Biology is weird. Seriously. You think you know how animals work, and then you start looking into the genetics of a son of a donkey. People throw that phrase around—sometimes as a literal description, sometimes as a clunky translation of an insult—but the actual science of what happens when a donkey breeds with something else is fascinating. It’s not just about "making a mule."
There is a massive difference between a mule and a hinny. It basically comes down to which parent is which. If the father is a donkey, the offspring is a mule. If the mother is a donkey, you’ve got a hinny. They look different. They act different. They even have different reputations in the farming world.
Most people just assume a hybrid is a hybrid. It isn’t.
The Genetics of the Mule vs. the Hinny
When a male donkey (a jack) breeds with a female horse (a mare), you get the classic mule. This is the son of a donkey that helped build civilizations. Why? Because they are sturdy. They have the patience and the tough hooves of their father, combined with the size and strength of their mother.
Genetically, it's a bit of a mess, but a functional one. Horses have 64 chromosomes. Donkeys have 62. When they get together, the kid ends up with 63. That odd number is exactly why they are almost always sterile. Their bodies just don’t know how to divide that extra chromosome during meiosis.
But what about the hinny?
A hinny is the offspring of a male horse (a stallion) and a female donkey (a jenny). Even though the chromosome count is the same—63—the result is totally different. Hinnies are usually smaller. They have shorter ears and look more "horsy" than a mule. They are also notoriously difficult to produce. Stallions and jennies don't always "get along" as easily as jacks and mares do, and for some reason, the pregnancy is less likely to take.
Honestly, if you see a working animal in the field, it’s probably a mule. Hinnies are sort of the rare, accidental cousins of the equine world.
✨ Don't miss: Exactly What Month is Ramadan 2025 and Why the Dates Shift
Why Donkeys Are Smarter Than You Think
We have this stereotype that donkeys are stubborn. You’ve heard it a million times. "Stubborn as a mule."
It’s a lie.
What we call stubbornness is actually a highly developed sense of self-preservation. A horse is a prey animal that tends to bolt when it gets scared. It runs first and thinks later. A donkey? A donkey stops. It evaluates. If a donkey thinks a path is dangerous or a load is too heavy, it simply won't move. You can't whip a donkey into doing something it thinks will kill it.
That trait passes directly to the son of a donkey. Mules are prized by trail guides in places like the Grand Canyon specifically because they won't walk off a cliff just because you told them to. They are cautious. They are thinkers.
Experts like Meredith Hodges, who has spent decades training litle-known "lucky three" mules, point out that you have to earn a mule's trust. You don't "break" a mule like you break a horse. You negotiate with it. If you treat a mule like a machine, it will shut down. If you treat it like a partner, it will outwork any horse on the planet.
Survival of the Hardiest
The physical specs of these animals are ridiculous.
- Heat Tolerance: Donkeys originated in the African desert. Their offspring inherit a metabolism that handles heat way better than a purebred horse.
- Hoof Quality: Donkey hooves are upright and tough. They don't need shoes as often as horses do, especially in rocky terrain.
- Feeding: A mule or a hinny can survive on "poor" forage. They don't need the high-sugar, high-protein grains that performance horses require. They are incredibly efficient at extracting nutrients from dry brush.
- Longevity: It’s not uncommon for a mule to live into its 40s. A horse is lucky to hit 30.
I’ve talked to ranchers in the high desert who swear they’d never go back to horses for pack work. One guy told me his mule, "Festus," basically saved his life by refusing to cross a washed-out bridge in the middle of a night storm. The horse behind him tried to go and slipped. Festus stayed planted.
🔗 Read more: Dutch Bros Menu Food: What Most People Get Wrong About the Snacks
That’s the son of a donkey for you. It’s got a brain that works in overtime.
The Cultural Weight of the "Son of a Donkey"
Depending on where you are in the world, the term carries different weight. In parts of the Middle East and the Mediterranean, donkeys and their offspring are the backbone of the economy. They carry the water. They plow the steep hillsides where tractors can't go.
But the phrase has also been used as a derogatory term. In certain languages, calling someone the "son of a donkey" is a way of calling them stupid or stubborn. It’s a massive irony because, as we've established, donkeys are actually some of the most intelligent equines.
We tend to look down on things that are "half-breeds" or "beasts of burden," but history says otherwise. George Washington was obsessed with mules. He saw them as the future of American agriculture. He even requested a high-quality jack from the King of Spain to start his own breeding program at Mount Vernon. He knew that the son of a donkey was the only animal tough enough to build a new nation's infrastructure.
Misconceptions and Reality Checks
Let’s clear some things up.
First, mules aren't always sterile. There have been a handful of documented cases—around 60 in the last few centuries—where a female mule (a molly) has actually given birth. It’s a "one in a billion" genetic fluke, but it happens. When it does, it usually makes local news because it feels like a miracle.
Second, they aren't mean. A mule that kicks is usually a mule that has been mistreated. Because they remember everything, if you hit a mule, it will remember that for ten years. And it might wait for the perfect moment to remind you.
💡 You might also like: Draft House Las Vegas: Why Locals Still Flock to This Old School Sports Bar
Third, they are loud. If you’ve never heard a mule bray, it’s a terrifying mix of a horse's whinny and a donkey's "hee-haw." It’s a discordant, vibrating sound that can carry for miles.
Practical Insights for the Aspiring Owner
If you’re actually looking to get a son of a donkey—either a mule or a hinny—you need to change your mindset.
- Don't buy a "green" mule if you are a beginner. They are too smart for you. They will figure out your weaknesses in five minutes and spend the rest of the day exploiting them.
- Check the ears. The longer the ears, the more donkey blood is dominant. This usually translates to better heat tolerance but more "thinking" before acting.
- Look at the hooves. If the hooves look narrow and boxy, that’s the donkey influence. It’s great for rocks, but they can be sensitive to overly wet, muddy pastures which can lead to thrush.
- Find a specialized vet. Not all horse vets are comfortable with mules. Their reaction to anesthesia is different. If a vet doses a mule exactly like a horse of the same weight, the mule might wake up mid-surgery or stay under way too long.
You have to respect the lineage. The son of a donkey isn't a "lesser" horse. It is a specialized, high-intelligence hybrid designed for endurance.
Whether you call it a mule, a hinny, or just a stubborn friend, these animals are proof that sometimes the "mix" is better than the "pure" version. They represent a weird, beautiful glitch in nature that humans have relied on for thousands of years.
To get started with these animals, your best bet is to visit a local "Mule Day" or a draft animal showcase. Talk to the handlers. Watch how they move. You'll notice quickly that the people who work with them don't just own them—they respect them.
Next Steps for Potential Owners:
- Research the "Longears" community in your region to find reputable breeders.
- Study the "donkey-logic" training methods which focus on pressure and release rather than dominance.
- Ensure your fencing is higher than it would be for a horse; mules are incredible jumpers from a standing start.
- Check local livestock ordinances, as some suburban areas classify donkeys and mules differently than horses due to their vocalizations.
- Evaluate your pasture; ensure you have a "dry lot" available to prevent your mule from getting founder (laminitis) on lush grass, as their metabolism is extremely efficient.