You’ve seen the face. Even if you haven't watched a single frame of silent film, you know the grin. It’s the jagged, frozen rictus that inspired the Joker. But behind that terrifying prosthetic—and the heavy expressionist shadows—is a group of performers who basically changed how we think about "monster movies." When people talk about The Man Who Laughs cast, they usually start and end with Conrad Veidt. That's a mistake. While Veidt is the soul of the film, the surrounding players created a chemistry that turned a Universal melodrama into a masterpiece of gothic horror.
Paul Leni directed this thing in 1928. It was the tail end of the silent era. The technology was peaking, and the acting styles were shifting from wild theatrical gestures to something... weirder. More internal. Honestly, if you look at the names on the call sheet, you’re looking at a collision of German Expressionism and Hollywood studio muscle.
📖 Related: Why Careful What You Wish For Still Hits Different: A Watch Guide for the 2015 Thriller
The Man Behind the Mask: Conrad Veidt as Gwynplaine
Conrad Veidt was already a legend by 1928. He’d played the somnambulist in The Cabinet of Dr. Caligari. He was used to being the "strange" guy. In The Man Who Laughs, he plays Gwynplaine, a man whose face was carved into a permanent smile by "Comprachicos" as a punishment for his father's crimes.
Veidt’s performance is a masterclass in physical limitation. Imagine trying to act when your mouth is literally hooked open by a metal dental appliance. He couldn't speak. He could barely breathe comfortably. He had to do everything with his eyes. And those eyes? They’re heartbreaking. You see the shame, the love for Dea, and the searing resentment for a world that sees him as a freak. It isn't just a horror performance; it’s a tragic one. Most actors would have leaned into the "scary" aspect of the grin, but Veidt plays Gwynplaine as a victim of state-sponsored cruelty.
The makeup itself, designed by Jack Pierce (who later did Frankenstein), was brutal. Veidt had to wear these metal hooks that pulled his mouth wide. It was painful. It caused gum issues. But that discomfort bled into the character. There’s a tension in his body that you just can't fake.
Mary Philbin and the Heart of the Film
Then there’s Mary Philbin. She plays Dea, the blind girl who loves Gwynplaine because she can’t see the "monster" the rest of the world sees. Philbin was already famous for The Phantom of the Opera (1925), where she played opposite Lon Chaney. She was the queen of the "beauty and the beast" dynamic.
Her performance as Dea is delicate. Maybe a bit too "silent film dainty" for some modern tastes, but it works as a counterweight to the harshness of the rest of the The Man Who Laughs cast. She provides the only warmth in a film that is otherwise filled with cynicism and political backstabbing. When she touches Gwynplaine’s face, it’s one of the few moments in the movie where the tension drops. You actually believe she sees the man, not the grin.
The Villains: Brandon Hurst and Olga Baclanova
A movie like this is only as good as its villains. Brandon Hurst plays Barkilphedro. What a name. He is the court jester, but he’s basically a high-functioning psychopath. Hurst plays him with this oily, slithering energy. He’s the one pulling the strings behind the scenes, ensuring that Gwynplaine’s noble heritage is kept secret until it can be used for maximum chaos.
And then we have Olga Baclanova as Duchess Josiana. She is incredible. Baclanova was a Russian stage actress, and she brings this predatory, bored-aristocrat energy to the role. She’s attracted to Gwynplaine specifically because he’s "hideous." It’s a very modern, transgressive plot point. She doesn't pity him; she wants to use him as a thrill. Her performance is sharp, sexual, and dangerous. It’s a complete 180 from Mary Philbin’s Dea.
🔗 Read more: 1923 cast season 2: Who is actually coming back to the Dutton Ranch
The Supporting Players You Might Miss
We can't ignore Cesare Gravina as Ursus. He’s the father figure, the carnival philosopher who adopts Gwynplaine and Dea. Gravina brings a much-needed groundedness to the story. He’s the one who has to manage the "freak show" while trying to protect his "children" from the cruelty of the London crowds.
- George Siegmann as Dr. Hardquanonne: He’s the guy who reveals the truth about Gwynplaine’s origin. Siegmann was a veteran of the era, often playing tough guys or villains.
- Josephine Crowell as Queen Anne: She’s cold. Formidable. She represents the unfeeling power of the monarchy that ruined Gwynplaine's life.
- Sam De Grasse as King James II: He only appears in the prologue, but his cruelty sets the entire plot in motion.
