You’re walking down East Butler Avenue in Ambler, and for a second, you expect to smell that heavy, sweet scent of hickory smoke. It was a staple. For over a decade, The Lucky Well Ambler PA wasn't just a place to grab a bite; it was the anchor of the downtown scene.
Then, everything changed.
If you’ve been looking for a table lately, you’ve probably realized the doors are locked. The smoker is cold. Honestly, it’s a weird feeling for locals who spent ten years treating this place like a second living room. But the story of what happened—and what’s there now—is a lot more interesting than just another restaurant closing its doors.
The Rise of a BBQ Empire (and Why It Stuck)
Chef Chad Rosenthal didn’t just open a restaurant in 2013. He basically planted a flag. Before The Lucky Well, Ambler was "up and coming," but Rosenthal—a guy you’ve probably seen on Food Network Star or beating Bobby Flay with a fried chicken sandwich—gave people a reason to make the drive from Philly.
He called it "Memphis-style." That meant dry rubs. No drowning the meat in sauce before it hits the plate. You got the St. Louis ribs, the brisket, and those wings that people still talk about in hushed, reverent tones. It was high-end BBQ but felt casual. It had that "fine dining in a t-shirt" vibe that’s hard to pull off without looking like you're trying too wide.
💡 You might also like: Different Kinds of Dreads: What Your Stylist Probably Won't Tell You
The name itself was a throwback. Years ago, there was an old Lucky Well hotel in the region. Rosenthal grabbed that bit of history and ran with it. He even put a horseshoe in the logo. For a long time, the luck held.
Why Did The Lucky Well in Ambler PA Actually Close?
Let’s get real. Running a BBQ joint is a nightmare for the margins.
Rosenthal was pretty transparent about it when he called it quits at the end of 2023. You’ve got the rising cost of meat—brisket isn't getting any cheaper—and the lingering hangover from the pandemic. It’s a lot of overhead for a massive footprint on Main Street.
By December 31, 2023, the party was over.
📖 Related: Desi Bazar Desi Kitchen: Why Your Local Grocer is Actually the Best Place to Eat
But it wasn’t a "failure" in the way people think. It was a pivot. The building was sold to the crew behind Cantina Feliz. If you’re from the area, you know them from Fort Washington. They saw an opportunity to move their Mexican concept into the heart of Ambler, and Rosenthal saw a chance to stop worrying about a 100-seat dining room every Tuesday night.
What’s Happening at 111 E Butler Ave Now?
If you go to the old spot today, you aren't getting pulled pork.
Cantina Feliz officially took over the space in 2024. It’s a different energy—tequila and tacos instead of whiskey and brisket—but the "good bones" of the building are still there. The move actually made a ton of sense for the town. It kept a prime piece of real estate from sitting empty, which is the death knell for small-town Main Streets.
Meanwhile, Chad Rosenthal didn't just disappear into the sunset. He’s been busy.
👉 See also: Deg f to deg c: Why We’re Still Doing Mental Math in 2026
- Rosey’s Banh Mi: Right across the street. If you miss his cooking, go get a sandwich there.
- The Mary Ambler: A new tavern concept he’s been working on at 47 East Butler Avenue.
- The Experience Group: This is his way of doing BBQ without the restaurant. Think live-fire catering at farms, wineries, and even your own backyard.
The Legacy of the Smoke
People still search for The Lucky Well Ambler PA because it left a mark. It was the place where you’d hear live blues on a Saturday night while the kids messy-faced their way through a pile of cornbread.
Some people hated the price. "Twenty bucks for wings?" was a common gripe on Reddit. But for those who got it, they got it. It was about the wood-burning broiler and the fact that the mac and cheese was topped with Cheez-Its. You can't fake that kind of soul.
Moving Forward: Your Ambler Food Strategy
If you’re heading to Ambler looking for that Lucky Well vibe, you have to adjust your expectations. The BBQ era of 111 E Butler is in the history books, but the culinary scene in the borough is arguably stronger now than it was when Chad first opened.
- For the Tacos: Hit up the new Cantina Feliz in the old Lucky Well spot. The atmosphere is still great, and the margaritas are top-tier.
- For the Chef’s Touch: Visit Rosey’s Banh Mi. It’s smaller, more intimate, and reminds you why Rosenthal is a household name in the first place.
- For the Future: Keep an eye on The Mary Ambler. It’s a love letter to Pennsylvania, with everything in the tavern sourced from within the state.
The "luck" didn't run out; it just changed shape. Ambler is still a destination, even if the smoke has cleared.
Next Steps:
If you're missing that specific Lucky Well flavor, you can still book the Experience Group for private events. For a casual lunch, head to Rosey's Banh Mi at 58 E. Butler Ave to see what Chef Rosenthal is cooking up this week.