Honestly, if you grew up in the Rust Belt or anywhere near the shadow of the Golden Dome or Happy Valley, you know the vibe. Notre Dame Penn State isn't just a football game. It’s a collision of identities. It’s the Midwest versus the East Coast, the independent powerhouse versus the Big Ten giant, and two of the most stubborn fanbases in the history of the sport arguing about who actually has the better "tradition."
People forget how intense this got in the late 80s and early 90s.
It wasn't just about rankings. It was about Lou Holtz and Joe Paterno—two legends who couldn't have been more different if they tried—staring each other down across the sidelines. When these two teams meet, the atmosphere changes. The air gets a little thinner. Even though they don’t play every year like they used to, the friction is still there.
The History Most People Get Wrong
A lot of younger fans think this is just some random non-conference matchup that happens every few decades. Wrong. Between 1981 and 1992, Notre Dame and Penn State played every single year. It was a staple. It was the game you circled on the calendar because it usually had massive national title implications.
Think back to 1986.
Penn State was ranked No. 3, Notre Dame was unranked but dangerous under a first-year coach named Lou Holtz. The Irish almost pulled the upset in South Bend, but the Nittany Lions escaped 24-19 and eventually went on to win the National Championship. That game set the tone for a decade of high-stakes drama. It wasn't just football; it was a battle for the soul of the Northeast and the Great Lakes.
Then you have the 1990 clash. No. 1 Notre Dame. No. 18 Penn State. In South Bend.
The Irish were rolling, looking like a lock for another title run. Penn State came in and absolutely stunned them 24-21. It’s still one of the most painful losses in Irish history. It’s games like that which cemented the Notre Dame Penn State rivalry as something special. It wasn't a "friendly" rivalry. It was competitive, often bitter, and deeply respected by both sides.
Why the Series Went Cold
So, why did we stop seeing this every year? It’s basically about the Big Ten and independence.
When Penn State joined the Big Ten in 1993, their schedule got locked down. They had eight, then nine conference games to worry about. Notre Dame, ever the stubborn independent, wanted to keep their national schedule—playing USC, Navy, and a rotation of ACC and Pac-12 (at the time) teams. The math just stopped working. Fans on both sides have been begging for a consistent home-and-home series for years, but college football scheduling is a nightmare of contracts and television revenue.
- Penn State has their Big Ten grind.
- Notre Dame has their ACC "partnership" requirements.
- The windows for elite non-conference games are tiny.
It’s a shame, really. There’s a specific grit to this matchup that you don’t get when Notre Dame plays a school from out West or when Penn State plays a generic non-conference opponent from the MAC.
The 2006-2007 "Renewal" Tease
We got a taste of it again in the mid-2000s. In 2006, No. 4 Notre Dame hammered Penn State 41-17. Brady Quinn was at his peak, and the Irish looked unstoppable. But the very next year? Penn State got their revenge in Happy Valley, winning 31-10 against a struggling Irish squad. That 2007 game was actually the first time Penn State had beaten Notre Dame at home since the early 80s. The "White Out" wasn't quite what it is today, but the energy was terrifying.
Breaking Down the Recruiting Wars
The rivalry isn't just on the grass. It’s in the living rooms of high school kids in Pennsylvania, New Jersey, and Ohio. This is where the Notre Dame Penn State battle truly lives every single day of the year.
Pennsylvania has always been a primary pipeline for Notre Dame. Think about Joe Montana (New Eagle, PA) or Raghib "Rocket" Ismail (Wilkes-Barre, PA). When Notre Dame reaches into PA and pulls out a five-star recruit, it drives the Penn State faithful crazy. Conversely, when Penn State lands a big-time recruit that the Irish were coveting, it’s a massive statement of regional dominance.
James Franklin and Marcus Freeman are currently locked in this exact struggle. They are both elite recruiters. They both pitch "lifestyle" and "tradition." If you're a top-tier linebacker in the Northeast, you’re getting calls from both South Bend and State College. The overlap in their recruiting boards is almost 1:1.
What a Modern Matchup Looks Like
If these two played tomorrow, what happens?
You’re looking at two of the best defenses in the country, usually. Penn State has turned into "Linebacker U" again, and Notre Dame’s secondary under Freeman has been elite. It would be a low-scoring, physical, "three yards and a cloud of dust" kind of game, regardless of what modern spread offenses they’re running. It’s the DNA of the programs.
- Physicality in the trenches.
- High-level special teams play.
- A massive emphasis on not turning the ball over.
- Crowds that make it impossible for the opposing QB to hear a thing.
