If you haven’t been paying attention to the local politics of Northern Indiana lately, you might think South Bend is still just "the place where Pete Buttigieg used to be in charge." Honestly, that’s a fair assumption if you only watch national cable news. But things have changed. A lot.
Right now, James Mueller is the guy sitting in the mayor's office at 215 S. Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. Blvd. He’s the 33rd person to hold the title, and as of early 2026, he’s navigating a landscape that feels very different from the "Mayor Pete" era.
Mueller isn't just a placeholder. He’s a South Bend native with a PhD from the University of Delaware and a history of working in high-level public policy. He actually served as Buttigieg’s Chief of Staff before winning his own term in 2019. Then, in November 2023, he cruised to a second term with a massive 73% of the vote. People in South Bend clearly like his vibe, even if the city is facing some pretty stiff headwinds right now.
The Reality of Being Mayor of South Bend Indiana Today
Being the mayor of South Bend Indiana in 2026 isn't exactly a walk in the park. While the city saw a huge "glow-up" during the 2010s, the current administration is dealing with the unglamorous reality of municipal math.
Basically, the money is tight.
In late 2025, Mueller had to stand in front of the Common Council and break some tough news. Because of state-level property tax reforms (specifically Senate Enrolled Act 1), the city’s revenue growth is getting squeezed. He literally told the council, "For the next few years, there are no new dollars." That means no flashy new programs. No "moonshot" projects. Just trying to keep the lights on and the streets paved.
📖 Related: The Galveston Hurricane 1900 Orphanage Story Is More Tragic Than You Realized
Despite that, he pushed through 3% raises for city employees in the 2026 budget. Why? Because inflation is hitting South Bend just like everywhere else, and the city can't afford to lose its best workers to the private sector. It’s a delicate balancing act that most mayors would hate, but Mueller seems to thrive on this kind of technical, policy-heavy work.
Public Safety is the Big Conversation
If you walk into a coffee shop in the East Bank or a diner on the West Side, people aren't talking about budget spreadsheets. They’re talking about safety.
2026 started off rough. Within the first two weeks of the year, South Bend saw five shootings. It’s the kind of statistic that keeps a mayor up at night. Mueller has been vocal about "reforming public safety systems," but he’s also dealing with a community that wants results yesterday.
His approach is sort of a "both/and" strategy. He’s trying to support the police while also pushing for "community initiatives" led by folks like Maurice "Moe" Scott. The goal is to stop the violence before it starts, rather than just cleaning up the mess afterward. It’s a slow process.
Beyond the Shadow of "Mayor Pete"
It’s impossible to talk about the mayor of South Bend Indiana without mentioning Pete Buttigieg. For years, the two were joined at the hip politically. Mueller was the policy guy behind the curtain while Pete was the face of the city.
👉 See also: Why the Air France Crash Toronto Miracle Still Changes How We Fly
But Mueller has carved out his own lane.
- Neighborhood Focus: While the Buttigieg years were famous for "Smart Streets" and downtown revitalization, Mueller has spent a lot of his energy on "rebuilding neighborhoods block by block."
- Economic Empowerment: He established the Engagement & Economic Empowerment Division. It’s a fancy name, but the goal is simple: making sure the wealth from South Bend's growth actually reaches the people who have lived there for generations.
- Sustainability: With his background in energy policy (he worked for Senator Maria Cantwell and the George Washington University Solar Institute), he’s pushed South Bend to be a leader in "green" municipal infrastructure.
He’s less of a "superstar" and more of a "super-manager." You won’t see him on every Sunday morning talk show, but you will see him at a 2026 budget hearing arguing about the cost of living adjustments for trash collectors.
What Most People Get Wrong About the Mayor's Power
A lot of people think the mayor can just wave a wand and fix everything. In South Bend, it doesn't work that way. The mayor is the chief executive, responsible for over 1,000 employees and a budget that sits around $380 million. But he has to work with a 9-member Common Council.
If the Council doesn't buy what the mayor is selling, nothing moves. Luckily for Mueller, he’s been pretty good at building consensus. He’s kept a lot of the same department heads for years—people like Eric Horvath in Public Works and Denise Riedl in Innovation. That stability is rare in local government.
The 2026 Outlook
What’s next? Honestly, 2026 is going to be a year of "grit."
✨ Don't miss: Robert Hanssen: What Most People Get Wrong About the FBI's Most Damaging Spy
Governor Mike Braun has been pushing an agenda focused on affordability across Indiana, and South Bend is trying to catch those tailwinds. Mueller’s priority is keeping the city’s credit rating high while dealing with those property tax cuts from the state.
He’s also focused on the "cradle to career" education pipeline. South Bend has some incredible assets—like the University of Notre Dame and IU South Bend—but the city is still working on making sure every kid in the local school system has a shot at those high-tech jobs that are starting to pop up in the region.
Actionable Insights for Residents and Observers
If you’re living in South Bend or just watching from afar, here is how you can actually engage with what the mayor’s office is doing right now:
- Use the 311 System: Mueller is a big data guy. If there’s a pothole or a street light out, call 311. This administration tracks those metrics religiously.
- Attend "Build the Budget" Meetings: Every year, the city holds public forums where you can literally voice your priorities for the next fiscal cycle. This usually kicks off in the summer.
- Watch the Common Council: If you want to see where the real friction is, watch the Monday night council meetings. That’s where the debates over housing and police reform actually happen.
- Stay Informed on Property Tax Changes: Since these state-level changes are directly affecting your local services, keep an eye on how the 2026 and 2027 budgets shift to accommodate the revenue loss.
South Bend is a city that has spent the last decade trying to prove it's "back." Under James Mueller, it's realizing that "back" isn't a destination—it's a constant, daily grind of fixing pipes, balancing books, and trying to keep people safe. It’s not always glamorous, but it’s the work that defines the city in 2026.
Next Steps for You: Check the official City of South Bend website to find your specific district council member, as they are the primary link between your neighborhood and the mayor's office. If you're looking to start a business, contact the Department of Community Investment to see what local grants or tax abatements are currently available for the 2026 fiscal year.