Honestly, if you sit down to watch the very first aired episode of Gene Roddenberry's space epic, you might get a little confused. Most people expect to see the pilot. They want the origin story. But when "The Man Trap" beamed onto NBC screens on September 8, 1966, viewers were dropped right into the middle of the action with zero context. No explanation of the United Federation of Planets. No "how we met" for Kirk and Spock. Just a dusty planet, a salt-hungry shapeshifter, and some surprisingly dark vibes. Original Star Trek episode 1 wasn't actually the first one filmed, which is the first thing every trivia nerd will tell you at a party, but it was the world's introduction to the Enterprise.
It’s a weird start.
If you look at "The Cage" (the actual first pilot) or "Where No Man Has Gone Before" (the second pilot), they feel like high-concept sci-fi. But "The Man Trap" feels like a gothic horror story wrapped in a space blanket. The plot is basically this: the crew visits Professor Robert Crater and his wife, Nancy, on planet M-113. The twist? Nancy isn't Nancy. She’s the last of a species that survives by sucking salt out of human bodies. It's gruesome. It's lonely. It’s also a masterclass in how to sell a brand-new show to a 1960s audience that was used to Westerns and creature features.
Why The Man Trap Was the Chosen One
Network executives are a cautious bunch. NBC had "Where No Man Has Gone Before" ready to go, but they sat on it. They chose "The Man Trap" to lead the charge because it had a clear "monster of the week" hook. It was easy to understand. You have a scary creature, a bit of mystery, and a clear resolution. They were terrified that the more cerebral episodes would bore people.
Looking back, the pacing is fascinatingly slow compared to modern TV. We spend a lot of time watching Kirk, Spock, and McCoy walk through red-filtered sand. There is a specific tension here that the show rarely captured again. It’s about the tragedy of extinction. The "Salt Vampire," as fans call it, isn't inherently evil; it’s just hungry. It’s the last of its kind. When McCoy finally has to kill the creature—which is disguised as his ex-flame—the look on his face isn't one of triumph. It’s pure trauma. DeForest Kelley absolutely sells the heartbreak of realizing his old girlfriend has been dead for years and he just shot the thing wearing her skin.
Breaking Down the Production Weirdness
You’ve probably noticed the uniforms look a bit different if you’re a sharp-eyed fan. Because this was one of the early episodes produced after the pilots, the "look" of Trek was still hardening. The colors are incredibly saturated. The lighting is harsh. But the chemistry? That was there from the jump. William Shatner, even in this debut, played Kirk with a certain athletic intensity that jumped off the screen. He wasn't the meme he became later. He was a focused, slightly stressed commander trying to protect his men from a threat he didn't understand.
💡 You might also like: Greatest Rock and Roll Singers of All Time: Why the Legends Still Own the Mic
Budget constraints were everywhere. The ruins on M-113 were mostly cardboard and plaster. Yet, the sound design—that rhythmic, pulsing wind of the planet—creates an atmosphere of total desolation. It’s a reminder that Star Trek didn't start as a shiny utopia. It started as a dangerous frontier.
The Salt Vampire and the "Nancy" Problem
One of the coolest things about original Star Trek episode 1 is the psychological trickery. The creature appears differently to everyone who looks at it. To McCoy, she’s the beautiful woman he remembers from ten years ago. To Kirk, she’s a middle-aged lady. To a random crewman, she’s a blonde bombshell. This allowed the production to use different actresses, which kept the audience guessing. It also touched on a very "Trek" theme: our perceptions are filtered through our own desires and memories. We don't see the world as it is; we see it as we are.
Professor Crater, played by Alfred Ryder, provides the moral gray area. He’s been living with this creature, feeding it salt, protecting it like a pet or a spouse. He’s complicit in the deaths of crew members because he can't let go of the "Nancy" he sees. It’s a dark, messy domestic drama happening on a dead planet.
Things Most People Get Wrong About the Premiere
Many fans assume the iconic opening monologue—"Space: the final frontier"—was always there. And while it was, the arrangement of the theme music by Alexander Courage was still being tweaked. The episode also features some "early installment weirdness." For instance, Uhura is wearing a gold uniform in some scenes instead of her signature red. Spock is a bit more emotive. He even smiles slightly at one point, which would later become a total "no-no" for the character's Vulcan stoicism.
