October 17, 1989. 5:04 p.m. Most people in the Bay Area were settling in to watch the World Series. Then the ground turned into liquid. If you look at the official records, the magnitude of san francisco earthquake 1989—specifically known as the Loma Prieta quake—is pinned at a 6.9.
But here’s the thing: for years, everyone called it a 7.1.
That shift isn't just a rounding error or scientists being picky. It tells a story about how we measure the raw power of the earth and why some neighborhoods in San Francisco fell over while others barely felt a tremor. The magnitude of an earthquake is supposed to be a fixed number, a single data point that tells you how much energy was released at the source. In reality? It’s a lot more complicated than a needle jumping on a piece of paper.
The Moment Magnitude vs. Richter Confusion
Back in the day, we all used the Richter scale. It’s what we were taught in school. But the Richter scale is actually kind of "old school" tech now. It was designed for Southern California and it "saturates" when things get really big. Basically, it hits a ceiling.
When the Loma Prieta quake hit, initial readings suggested a 7.1. Later, after looking at more data from all over the globe, the U.S. Geological Survey (USGS) refined that to a 6.9 moment magnitude. Now, a 0.2 difference might sound like nothing to you or me. But magnitude scales are logarithmic.
Math is weird.
In a logarithmic scale, a whole number jump—like from a 6.0 to a 7.0—represents 32 times more energy release. So, that tiny-looking "0.2" difference actually means the 7.1 version of the quake people thought they experienced was significantly more powerful than the 6.9 it officially became. Even at 6.9, it was a monster. It lasted about 15 seconds, which feels like an eternity when your house is shaking, though in the world of "Big Ones," 15 seconds is actually relatively short.
Why the magnitude of san francisco earthquake 1989 felt different depending on your zip code
Magnitude is the size of the earthquake at its source—the "engine" of the quake. Intensity is what you actually feel at your kitchen table. This is where the 1989 disaster gets really interesting and, frankly, terrifying.
✨ Don't miss: The CIA Stars on the Wall: What the Memorial Really Represents
The epicenter was actually in the Santa Cruz Mountains, near Loma Prieta peak. That’s about 60 miles away from San Francisco. So why did the Cypress Street Viaduct in Oakland collapse? Why did the Marina District in SF catch fire?
It’s all about the mud.
If you were standing on solid granite in the mountains, you felt a sharp, violent jolt. But if you were in the Marina District or on the Nimitz Freeway, you were standing on "made land"—soft soil, loose sand, and bay fill. When the seismic waves hit that soft dirt, they slowed down and grew taller. Think of it like a whip cracking. The energy amplifies. This process is called soil liquefaction. The ground basically turns into a thick soup. You could have a 6.9 magnitude quake feel like a 9.0 if you’re standing on the wrong kind of dirt.
Deep Dive into the Fault Line
The San Andreas Fault is the big name everyone knows. It’s the "celebrity" of tectonic plates. But the Loma Prieta event didn’t actually happen on the main San Andreas line. It happened on a "tributary" or a side-fault called the Santa Cruz Mountains segment.
Unlike many California quakes that just slide side-to-side (strike-slip), this one had a vertical component. The Pacific Plate didn’t just slide north; it actually pushed up and over the North American Plate by about 4.5 feet. That vertical movement is part of why the damage to infrastructure was so lopsided.
- The Bay Bridge: A section of the upper deck collapsed onto the lower deck.
- The Cypress Viaduct: This was a double-decker highway that literally pancaked, killing 42 people.
- The Marina: Homes built on debris from the 1906 quake collapsed because the "soil" underneath them gave way.
It’s a grim irony. Much of the land that failed in 1989 was actually rubble from the Great 1906 Earthquake that had been dumped into the bay to create more real estate. We literally built our new problems on top of our old ones.
Comparing 1989 to 1906
People always want to compare the two. The 1906 earthquake had an estimated magnitude of 7.9.
🔗 Read more: Passive Resistance Explained: Why It Is Way More Than Just Standing Still
Remember that logarithmic math?
A 7.9 is roughly 30 times more powerful than a 6.9. While the magnitude of san francisco earthquake 1989 was enough to stop the World Series and cause $6 billion in damage, it was a "moderate" event compared to what the San Andreas is actually capable of. Scientists like Dr. Lucy Jones have often pointed out that 1989 was a "wake-up call" rather than the main event. It showed us that our bridges weren't ready and our building codes were sagging.
The Infrastructure Legacy
After the dust settled, the 6.9 magnitude became a benchmark. It changed how we build things in California.
Engineers realized that "strength" wasn't the goal. Flexibility was. If you build a bridge to be perfectly rigid, a 6.9 magnitude quake will snap it like a dry twig. If you build it to sway, it survives. This led to the massive retrofitting of the Richmond-San Rafael Bridge and the eventual complete replacement of the Eastern Span of the Bay Bridge.
Honestly, if that same 6.9 hit today, the damage would be significantly less in some areas but potentially worse in others because our population density has skyrocketed. We have more "stuff" in the way of the moving earth now.
What about the "Seismic Gap"?
Geologists talk about something called a seismic gap—a section of a fault that hasn't moved in a long time. For a while, people thought Loma Prieta filled the gap. It didn't.
Because the 1989 quake happened on a side fault and didn't relieve the main stress on the San Andreas or the nearby Hayward Fault, the "Big One" is still technically "overdue." It’s a bit of a localized myth that 1989 "bought us more time." If anything, it just reminded us that the ground beneath the Bay Area is a jigsaw puzzle of cracks, and we've only seen one piece move recently.
💡 You might also like: What Really Happened With the Women's Orchestra of Auschwitz
Survival is about more than just the number
When you hear "6.9 magnitude," don't just think about the number. Think about the duration and the depth. The 1989 quake was deep—about 11 miles down. If that same magnitude of san francisco earthquake 1989 had happened only 4 or 5 miles down, the surface destruction would have been exponentially worse.
We got lucky.
It happened during the World Series pre-game. Usually, at 5:04 p.m., the freeways would have been packed with tens of thousands of cars. Because people left work early to watch the Giants play the Athletics, the roads were eerily empty. That "coincidence" saved hundreds, maybe thousands, of lives.
Actionable Steps for the Next One
The magnitude is out of your control. Your reaction isn't. Based on what we learned from the 1989 data, here is what actually matters for residents today:
- Check your foundation: If you live in a house built before 1989, find out if it has been "bolted" to the foundation. In 1989, many homes simply slid off their bases.
- Know your soil: The USGS has liquefaction maps. If you are on "soft" soil, you need better insurance and a more robust emergency kit.
- Drop, Cover, and Hold On: It sounds cliché, but the 1989 injury reports showed that people who tried to run out of buildings were often hit by falling glass or masonry. Stay put.
- The "Text, Don't Call" Rule: After 1989, phone lines were jammed. In a modern quake, data (texts) often gets through when voice calls fail.
The magnitude of san francisco earthquake 1989 stands as a historical marker. It was the first "televised" major earthquake, happening right as the cameras were rolling at Candlestick Park. It taught us that the earth doesn't care about our schedules, our baseball games, or our commute times. It just moves.
Next Steps for Safety
Verify your home's proximity to active fault lines using the USGS Fault Map tool. If you live in an older "soft-story" apartment building (common in San Francisco and Oakland), ask your landlord about seismic retrofitting status, as these structures are the most vulnerable to magnitude 6.0+ events. Update your emergency water supply to last at least 72 hours, as 1989 proved that water mains are often the first thing to snap.