The Man on the Roof and the 2024 Butler Assassination Attempt: What We Still Don't Know

The Man on the Roof and the 2024 Butler Assassination Attempt: What We Still Don't Know

It’s an image burned into the collective memory of millions. A sloped silver roof. A young man in a grey T-shirt. The blurred movement of a rifle. On July 13, 2024, the world watched as Thomas Matthew Crooks—the "man on the roof"—nearly changed the course of American history by attempting to assassinate President Donald Trump.

People are still obsessed. Why? Because the security failures that day were, frankly, baffling. How does a 20-year-old kid with a ladder and a rangefinder get a direct line of sight to a presidential candidate from less than 150 yards away? It sounds like a bad movie plot. But it was real. And the fallout is still happening.

Who Was Thomas Matthew Crooks?

The man on the roof wasn't a shadowy international operative. He was a dietary aide from Bethel Park, Pennsylvania. He liked history. He was reportedly a member of a local gun club. Neighbors described him as quiet, maybe a bit of a loner, but nothing screamed "assassin."

That’s what makes it so chilling.

Crooks didn't leave a manifesto. He didn't have a loud political social media presence that would have flagged him to the FBI months in advance. Investigators found that he had searched for information on both Donald Trump and Joe Biden. He looked up the dates of the Democratic National Convention. He looked up the Butler rally. He was hunting for an opportunity. Basically, he was a ghost until the moment he pulled the trigger.

He had a DPMS Panther Arms AR-15. It was his father's gun. Think about that for a second. This wasn't some high-tech sniper rig. It was a standard, civilian-grade rifle. He bought a 5-foot ladder from Home Depot. He bought 50 rounds of ammunition. He drove to the site.

The Failure of the "Dead Space"

The American Glass Research (AGR) building. That’s the official name of the place where the man on the roof took his position.

✨ Don't miss: Melissa Calhoun Satellite High Teacher Dismissal: What Really Happened

If you look at the site map, it’s frustratingly close. The roof was outside the Secret Service’s "inner perimeter," which meant it was the responsibility of local law enforcement to secure it. But there was a massive communication breakdown. Local tactical teams were actually inside the building while Crooks was on top of it.

You've probably heard the reports of the "dead space." This refers to areas that aren't actively watched by a human eye or a camera. Because the roof was sloped, the snipers positioned on the barns behind the stage couldn't see Crooks until he reached the very peak.

It was a perfect storm of incompetence.

Witnesses saw him. People were literally pointing at him. "There’s a guy on the roof with a gun!" they yelled. They filmed him. They tried to alert the police. A local officer even climbed up to the edge of the roof, saw Crooks, and then dropped back down after Crooks pointed the rifle at him. Seconds later, the shots started.

The Physics of the Near-Miss

Donald Trump survived because he turned his head at the exact right millisecond. He was looking at a chart about immigration.

$v = \sqrt{\frac{2 \cdot E}{m}}$

🔗 Read more: Wisconsin Judicial Elections 2025: Why This Race Broke Every Record

If we look at the ballistics, a .223 Remington or 5.56 NATO round travels at roughly 3,200 feet per second. At 130 yards, the travel time is negligible—less than 0.15 seconds. There is no reacting to the sound. The bullet arrives before the "crack" of the rifle reaches the ear.

The bullet grazed Trump’s right ear. It was a matter of millimeters. If his head had been straight, the trajectory would have been fatal.

But while the former President survived, others didn't. Corey Comperatore, a former fire chief, was killed while shielding his family. Two other spectators, David Dutch and James Copenhaver, were critically injured. This wasn't just a political event; it was a crime scene of immense proportions.

Why the Counter-Sniper Response Took So Long

One of the biggest questions people ask is why the Secret Service counter-snipers didn't fire sooner. They had him in their scopes.

The "Hawkeye" teams (the Secret Service snipers) are trained to identify a threat before neutralizing it. They aren't allowed to just pick off everyone who looks suspicious in a crowd. But a man with a rifle on a roof? That’s a clear threat.

The official testimony from Kimberly Cheatle, the then-Director of the Secret Service, was widely criticized. She initially suggested the slope of the roof was too dangerous for agents to stand on, a comment that led to her eventual resignation. The truth is more likely a failure of command and control. The radio frequencies between local police and the Secret Service weren't bridged. The guys with the rifles didn't know what the guys on the ground were seeing.

💡 You might also like: Casey Ramirez: The Small Town Benefactor Who Smuggled 400 Pounds of Cocaine

When the counter-sniper finally fired, it was a single, suppressed shot. Crooks was killed instantly. It took only a few seconds from his first shot to his death, but in those seconds, the world changed.

The Investigations and the Aftermath

Since July, there have been multiple congressional hearings. We've seen drone footage showing Crooks scouting the area earlier in the day. We’ve learned he used a drone to fly over the rally site at around 4:00 PM to get an aerial view of the security layout.

The FBI has conducted nearly 1,000 interviews. They cracked his phone. They looked at his search history.

What they found was a young man fascinated by mass shootings and high-profile targets. He wasn't necessarily a partisan zealot; he was a person seeking a "moment."

Modern Security Shifts After Butler

Everything has changed for outdoor political events now. You’ll notice more ballistic glass. You'll see more drones in the air—ours, not theirs.

The "man on the roof" highlighted a massive vulnerability in how we protect public figures in the age of decentralized threats. You don't need a complex conspiracy. You just need a ladder and a lapse in communication.

Key Takeaways and Lessons from the Incident

  • Communication is the first line of defense. If the local police and Secret Service had been on the same radio channel, Crooks would likely have been apprehended before he even got on the roof.
  • The "Perimeter" is an illusion. Just because someone is 150 yards away doesn't mean they aren't a direct threat. Modern ballistics make that distance a chip shot for even an amateur marksman.
  • Public Vigilance Matters. The bystanders were right. They saw the threat before the professionals did. In high-stakes environments, the "see something, say something" rule is vital, but the authorities must have a mechanism to act on those tips instantly.
  • Technology is a double-edged sword. Crooks used a drone to plan his attack. Security teams now have to account for "eyes in the sky" that aren't their own.

To stay informed on the ongoing legislative changes regarding executive protection, monitor the House Committee on Homeland Security's public reports. The final oversight findings are expected to reshape the Secret Service's budget and operational protocols for the next decade. Pay close attention to the "Counter-Unmanned Aircraft Systems" (C-UAS) sections of these reports, as they detail the new tech being deployed to prevent future "man on the roof" scenarios.