The last time they met, the world was a different place. Now, with the 12-team playoff, the stakes for a potential Notre Dame Penn State game are higher than ever. Imagine a quarterfinal matchup in December at a snowy Beaver Stadium or a frozen Notre Dame Stadium. That’s the stuff of legends.
The Cultural Divide
It’s funny to look at how the fanbases perceive each other.
Notre Dame fans often see themselves as the "national" brand—the team of the people, the team with the movie (Rudy, obviously), and the team that doesn't need a conference. Penn State fans see themselves as the "unrivaled" blue-collar powerhouse of the North. They pride themselves on the "White Out," the 107,000 people screaming in unison, and a sense of community that feels more localized and intense than Notre Dame’s global reach.
There is a mutual respect there, but it’s the kind of respect where you still want to beat the other guy by thirty points.
The "Snow Bowl" and Other Legends
We can't talk about these two without mentioning the 1992 "Snow Bowl." It was the last game of the regular season series. It was freezing. It was snowing. It was perfect. Jerome "The Bus" Bettis was running through the slush, and Notre Dame won a 17-16 thriller. That game basically sums up the entire rivalry. It was ugly, it was cold, and it came down to a single point.
That’s what’s missing from the current college football landscape: these regional, historic battles that feel like they actually mean something to the people living there.
Is a Permanent Series Possible?
People keep asking if we’ll ever see them play every year again.
The short answer? Don't hold your breath, but don't lose hope. With the Big Ten expanding and the College Football Playoff changing how teams think about "strength of schedule," there is more incentive to play "big" games. A loss to a top-10 Penn State doesn't kill Notre Dame's season anymore. A loss to Notre Dame doesn't ruin Penn State's Big Ten title hopes.
The obstacle is still the schedule. Notre Dame is locked into five ACC games a year. They have USC and Navy as permanent rivals. That leaves very few spots for a game of this magnitude. But money talks. The TV ratings for a Notre Dame Penn State game would be astronomical. Networks like NBC, CBS, and FOX would sell their souls for a primetime Saturday night slot featuring the Irish and the Nittany Lions.
Surprising Stats You Should Know
While everyone focuses on the 80s, the overall series is remarkably close.
👉 See also: When Does Michigan Play Football Today: Clearing Up the Schedule Confusion
- Total games played: 19
- Notre Dame wins: 9
- Penn State wins: 9
- Ties: 1
It is literally a dead heat. You cannot get more balanced than that. The 1-1-1 tie happened way back in 1913, which feels like a different universe, but every game since then has been a tug-of-war for the lead.
The scoring margins are usually razor-thin. Excluding a couple of blowouts in the mid-2000s and late 80s, most of these games are decided by a touchdown or less. It’s a testament to how similar these programs are in terms of talent and coaching.
The Verdict on the Rivalry
Is it a "rivalry" if they don't play every year?
Yes.
Ask any Penn State fan who they hate the most outside of Ohio State and Michigan. Notre Dame is usually in the top three. Ask a Notre Dame fan about the most intimidating places to play. Happy Valley is always on the list. The distance between the two campuses is only about 450 miles. That’s a six-hour drive through some of the most football-obsessed country in America.
The Notre Dame Penn State connection is built on a shared history of excellence and a shared geography of grit. It doesn't need a trophy or a corporate sponsor name to make it real. The fans make it real. The history of Paterno and Holtz makes it real. The recruiting battles in the Lehigh Valley make it real.
Actionable Ways to Track This Matchup
If you want to stay on top of when these two might actually meet again, or just keep up with the ongoing rivalry, here is what you should do:
- Monitor the 2028-2030 Schedule Releases: Athletic directors are currently in talks for non-conference games in the late 2020s. This is the most likely window for a new home-and-home agreement.
- Follow Recruiting in PA and NJ: Watch sites like 247Sports or On3. When a four-star kid from Philadelphia has "Notre Dame" and "Penn State" as his top two, that is where the rivalry is currently being fought.
- Check the Playoff Rankings: In the new 12-team format, these two are frequently projected to meet in the opening rounds. A neutral-site playoff game in Indianapolis or even a home-site game is statistically very likely in the next three years.
- Watch the "Common Opponents": Since they both play teams like Ohio State, USC (now Big Ten), and various ACC schools, you can gauge their relative strength by how they perform against the same competition.
The next time the blue jerseys of Penn State and the gold helmets of Notre Dame are on the same field, the college football world will stop to watch. It’s a throwback to a time when the game was played in the mud and the stakes were everything. Until then, the debate continues in the sports bars and message boards across the Northeast.
Keep an eye on the official athletic department Twitter (X) accounts for "Series Announcement" leaks, as these high-profile deals often get teased months before the formal press release. If you're a fan of either team, start saving up now—tickets for the next meeting will easily be the most expensive in the region.