Eight seconds. That is all it took for one of the most gifted defensive players in NFL history to nearly flush his entire career down the drain. If you were watching Thursday Night Football on November 14, 2019, you probably remember the pit in your stomach when it happened. The Cleveland Browns were actually winning—a rarity back then—beating the Pittsburgh Steelers 21-7. The game was essentially over.
Then, Myles Garrett buried Mason Rudolph into the turf.
It looked like a standard, albeit late, hit at first. But when they didn't get up, the world shifted. Rudolph felt Garrett lingered too long. He grabbed at Garrett's helmet. Garrett, a man who looks like he was carved out of granite, didn't just push back. He ripped Rudolph’s helmet clean off his head.
What followed was the Myles Garrett helmet swing, a moment of raw, unchecked aggression that looked more like a medieval battle than a professional football game. Garrett wound up and cracked the crown of the helmet onto Rudolph’s unprotected skull.
The Fallout Nobody Saw Coming
The immediate reaction was pure chaos. Joe Buck, calling the game for Fox, sounded genuinely horrified. He called it "one of the worst things I've ever seen on a professional sports field." He wasn't exaggerating. Within minutes, the internet was a wildfire of "did he just do that?"
📖 Related: Jake Paul Mike Tyson Tattoo: What Most People Get Wrong
Maurkice Pouncey, the Steelers' center, went into full-blown protector mode. He tackled Garrett, punched his helmeted head, and kicked him while he was down. It was ugly. It was primal. Honestly, it felt like the NFL’s "Malice at the Palace" moment.
The league didn't wait around. By the next morning, the hammer came down.
- Myles Garrett: Suspended indefinitely (eventually missing the final 6 games of 2019).
- Maurkice Pouncey: 3 games (later reduced to 2).
- Larry Ogunjobi: 1 game for shoving a helmetless Rudolph from behind.
- Fines: Both teams were docked $250,000 each.
Garrett lost about $1.2 million in game checks. That’s a lot of money for a few seconds of rage.
Why the Myles Garrett Helmet Swing Still Haunts the AFC North
You can't talk about this without mentioning the "he said, she said" that followed. During his appeal, Garrett dropped a bombshell. He claimed Rudolph sparked the fuse by using a racial slur.
👉 See also: What Place Is The Phillies In: The Real Story Behind the NL East Standings
Rudolph denied it instantly. The NFL investigated, checked the mics, and found "no evidence" to support the claim. But because there were no microphones right there in the dirt, a segment of fans will always believe Garrett, while others will always see him as a guy trying to justify an unjustifiable act.
It’s a stain that doesn’t quite wash out.
Even though Garrett has since won a Defensive Player of the Year award and became a perennial All-Pro, the "helmet swing" is usually the second or third sentence in any long-form profile about him. He’s the guy who used a piece of safety equipment as a lethal weapon.
The Legal Side of the Brawl
People kept asking: Why wasn't he arrested? Technically, hitting someone in the head with a five-pound blunt object is assault. In Ohio, where the game took place, it fits the legal definition of "knowingly causing physical harm."
✨ Don't miss: Huskers vs Michigan State: What Most People Get Wrong About This Big Ten Rivalry
However, the legal system usually stays out of the lines of professional sports. Unless there is a "gross" departure from the game—like a guy coming off the bench with a literal weapon—prosecutors let the league handle it. Rudolph’s legal team briefly mentioned "exploring options," but they eventually backed off. They let it remain an NFL matter.
What Most People Get Wrong
A lot of people think this was a totally unprovoked attack. It wasn't. That doesn't make it right, but context matters if you want to understand why it happened.
- The Tussle: Rudolph started the physical escalation by trying to pull Garrett's helmet off first while they were on the ground.
- The Chase: After his helmet was ripped off, Rudolph didn't stay back. He chased Garrett. He was arguably looking for a fight just as much as Garrett was until the swing connected.
- The Damage: Amazingly, Rudolph wasn't seriously injured. He had a knot on his head, but he avoided a major concussion or skull fracture. If that helmet had landed an inch or two differently, we might be talking about a permanent disability or worse.
Moving Forward: Lessons for the League
The NFL used this incident to tighten up. They realized that "unnecessary roughness" is a broad term that doesn't quite cover "using equipment as a weapon."
If you are looking for actionable takeaways from this mess, look at how the league handles ejections now. They are much faster to toss players for non-football acts. They also updated the "Rule 12, Section 2, Article 17," which specifically covers using a helmet as a weapon.
For players and coaches, the lesson is basically "cool heads prevail." Garrett was at the peak of a 10-sack season. He was the frontrunner for DPOY. He threw it all away for a game that was already won.
What you can do next:
- Watch the mic'd up segments from that era to see the intensity of the Browns-Steelers rivalry.
- Research the "Albert Haynesworth stomp" from 2006 to see how the NFL’s punishment scale has evolved over the decades.
- Look into the 2021 post-game handshake between Garrett and Rudolph, which served as a quiet, formal end to the beef.