Why the Casting Worked (and Still Works)
Director Paul Leni came from the German school of filmmaking where the "ensemble" was part of the architecture. The The Man Who Laughs cast doesn't feel like a bunch of stars vying for screen time. They feel like pieces of a nightmare. The contrast between Veidt’s distorted face and Baclanova’s icy beauty creates a visual tension that carries the movie through its slower moments.
It’s also worth noting how international this cast was. You had Germans, Russians, and Americans all working under a director who barely spoke English at the time. That "Tower of Babel" atmosphere contributed to the film’s unique, otherworldly feel. It doesn't quite look like England, and it doesn't quite look like America. It looks like a fever dream.
The Joker Connection
You can't talk about the The Man Who Laughs cast without mentioning Bob Kane and Bill Finger. When they were creating the Joker in 1940, they looked directly at Conrad Veidt. They didn't just take the grin; they took the hollowed-out eyes and the sense of a man who is a "laughing" mask hiding a chaotic interior.
Actually, if you watch Veidt’s performance, you see the Joker’s DNA everywhere. The way he moves, the way he uses his hands—it’s all there. But while the Joker is a monster who chooses chaos, Gwynplaine is a good man trapped in a monster's skin. That’s the irony. The most famous "villain" in comic book history was inspired by one of cinema’s most tragic heroes.
Behind the Scenes Drama
Production wasn't easy. Universal poured a ton of money into this. It was meant to be their prestige "Super Jewel" production. The sets were massive. The costumes were authentic to the late 17th century. But it was the makeup that caused the most grief.
Conrad Veidt had to keep his "smile" in for hours. He couldn't eat with it on. He reportedly lived on a liquid diet during filming. The pain wasn't just physical; it was psychological. He was playing a character who was constantly mocked, and even on set, the sight of him was jarring. He stayed in character, often isolating himself from the rest of the The Man Who Laughs cast to maintain that sense of loneliness.
Legacy and Modern Rediscovery
For decades, The Man Who Laughs was a bit of a lost relic. It was overshadowed by the later Universal monsters like Dracula and Frankenstein. But in the last twenty years, thanks to restorations and the exploding popularity of the Joker, it’s become a cult favorite.
The nuance of the acting is what keeps it relevant. In many silent films, the acting is "big"—lots of eye-rolling and fainting. But Leni’s cast is surprisingly subtle. Look at the scene in the House of Lords where Gwynplaine finally reveals himself to the peers of England. Veidt’s movement—the way he stumbles, the way he tries to hold his dignity while they howl with laughter at him—is gut-wrenching. It’s a scene about class warfare as much as it is about physical deformity.
✨ Don't miss: Prophet Song: Why Paul Lynch’s Booker Prize Winner is Terrifyingly Relevant Now
Key Insights for Film History Buffs
If you’re diving into this film for the first time, keep an eye on these specific details. They’ll help you appreciate the work the The Man Who Laughs cast put in:
- The Eyes of Veidt: Watch how he expresses joy without using his mouth. It’s almost impossible, yet he does it when he’s with Dea.
- Baclanova’s Body Language: She moves like a cat. Notice how she circles Gwynplaine in their scenes together. It’s predatory.
- The Crowd Work: The extras in the "freak show" and the House of Lords were meticulously directed. Their laughter is a character in itself.
- Lighting as a Character: The way Leni lights Mary Philbin makes her look ethereal, almost glowing, which contrasts sharply with the sharp, jagged shadows cast on Veidt.
How to Experience The Man Who Laughs Today
Don't settle for a grainy YouTube rip. This movie lives and dies by its visual clarity. Look for the Flicker Alley or Eureka (Masters of Cinema) Blu-ray restorations. They cleaned up the film from the original nitrate negatives, and the detail in the makeup is stunning. You can actually see the texture of the "scars" on Veidt’s face.
Once you’ve watched it, compare it to the 2012 French remake. The newer version has its merits, but it lacks the haunting, expressionist soul of the 1928 original. There is something about the silent era—the lack of dialogue—that makes the tragedy of a man who cannot stop "smiling" even more potent.
Next Steps for Your Deep Dive:
- Watch the 1928 original specifically for the House of Lords sequence; it's the peak of Veidt's career.
- Compare the Joker's first appearance in Batman #1 (1940) to stills of Gwynplaine; the visual "theft" is fascinating to see side-by-side.
- Research Paul Leni’s background in German theater to understand why the film looks so "un-American" for a Hollywood production.