Another misconception? That it was a massive hit. It wasn't. The reviews were mixed at best. Variety famously called it "unimaginative" and "tedious." Imagine being the reviewer who wrote that, only to see the show become a multi-billion dollar cultural juggernaut sixty years later. Ouch.
📖 Related: Ted Nugent State of Shock: Why This 1979 Album Divides Fans Today
The Supporting Cast and the Redshirts
We have to talk about the casualties. This episode features the first "Redshirt" deaths, though they weren't all wearing red yet. Crewmen Darnell, Sturgeon, and Green all bite the dust. The way the show handles their deaths is cold. It’s a reminder that in the 1960s, TV mortality was often just a plot device to show the monster was dangerous. There's no funeral. There's no moment of silence. Kirk just moves on to the next problem. It’s a stark contrast to the later movies where every death feels like a monumental shift in the universe.
The creature itself, designed by Wah Chang, remains one of the most memorable designs in the series. It’s ugly. It has those weird suction-cup fingers. But there’s a sadness in its eyes. Chang was a genius who also designed the Gorn and the Romulan Bird of Prey. He understood that a monster is more effective when it looks like it has a history, not just a scary face.
Historical Context: Why Salt?
Why salt? Why not blood or "life force"? The choice of salt as the creature's requirement was actually a clever bit of writing by George Clayton Johnson. He was a prolific sci-fi writer who also worked on The Twilight Zone (he wrote "Nothing in the Dark" and "Kick the Can"). Using salt made the creature feel biological and grounded. It’s a basic chemical need. It made the horror feel "medical," which played perfectly into McCoy’s character as a doctor.
If you watch the episode closely, you can see the sweat on the actors. The set was hot. The costumes were heavy. This physical discomfort translates into the performances. Everyone looks on edge. When they find the bodies with those weird red ring-shaped sores on their skin, it feels like a plague story.
Practical Ways to Re-watch (or Watch for the First Time)
If you're going back to watch original Star Trek episode 1, don't go in expecting the polish of The Next Generation or the high-octane action of the modern reboots.
👉 See also: Mike Judge Presents: Tales from the Tour Bus Explained (Simply)
- Watch the Remastered Version: The CGI updates to the Enterprise models are nice, but the real benefit is the color correction. The purples and oranges of the planet surface look stunning in 4K.
- Listen to the Score: Alexander Courage's work here is exceptional. The "lurking" music for the creature is genuinely unsettling.
- Pay Attention to Spock: Watch how Leonard Nimoy plays with the character's voice. It’s a bit higher and more "human" than it would eventually become.
- Spot the Background Actors: Many of the "dead" crew members reappear in later episodes as different characters. It’s a fun game of "spot the extra."
Moving Forward with the Enterprise
The brilliance of starting with "The Man Trap" is that it established the Enterprise as a place of safety in a hostile universe. When the crew finally leaves M-113 and heads back into the black, there is a palpable sense of relief. We realized that while the planets are dangerous, the ship—and the people on it—are home.
To truly appreciate the evolution of the series, follow up "The Man Trap" with "Balance of Terror" or "City on the Edge of Forever." You’ll see how the show moved from basic creature features to complex political and philosophical dramas. But never forget the Salt Vampire. It’s the creature that paved the way for every Klingon, Borg, and Romulan that followed.
Actionable Next Steps:
- Compare the "Remastered" version on Paramount+ with original broadcast clips on YouTube to see how much the matte paintings were altered.
- Read George Clayton Johnson’s original treatment for the episode to see how the "Nancy" character was originally envisioned as much more malicious.
- Check out the "The Star Trek Compendium" by Allan Asherman for the specific filming dates that explain why the uniforms and sets seem inconsistent in this first aired hour.
The legacy of this first episode isn't just about the monster. It's about the fact that for the first time, audiences saw a future where humanity was out there, exploring, making mistakes, and trying to survive the weirdness of the cosmos. It wasn't perfect, but it was the start of something that would never truly end.