You’re standing on a pier at 41st Street. The Hudson River smells like salt and diesel. Honestly, it’s a bit chaotic, but that’s just Pier 81 for you. Most people think getting a decent lobster roll in Manhattan requires sitting in a cramped, overpriced bistro in the West Village where the tables are the size of postage stamps. They're wrong. There’s this floating lobster shack called North River Lobster Company New York, and it’s basically a three-story boat that sails around while you eat. It’s weirdly genius.
New York City has plenty of tourist traps. You know the ones—the places where the food is secondary to the "view," and the view is mostly other tourists' heads. This isn't quite that. It’s a legitimate sailing vessel. It moves. You feel the engines thrumming under your feet. It’s a "floating lobster shack," and while that sounds like a marketing gimmick, it actually solves the biggest problem with summer in the city: the heat. Out on the water, the temperature drops by about ten degrees, and the breeze is real.
What Most People Get Wrong About the Sailing Schedule
People show up and think it’s a standard dinner cruise. It isn’t. Don’t expect a formal white-linen gala where you’re trapped for four hours. North River Lobster Company operates more like a ferry with a very expensive kitchen.
They do short loops. Usually, the boat stays out for about 45 to 60 minutes. It heads down toward the Intrepid, gives you a look at the skyline, and then turns back. The boarding process is the part where people lose their minds. You can't just wander on whenever you want. There’s a boarding window. If you miss the boat, you’re sitting on the pier for an hour waiting for the next cycle. Check the schedule on their site before you leave your apartment. Seriously.
The best part? You don't always need a reservation, though they’re recommended if you have a group. If you're solo or a duo, you can often snag a spot at the bar. But if you’re looking for those prime seats on the top deck—the "Sky Deck"—you better get there early or be prepared to hover like a seagull.
The Menu: It’s Not Just About the Lobster
Let's talk about the food because that's why you're here. The North River Lobster Company New York menu is built around the "Shelly," their signature lobster roll. It’s a quarter-pound of chilled lobster. Is it the best lobster roll in the entire world? Maybe not if you’re comparing it to a shack in Kennebunkport, but for a boat in the Hudson, it’s surprisingly solid.
They use a toasted brioche bun. This is non-negotiable. If a lobster roll comes on a standard hot dog bun that hasn't seen a pat of butter, it’s a crime. Here, it’s buttery. The meat is tossed in a light lemon herb mayo.
- The Lower East Side Roll: This one has everything bagel seasoning. It sounds like a "New York" cliché, but it works.
- The Maine Roll: This is the purist's choice. Minimal interference.
- The Norwegian: This one has smoked salmon and capers. It's a bit of a curveball.
They also have "The Shelly" in a jumbo size. It’s massive. Like, "I need a nap immediately" massive. If you aren't a lobster fan, the menu has some backup options like burgers and truffle fries. But honestly, if you’re going to a floating lobster shack and ordering a burger, you’re kind of missing the point. The fries are decent, though. Crispy. Salty. They handle the humidity better than you’d expect.
✨ Don't miss: Why Dog House Albuquerque New Mexico Still Rules the Footlong Game
The Bar Scene and the "Mason Jar" Culture
Drinks are a huge part of the draw. They serve cocktails in these massive mason jars. It’s very "summer in the city" aesthetic. You’ll see a lot of people holding the "Pink Lady" or some version of a spiked lemonade while staring at the New Jersey skyline.
Prices are... well, they're New York City boat prices. Expect to pay a premium. You’re paying for the fuel, the crew, and the fact that you’re drinking a margarita while passing the Statue of Liberty in the distance. Is it cheap? No. Is it fun? Yeah, usually.
A Quick Tip on Seating
The boat has three levels.
- The Main Deck: This is indoors and climate-controlled. Good if it’s 95 degrees and the humidity is 100%.
- The Mid Deck: Half-covered. Best of both worlds.
- The Sky Deck: Completely open. This is where the party is. It’s also where you’ll get sunburnt in twelve minutes if you aren't careful.
If you want a quiet, romantic dinner, this might not be the spot. It gets loud. There’s music. People are taking selfies. It’s high energy. If you want a vibe that feels like a backyard BBQ but on the Hudson River, you're in the right place.
Logistics: Getting to Pier 81
Getting to the North River Lobster Company isn't the most convenient trek. It’s located at 12th Avenue and West 41st Street. If you’re taking the subway, you’re looking at a long walk from Times Square or the 42nd St-Port Authority station. It’s about 15 to 20 minutes of hoofing it past the Javits Center and various construction sites.
