You’ve seen the faces. Massive. Granite. Thomas Jefferson, Theodore Roosevelt, George Washington, and Abraham Lincoln staring out over the Black Hills of South Dakota. It’s an American icon, but honestly, carrying a mountain in your pocket is a lot easier than driving to Keystone. That’s where the Mount Rushmore National Memorial coin comes in, though "the" coin is actually several different coins minted over the last century.
People get confused. They think there’s just one. In reality, the U.S. Mint has returned to this specific landmark multiple times, and if you aren't careful, you’ll end up buying a common pocket change quarter when you thought you were getting a rare silver commemorative. Or vice versa.
Numismatics—the fancy word for coin collecting—isn't just about shiny metal. It's about history you can hold. When Gutzon Borglum started carving that mountain in 1927, he probably didn't realize his work would end up shrunk down onto copper-nickel clad and 90% silver discs.
The 1991 Commemorative: The One You Actually Want
If we’re talking about the "real" collector's piece, we have to look at 1991. This was the Golden Anniversary of the memorial. Congress authorized a special set of coins to celebrate the 50th year of the site's completion. They didn't just make one; they made a gold five-dollar piece, a silver dollar, and a copper-nickel half dollar.
The silver dollar is the standout. It’s 90% silver and 10% copper. On the front, you’ve got the mountain itself, but Marika Somogyi (the designer) added a wreath and some stars that give it a very "old world" prestige. The back is interesting because it features the Great Seal of the United States superimposed over a map of the country.
Most people don't realize that these weren't meant for laundry machines. They were sold to raise money. Specifically, a portion of the surcharges went to the Mount Rushmore National Memorial Society to help pay for much-needed renovations. It was a way for the public to fund the preservation of the "Shrine of Democracy" without just handing over tax dollars.
Prices vary. A lot. You can find the half-dollar version for a few bucks at a local coin shop because they made millions of them. The gold five-dollar coin? That's a different story. It contains about 0.24 troy ounces of gold. You aren't buying that for the "art" as much as you are for the melt value plus a collector's premium. It’s heavy. It’s yellow. It’s expensive.
That Quarter in Your Cup Holder
Then there’s the 2013 version. Part of the "America the Beautiful" Quarters Program. This is the Mount Rushmore National Memorial coin most people see in the wild.
It’s different.
Instead of showing the whole mountain from a distance, the 2013 quarter depicts workmen finishing the face of Thomas Jefferson. It’s a "behind the scenes" look at the construction. It’s cool because it honors the 400 laborers who actually climbed those stairs and handled the dynamite. They were paid about $8 a day during the Great Depression. Dangerous work.
If you find one in your change, it's worth twenty-five cents. Sorry. But! If you find one that is "S" minted (from San Francisco) and it looks mirror-like, you might have a Proof. Or, even better, if you have the 5-ounce silver bullion version of this same design, you’re holding a massive puck of silver that’s worth well over $150 depending on the current spot price.
🔗 Read more: Finding Your Spot: How to Actually Use a Perseid meteor shower map Without Getting Lost in the Dark
Why the 1991 Silver Dollar is Special
The 1991 silver dollar is unique because it was the first time the memorial appeared on a large-format silver coin. Before that, it was mostly stamps or postcards. The minting quality in the early 90s was undergoing a transition. You see a lot of "frosted" finishes on the cameo proofs that are just stunning.
Wait. Let’s talk about the "faces" for a second.
The 1991 design shows the mountain as it looks today. The 2013 design shows it under construction.
Collecting both gives you a timeline. A narrative.
Spotting a Fake (And What to Ignore)
Honestly, you don't see many "fake" Mount Rushmore quarters. It costs more to fake a quarter than the quarter is worth. But the 1991 Gold Five Dollar coin? Yeah, be careful there.
Always look for the mint mark.
- P is Philadelphia.
- D is Denver.
- S is San Francisco.
- W is West Point (usually for the gold).
If you’re buying on eBay, look for "NGC" or "PCGS" slabbed coins. These are third-party graders. They verify the coin is real and give it a grade from 1 to 70. A 70 is perfect. A 69 is almost perfect but has a tiny microscopic scratch that will drive you crazy once you know it’s there.
The "Shrine of Democracy" Controversy
You can't talk about the Mount Rushmore National Memorial coin without acknowledging that the mountain itself is a lightning rod. The Lakota Sioux call this area Tunkasila Sakpe (Six Grandfathers). It was taken from them after gold was discovered, despite treaties saying otherwise.
Collectors often debate whether these coins should exist. Some see them as a celebration of engineering and American ideals. Others see them as a permanent stamp of colonialism on sacred land.
Numismatics isn't just about "pretty birds" and "dead presidents." It’s about the friction of history. When you hold the 1991 silver dollar, you’re holding a representation of that friction. The coin doesn't mention the Sioux. It doesn't mention the controversy. It just shows the granite faces.
Investing vs. Hoarding
Don't buy the 2013 quarters thinking you'll retire on them. You won't.
If you want value, look for the "Silver Proof Sets" from 2013. These weren't made for circulation. They are 90% silver (or 99.9% in later years) and have a much lower mintage. Lower mintage usually means higher value over time because there are fewer to go around.
The 1991 set is also a solid buy because the silver dollar has a classic design that hasn't aged poorly. Some coins from the 70s and 80s look "dated" or "tacky." The Rushmore commemoratives feel timeless.
Current Market Reality
As of 2026, the market for "modern commemoratives" is steady but not explosive. You aren't going to see a 1000% return in two weeks. This is a slow game. It’s for people who like the history of the Black Hills and the artistry of the U.S. Mint.
How to Start Your Collection
If you're new to this, don't go out and spend $600 on a gold coin today. Start small.
- Grab a 2013 Quarter: Find the cleanest one you can in your change. Put it in a cardboard "2x2" holder.
- Buy the 1991 Half Dollar: It's usually under $10. It’s a great way to see the detail without breaking the bank.
- Graduate to the Silver Dollar: Look for the 1991-S Proof. It comes in a nice velvet box (usually).
- Research the "W" Mint Quarters: In 2019 and 2020, the mint put "W" marks on some quarters and dropped them into circulation. They didn't do this for the 2013 Rushmore, but it’s a good habit to check your change anyway.
The Mount Rushmore National Memorial coin is more than a souvenir. It’s a piece of a mountain that took 14 years to carve, reduced to the size of a thumbprint. Whether you're in it for the silver content or the historical weight, it's a staple for any American collection.
What to do next
First, check your "junk drawer" or your car's center console. You likely have a 2013 Mount Rushmore quarter right now. Take a close look at the reverse side. See those little guys hanging from ropes near Jefferson's ear? That level of detail is why this coin remains a favorite.
If you want to step up, head to a reputable online dealer or a local coin show. Ask for the "1991 Rushmore Commemorative." Don't pay more than the current silver melt value plus a $10-$15 premium for a raw (ungraded) silver dollar. If it's in a plastic slab and graded MS70 or PF70, expect to pay significantly more.
Finally, read up on the sculptor Gutzon Borglum. He was a complicated, often problematic figure, but his vision defined the American landscape. Understanding the man helps you understand the coin.
Keep your coins out of direct sunlight and away from PVC plastic flips, which can turn your silver green and ruin the value. Get some archival-safe holders and start your "mountain" collection the right way.