If you flip on Buzzr or GSN at 3:00 in the morning, you’re basically walking into a cocktail party that’s been going on for fifty years. There’s Gene Rayburn with his impossibly long microphone, looking like he’s having the time of his life. But let’s be real. Nobody was watching for the fill-in-the-blank questions about "Dumb Dora." We were there for the Match Game cast.
It was a weird, beautiful fluke of television history. You had a group of C-list celebrities—and I say that with total affection—who became A-plus icons because they spent their afternoons drinking (allegedly) and making "boob" jokes on national TV. It shouldn't have worked. The 1962 original version of the show was a stiff, boring affair with people in suits. But when the 1973 reboot hit, something shifted.
The Holy Trinity: Somers, Reilly, and Dawson
You can't talk about the Match Game cast without starting with the "regulars." For a huge chunk of the 70s run, the show had a seating chart that felt as permanent as the Supreme Court.
Brett Somers wasn't even supposed to be there. Her husband at the time, Jack Klugman, did the first week of the show and basically told the producers, "Hey, my wife is bored, put her on the panel." She showed up in big glasses, a wig, and a voice that sounded like she’d just finished a pack of Luckies. She was sharp. She was grumpy. She was perfect.
Sitting right next to her was Charles Nelson Reilly. If Brett was the cynical aunt, Charles was the eccentric uncle who lived in a theater. He was a Tony Award winner, but most of us knew him for his ascots and his constant "feud" with Brett. Their chemistry was the engine of the show. They’d bicker like an old married couple, usually because Charles had written something totally bizarre and Brett was calling him out on it.
💡 You might also like: Not the Nine O'Clock News: Why the Satirical Giant Still Matters
Then you had Richard Dawson. Before he was the guy kissing everyone on Family Feud, he was the bottom-center anchor of the Match Game cast. He was the "pro." If a contestant needed a match to win $5,000, they went to Richard. He took it seriously. Too seriously, maybe? Eventually, he got so popular that contestants only picked him for the Head-to-Head match, which led to the invention of the Star Wheel just to give the other celebs a chance.
Why the Seating Chart Actually Mattered
It sounds nerdy, but where people sat on that tiered panel changed the whole vibe. You had six seats, and they usually followed a specific "type" casting:
- Top Left: Usually a rotating guest, often a handsome leading man or a rising starlet.
- Top Center: Brett Somers. Always. The anchor of the upper tier.
- Top Right: Charles Nelson Reilly. The "wild card" spot.
- Bottom Left: Often a comedian or a "wacky" personality like Nipsey Russell or Fannie Flagg.
- Bottom Center: Richard Dawson. The serious player.
- Bottom Right: Usually a "pretty girl" or a sweet-natured actress like Joyce Bulifant or Debralee Scott.
This wasn't just random. It created a visual rhythm. You’d have the chaos of the top row balanced by the (relative) sanity of the bottom row.
The "Semi-Regulars" Who Stole the Show
While the big three got the most screen time, the Match Game cast was a revolving door of 70s legends. Honestly, looking back at the guest lists is like a fever dream of pop culture.
📖 Related: New Movies in Theatre: What Most People Get Wrong About This Month's Picks
- Betty White: Long before The Golden Girls, Betty was a game show shark. She was polite, charming, and then she’d drop a double entendre that would make Gene Rayburn fall over.
- Fannie Flagg: She brought this Southern, self-deprecating energy. She was the one who usually came up with the most "creative" (read: wrong) answers.
- Nipsey Russell: The man spoke in rhyme. Every time Gene turned to him, you knew you were getting a poem. It was his bit, and he never missed.
- McLean Stevenson: After he left MASH*, he basically moved into the Match Game studio. He eventually became a regular in the later syndicated years.
The Evolution: From 73 to Alec Baldwin
The show didn't end when the 70s did. It just... mutated. We had the Match Game-Hollywood Squares Hour in the 80s, which was a bit of a mess. Then the 90s version with Ross Shafer, which felt a little too "bright" and "90s" for its own good.
But then ABC brought it back with Alec Baldwin in 2016.
A lot of purists hated it at first. But Baldwin leaned into the "drunken party" vibe of the original. He played the Gene Rayburn role with a mix of gravitas and silliness. The new Match Game cast featured people like Tituss Burgess, Jane Krakowski, and Caroline Rhea. It worked because it didn't try to be the 70s version; it just tried to capture that same feeling of "we’re all just here to hang out and be slightly inappropriate."
What Most People Get Wrong About the Cast
There’s this persistent rumor that the cast was drunk during filming. While "cocktail party atmosphere" was the official tagline, the truth is a bit more nuanced. They taped five episodes in one day. Usually, there was a dinner break between the third and fourth episodes. That’s when the "refreshments" reportedly came out. If you watch closely, the energy in the "Thursday" and "Friday" episodes (the ones taped later in the day) is usually about 20% higher and 50% weirder than the Monday ones.
👉 See also: A Simple Favor Blake Lively: Why Emily Nelson Is Still the Ultimate Screen Mystery
Also, it wasn't all fun and games. Richard Dawson eventually grew frustrated with the show. He felt he was "above" the silly puns, especially as he was preparing to host Family Feud. You can actually see his mood shift in the later seasons—he stops laughing as much, he’s less engaged. It’s a bit of a bummer to watch, but it’s part of the show's authentic, unscripted history.
Why the Match Game Cast Still Matters in 2026
We live in an era of hyper-edited, over-produced reality TV. Match Game was the opposite. It was raw. When a celebrity said something stupid, they couldn't edit it out because it was part of the game. The "matches" depended on it.
The cast felt like friends because they were friends. Charles Nelson Reilly and Brett Somers didn't just play those characters for the cameras; they had a genuine, deep-seated affection for each other that translated through the screen. You can't fake that kind of chemistry with a casting director and a chemistry read.
How to Watch Like an Expert
If you're diving back into the archives, look for the 1974-1977 era. That's the sweet spot. The cast was comfortable, the "Dumb Dora" jokes hadn't become stale yet, and the banter was at its peak.
- Watch the "Friday" episodes: These are the ones where the wheels usually come off.
- Pay attention to the hand signals: The celebs often tried to signal the contestant or each other—usually subtly, sometimes not.
- Check out the "Star Wheel" era: Notice how the energy changes when the contestants are forced to pick someone other than Richard Dawson.
The Match Game cast wasn't just a group of people playing a game. They were a weekly escape into a world where everything was a joke, everyone was invited, and the only thing that mattered was whether you could guess what "Old Man Periwinkle" was doing with his "blank."
Next Step: Check out the official Buzzr YouTube channel or your local subchannel listings to find the 1975-1976 season episodes—specifically the ones featuring the "Holy Trinity" of Somers, Reilly, and Dawson—to see this legendary chemistry in its prime.