Honestly, if you were hanging out in the Bay Area in 1983, nobody knew that four kids with greasy hair were about to change the world. They were just the "alcoholica" guys. When you look at the Metallica Kill 'Em All tracklist today, it feels like a holy text for metalheads, but back then, it was just a desperate attempt to get some songs on tape before the money ran out.
The album is raw. It’s messy. It’s arguably the only "true" thrash album they ever made before they started getting all progressive and "artsy" with Ride the Lightning. But there’s so much drama baked into these ten tracks that most casual fans completely miss. We’re talking about ghosts in the studio, fired guitarists, and lyrics about gas station sex that had to be scrubbed clean.
The Tracklist That Almost Didn't Happen
You’ve probably heard the legend of the original title. The band wanted to call it Metal Up Your Ass. They even had the artwork ready—a hand coming out of a toilet with a dagger. Unsurprisingly, the distributors said, "No way." Bassist Cliff Burton, who was always the coolest guy in the room, got fed up and said, "Just kill 'em all."
That frustration gave us the title we know today.
When they finally sat down to record at Music America Studios in Rochester, New York, they only had $15,000. That’s nothing. They were living in a literal haunted mansion (according to Lars Ulrich, anyway) and recording in a basement. You can hear that "basement" energy in every note.
1. Hit the Lights
This is the ultimate opener. It actually started as a song from James Hetfield’s old band, Leather Charm. If you listen to the version on the Metal Massacre compilation, it sounds totally different. By the time it hit the album, it was faster, meaner, and served as a mission statement.
2. The Four Horsemen
This is where things get controversial. This song is basically Dave Mustaine’s baby. He called it "The Mechanix," and the original lyrics were about... well, a very horny gas station attendant. James Hetfield stepped in and rewrote them to be about the Apocalypse because, let’s be real, that's way more metal. Dave eventually released his version with Megadeth, and fans have been arguing about which one is better for forty years.
💡 You might also like: Not the Nine O'Clock News: Why the Satirical Giant Still Matters
3. Motorbreath
The shortest track on the record. It’s the only Metallica song credited solely to James Hetfield. It’s got this weirdly catchy punk rock vibe that feels like a nod to Motörhead. It’s basically a three-minute adrenaline shot.
4. Jump in the Fire
Another Mustaine contribution. This one has a weirdly "swing" feel to it. It’s one of the few times Metallica sounds like they’re actually having fun rather than trying to summon a demon.
5. (Anesthesia) - Pulling Teeth
This isn't just a song; it's a rite of passage for bass players. Cliff Burton recorded this in a single take. He reportedly kicked everyone out of the room, took a hit of a joint, drank a beer, and just went for it. The engineer, Chris Bubacz, famously caught the "Bass solo, take one" intro on tape, and they kept it.
6. Whiplash
If you want to know what thrash metal is, listen to this. It’s the first time the word "thrash" was really used in a song to describe the scene. It’s fast, it’s chaotic, and it’s meant to make your neck hurt.
7. Phantom Lord
Named after James’s first-ever band. It’s got that classic NWOBHM (New Wave of British Heavy Metal) influence, particularly the middle section which slows down into a moody, melodic passage before exploding again.
8. No Remorse
This one is a fan favorite for the "chug." It’s about the soullessness of war, a theme they’d revisit a million times later (think "Disposable Heroes" or "One").
📖 Related: New Movies in Theatre: What Most People Get Wrong About This Month's Picks
9. Seek & Destroy
The big one. It’s the third most-played song in their entire history. Ironically, Dave Mustaine didn't write a single note of this. It’s all Hetfield and Ulrich. It’s slower than the rest of the album, focusing more on the "groove" than pure speed.
10. Metal Militia
The closer. At 175 BPM, it’s a total rager. It was meant to be a tribute to the "denim and leather" crowd that showed up to their early club gigs.
Why the Credits Still Cause Fights
You can't talk about the Metallica Kill 'Em All tracklist without mentioning Dave Mustaine. He was kicked out of the band just a month before they started recording. They literally packed his bags, bought him a Greyhound bus ticket, and sent him home while he was still asleep.
Kirk Hammett was flown in and had basically a few weeks to learn the songs. The manager, Jonny Zazula, told Kirk he had to play Dave’s solos. Kirk wasn't thrilled. He ended up keeping the first few notes of Dave's solos as a "tribute" (or maybe just to keep the peace) and then improvised the rest.
Mustaine still has co-writing credits on four tracks:
- The Four Horsemen
- Jump in the Fire
- Phantom Lord
- Metal Militia
To this day, he occasionally claims he wrote more, but these are the official ones on the sleeve.
👉 See also: A Simple Favor Blake Lively: Why Emily Nelson Is Still the Ultimate Screen Mystery
The Production Disaster
The band actually hates how this record sounds. Well, maybe "hate" is a strong word, but they weren't happy.
Producer Paul Curcio had previously worked with The Doobie Brothers. He had no idea what to do with a band this loud. He kept trying to turn the distortion down on the guitars. During the final mix, the band was actually locked out of the studio. Curcio and the engineer added a bunch of reverb and delays that the band didn't want. That’s why Kill 'Em All has that "echoey" 80s basement sound, whereas Ride the Lightning sounds massive and dry.
The Impact (By the Numbers)
It didn't even hit the Billboard 200 until 1986. That's three years after it came out! People didn't "get it" at first. But word of mouth is a powerful thing. By 1999, it was certified triple platinum. Today, it’s sold over 4.5 million copies in the US alone.
It proved that you didn't need a major label or a "radio-friendly" sound to make it. You just needed speed and a total lack of regard for your own safety.
Actionable Takeaways for the Modern Listener
If you’re revisiting the album or hearing it for the first time, keep these things in mind:
- Listen for the Bass: Most metal albums from the 80s buried the bass. On Kill 'Em All, Cliff is a lead instrument. Pay attention to his wah-wah pedal work on "Anesthesia."
- Compare the "Mechanix": Go listen to Megadeth’s version of "The Mechanix" and then Metallica’s "The Four Horsemen." It’s a fascinating look at how the same riffs can be used for two completely different vibes.
- Check the BPM: This was considered "unplayable" speed in 1983. Try to imagine hearing "Metal Militia" in a world where the fastest thing on the radio was Van Halen.
- Look at the Credits: Notice how Kirk Hammett doesn't have a single writing credit on this debut, despite playing all the solos. He was the "new guy" just executing what was already there.
The Metallica Kill 'Em All tracklist remains the blueprint. It’s the sound of four kids who had nothing to lose and a lot of anger to vent. Even with the weird production and the messy history, it’s still the most honest record they ever made.