't just random guessing; it's based on where the Giants' scouts have been spending their Saturdays.
The Big Ten has been a frequent destination for the Giants' front office. They love the "pro-ready" builds coming out of schools like Michigan and Iowa. These guys might not always have the highest "ceiling," but they have the highest "floor." For a team that has missed on too many high-risk picks, high-floor players are incredibly seductive.
✨ Don't miss: A qué horas juega Chivas hoy: Horarios, canales y lo que nadie te dice de la alineación
Wide Receiver or Tight End?
Wait, didn't they just get Malik Nabers? Yes. But look at the elite offenses in the league. They don't have one weapon; they have three. If the draft falls a certain way and a dominant "big slot" receiver or a mismatch-nightmare tight end is available, the Giants have to consider it.
Daboll’s system thrives when he can create mismatches. Right now, if you bracket Nabers, the offense stalls. Adding a 6'4" target who can win in the red zone would change the entire geometry of the field. It makes life easier for whoever is playing quarterback. It opens up the run game. It’s a force multiplier.
The "Best Player Available" Trap
There is a loud contingent of fans who want the Giants to strictly follow the "Best Player Available" (BPA) mantra. It sounds good on paper. It sounds like something a smart person would say on a podcast. In reality, it's a luxury the Giants don't have.
If the BPA is a wide receiver but your offensive line is a sieve, you’re just buying a Ferrari to park it in a driveway made of quicksand. The Giants have to balance "value" with "catastrophic need."
The linebacker corps is a perfect example. Bobby Okereke is a stud. But the guys around him? It’s a rotating cast of characters. If a dynamic, sideline-to-sideline linebacker is available in the second round, that might be a better pick than a "higher rated" receiver who won't see the ball because the QB is on his back.
The Value of the Second Round
Historically, the Giants have found some of their best value in the second round. Think back to guys like Osi Umenyiora or Sterling Shepard. In any NY Giants mock draft, the pick at 35 or 40 is often more indicative of the team's long-term vision than the flashier pick at 7.
This year, the second round looks deep at edge rusher. Kayvon Thibodeaux has shown flashes, and Brian Burns was a massive investment, but you can never have enough guys who can hunt the quarterback. A "NASCAR" package with three or four legitimate rushers is how the Giants won two Super Bowls. Maybe it's time to go back to the blueprint.
Addressing the "Culture" Factor
Joe Schoen and Brian Daboll talk a lot about "Giants people." It’s a bit cliché, but it matters for the draft. They want guys who can handle the New York media and the pressure of playing in a stadium shared with another team.
This usually means they shy away from players with major "character red flags," even if the talent is undeniable. When you’re reading a NY Giants mock draft, you can usually cross off the guys who had multiple suspensions in college. It’s just not how this regime operates. They want high-football-IQ players who are obsessed with the game.
This narrow focus can be a double-edged sword. It creates a stable locker room, but does it pass up on the "game-changers" who might be a little more difficult to manage? It’s a fair question. The Giants have been "stable" for a few years now, but they haven't been "dangerous."
Breaking Down the Draft Day Trade Scenarios
Don't be surprised if the Giants are aggressive. Schoen has shown he’s willing to move around. If they are sitting at pick 9 and their "guy" is sliding, they will jump up to 5. Conversely, if the top four QBs are gone and the board looks flat, trading back to pick up an extra second-rounder in 2027 is a very "Schoen" move.
The draft is a game of probability. The more picks you have, the higher your chance of hitting on a starter. For a team with as many holes as the Giants, volume might be the smartest play.
- The Trade Up: Only happens for a "transcendent" QB.
- The Stand Pat: Take the best offensive lineman or edge rusher available.
- The Trade Down: Occurs if a QB-hungry team wants to jump back into the top 10, allowing the Giants to stockpile mid-round assets.
Most people hate the trade-down scenario because it’s not "exciting." It doesn't sell jerseys on draft night. But it’s how you build a roster that doesn't collapse the moment one starter gets an ankle sprain.
How to Follow the Giants Draft Process
If you want to stay ahead of the curve, stop looking at the mock drafts that come out in November. They are based on outdated information. Instead, watch the Senior Bowl. Watch the Combine drills—specifically the 10-yard split for linemen and the change-of-direction stats for defensive backs.
The Giants' front office is obsessed with "functional athleticism." They don't care about a 40-yard dash time for a defensive tackle as much as they care about his "short-area burst."
Keep an eye on the visits. The "30 visits" are the biggest "tell" in the NFL. If the Giants bring in five different offensive guards for private workouts, you can bet your house they are taking one in the first three rounds. It’s the one time the team actually shows its hand.
Putting the Pieces Together
Ultimately, a NY Giants mock draft is just an educated guess. But the most "educated" guesses right now suggest a massive shift toward the trenches. Whether it’s a new protector for a new QB or a massive body to help Dexter Lawrence, the 2026 draft will be defined by size and strength.
The Giants are tired of being pushed around. You can hear it in Daboll’s press conferences. You can see it in the way they’ve targeted physical blockers in free agency. They want to be a "bully" team again.
What you should do next:
- Audit the Current Roster: Check the "dead cap" hits for 2026 on OverTheCap. It will tell you exactly which positions the Giants must replace via the draft because they can't afford them in free agency.
- Track the "30 Visits": As we get closer to April, look for the list of players visiting MetLife Stadium. Usually, at least 2-3 of their draft picks come from this list.
- Watch the Trench Play: In the remaining games of the season, don't watch the ball. Watch the right side of the Giants' offensive line and the interior of the defensive line. Those "ugly" snaps are where the 2026 draft will be won or lost.
The draft isn't just a day in April; it’s a year-long puzzle. For the Giants, the pieces are starting to look like a lot of heavy lifting in the trenches and a potential "reset" button at the most important position in sports. Whether they have the guts to pull the trigger is another story entirely.