Martin Scorsese’s 2002 epic is a bloody, soot-covered masterpiece that makes 1860s Manhattan look like a circle of hell. But honestly, the movie Gangs of New York true story is even weirder and more chaotic than the film suggests. You've got Bill the Butcher, the Dead Rabbits, and the Draft Riots—all real. However, the way they collided was a bit different than the cinematic rivalry between Leonardo DiCaprio and Daniel Day-Lewis.
Five Points was a nightmare.
It was a slum built on a filled-in pond called the Collect, which basically turned the ground into a swamp of rotting organic matter and industrial waste. The buildings were literally sinking. In this filth, thousands of people were packed into tenements, creating a pressure cooker of ethnic tension and political corruption. If you were an Irish immigrant stepping off a boat in the 1840s, you weren't met with open arms. You were met with a club to the head.
The Real Bill the Butcher Wasn't a Civil War Villain
Daniel Day-Lewis played William "Bill the Butcher" Cutting as a terrifying, top-hat-wearing nationalist who ruled the city during the Civil War. In reality, the man he was based on, William Poole, died years before the movie's climax.
Poole was a leader of the Bowery Boys and a champion bare-knuckle boxer. He hated the Irish with a passion that bordered on pathological. But he didn't die in a massive street battle during the 1863 Draft Riots. He was shot in a bar. Stanwix Hall, to be precise. It was a hit carried out by associates of his rival, John Morrissey.
Poole’s final words were supposedly, "I die a true American." He was a nativist through and through, a member of the "Know-Nothing" party, which was basically a political movement founded on the idea that if you weren't born in the U.S. and Protestant, you didn't belong. Scorsese shifted the timeline because a movie about a guy who dies in 1855 doesn't fit a narrative about the 1863 riots. It’s a creative choice, sure, but it changes the stakes. The real Bill wasn't fighting a war for the soul of America in the 1860s; he was already in the ground.
🔗 Read more: Mike Judge Presents: Tales from the Tour Bus Explained (Simply)
Hell-Cat Maggie and the Myths of the Five Points
Remember the woman with the sharpened teeth and brass fingernails?
Hell-Cat Maggie.
She's one of those figures where the movie Gangs of New York true story blurs into urban legend. Herbert Asbury wrote about her in his 1927 book, The Gangs of New York, which served as Scorsese’s primary source. Asbury was a journalist who loved a good story, and he didn't mind if the facts were a little thin.
According to the lore, Maggie was a fierce fighter for the Dead Rabbits. Did she actually file her teeth into points? Probably not. But the idea of her mattered. The Five Points was a place where gender roles were often tossed aside in the name of survival. Women were just as likely to be involved in the "swill milk" trade or the localized gang wars as the men. The "Dead Rabbits" themselves were a real gang, though their name likely came from a mistranslation of the Irish word "dod raibéad," meaning a giant, troublesome person. They didn't actually carry a dead rabbit on a pike into every battle, but the imagery was too good for Scorsese to pass up.
The Draft Riots: When the City Actually Burned
The climax of the film shows the Navy shelling New York City. That didn't happen. The Navy was there, and they had ships in the harbor, but they didn't level the Five Points with broadsides.
💡 You might also like: Big Brother 27 Morgan: What Really Happened Behind the Scenes
However, the real riots were arguably more horrific than the movie portrayed.
When the Conscription Act was passed in 1863, it allowed wealthy men to pay $300 to avoid the draft. That was a year's salary for a laborer. The poor Irish, who were already being treated like second-class citizens, were told they had to go die in a war to free enslaved people who would then come north and compete with them for low-wage jobs. It was a tinderbox.
The riots lasted for four days. It wasn't just gang-on-gang violence. It was a full-scale massacre. The primary targets weren't the "Nativists" like Bill the Butcher—they were Black New Yorkers. The Colored Orphan Asylum on Fifth Avenue was burned to the ground. Black men were lynched from lampposts. The police were completely overwhelmed, and eventually, the Union Army had to be called in straight from the Battle of Gettysburg to restore order at the point of a bayonet.
Politics, Tammany Hall, and "Big Tim" Sullivan
You can't talk about the Five Points without talking about the machine.
Tammany Hall ran the city. They realized early on that if they could control the Irish vote, they could control the treasury. This is where the film gets things mostly right. The gangs weren't just criminals; they were the "muscle" for political parties. On election day, gangs would practice "repeating"—dressing in different clothes and voting at multiple precincts. If you tried to vote for the wrong candidate, a Dead Rabbit or a Bowery Boy would ensure you didn't make it to the ballot box in one piece.
📖 Related: The Lil Wayne Tracklist for Tha Carter 3: What Most People Get Wrong
Scorsese uses the character of Boss Tweed to represent this, played with a greasy charm by Jim Broadbent. Tweed was real, and his corruption was legendary. He famously said, "I don't care who does the electing, so long as I do the nominating." The movie simplifies the relationship, but the reality was a symbiotic circle of graft: the gangs got protection from the police, and the politicians got the votes they needed to stay in power.
Why the Five Points Disappeared
By the end of the 19th century, the Five Points was gone. Not because the gangs stopped fighting, but because of urban renewal—or what they called it back then, "slum clearing."
Jacob Riis, a muckraking journalist, published How the Other Half Lives in 1890. His flash photography showed the middle class the true horrors of the tenements. The public outcry led to the demolition of the worst areas, like Mulberry Bend, which was replaced by a park. Today, if you visit the site of the Five Points, you’ll find the New York Supreme Court and other government buildings. The blood and the mud are buried under layers of concrete and bureaucracy.
How to Explore the Real History Today
If you're fascinated by the history of 19th-century New York, you don't have to rely on Hollywood. There are actual places you can visit to see what remains of that era.
- The Tenement Museum: Located on the Lower East Side, this is the closest you can get to seeing how people actually lived in the 1860s. They’ve preserved apartments exactly as they were.
- Green-Wood Cemetery: You can visit the grave of William Poole (the real Bill the Butcher) in Brooklyn. His headstone is a popular spot for history buffs.
- The Old St. Patrick's Cathedral: Located on Mott Street, this was the heart of the Irish Catholic community during the riots. The brick walls still show where the community had to defend themselves against nativist mobs.
- Read the Source Material: Pick up Herbert Asbury’s The Gangs of New York. Just remember to take it with a grain of salt—it’s half history and half folklore, which is exactly how the legends of the Five Points were meant to be told.
The movie Gangs of New York true story reminds us that the city wasn't built by "great men" in clean suits. It was built by people fighting for space, bread, and an identity in a place that didn't want them. It was messy, violent, and incredibly complicated.
To truly understand the era, look past the cinematic battles and into the municipal records of the draft riots. Research the "Daylight Club" or the "Short Tails" to see how the gang culture evolved after the Civil War. The real Five Points may be gone, but the friction between "old" Americans and "new" arrivals is a story that New York—and the rest of the country—is still writing today. Focus on the primary documents from the New York Historical Society if you want the unvarnished truth of the 1863 violence.