Cabs or Ubers are easier, but traffic on 12th Avenue is a nightmare during rush hour. If you're planning a Friday night trip, leave way earlier than you think you need to.
The Cost of the "Sailing Fee"
One thing that trips people up is the boarding pass. You don't just pay for the food. There is a "Sailing Fee." Usually, it’s around $10 to $15 depending on the day and season. Think of it as your ticket for the boat ride. Some people get annoyed by this, but considering a standard sightseeing cruise in NYC can cost $40 or more, paying fifteen bucks to get on a boat where you can also buy a lobster roll is actually a decent hack for seeing the city from the water.
They offer "Season Passes" too. It sounds crazy, but if you live in Hell’s Kitchen or Midtown West and want a reliable place to take out-of-town guests all summer, it pays for itself in three trips.
👉 See also: How Do You Spell Aunty: Why Both Versions Are Technically Right
When to Go (And When to Avoid It)
Timing is everything.
- Avoid: Saturday afternoons in July. It’s crowded. You’ll be standing in line. You’ll be fighting for a spot at the rail.
- Target: Tuesday or Wednesday evenings. The "Sunset Sails" are the gold standard. Seeing the sun go down behind the Jersey City skyline while the lights of Manhattan start to flicker on is genuinely cool. Even for cynical New Yorkers who have seen it a thousand times, it hits different from the water.
Rain usually doesn't stop the boat, but it does ruin the Sky Deck experience. They have plastic siding they can pull down on the middle deck, but if the weather looks like a monsoon, maybe reschedule. The Hudson can get a little choppy, though the boat is large enough that you won't feel like you're in the middle of The Perfect Storm.
Comparing the North River Experience to Others
There are other "oyster barges" and "boat bars" in the city. You’ve got Grand Banks at Pier 25 and Pilot in Brooklyn Bridge Park. Those are stationary. They stay tied to the dock. They are also significantly more "upscale" (read: more expensive and harder to get a table).
North River Lobster Company New York is the more populist version. It’s more casual. It actually leaves the dock. While Grand Banks feels like a fashion shoot, North River feels like a party. It’s better for groups. It’s better if you actually want to move on the water.
Reality Check: The Service
It’s a boat. The staff is working in a galley kitchen and running up and down stairs. Sometimes the service is lightning-fast; sometimes, when the boat is at capacity, it can take a while for your drink to show up. Go in with the mindset that you’re there for the experience, not a five-star fine dining service. Be patient. Tip well. They’re dealing with a lot of wind and moving parts.
📖 Related: Lowe's Father's Day Sale: What Most People Get Wrong
Practical Steps for Your Visit
If you're actually going to do this, here is the sequence to make it not suck.
First, check the weather. If it's a "Code Red" humidity day, plan for the indoor deck. Second, buy your boarding pass online in advance. It saves you from standing in the ticket line at the pier. Third, arrive at least 30 minutes before your scheduled "sailing" time. The boat leaves on the dot. They won't wait for you just because your Uber got stuck behind a delivery truck.
Once you’re on board, head straight for the bar or your table and get your order in immediately. The kitchen gets slammed the moment the boat starts moving because everyone has the same idea at the same time. If you order within the first five minutes of boarding, you’ll have your food by the time the boat hits the main channel. Then you can spend the rest of the cruise just relaxing with your drink.
Bring a light jacket, even in August. The wind on the Hudson is surprisingly chilly once the sun starts to dip. Also, wear shoes with some grip. It’s a boat deck; it can get wet, and high heels are a recipe for a twisted ankle if the boat hits a wake from a passing ferry.
Final Verdict
The North River Lobster Company is a solid choice for anyone who wants the "New York Waterfront" experience without the stuffiness of a formal cruise. The food is reliable, the views are unbeatable for the price, and there’s something inherently fun about eating a lobster roll while the city slides past you. It’s one of those rare spots that works for both a first date and a visit from your parents. Just watch the departure clock and don't forget your sunglasses.
Actionable Takeaways
- Check the Sailing Schedule: Sailing times change based on the day of the week. Do not assume it’s a constant loop.
- Pre-Purchase Passes: Buy your boarding pass on their official website to skip the pier-side kiosk.
- Strategic Boarding: Aim for the 6:00 PM or 7:00 PM slots for the best lighting and temperature.
- Order Early: Beat the "departure rush" by ordering your food and drinks the second you step onto the deck.