You know the one. If you grew up in the nineties, that white plastic clamshell case was basically a permanent fixture on your living room floor. But the The Little Mermaid cover—specifically the original 1989 VHS release—isn't just a piece of nostalgia. It’s a genuine piece of pop culture folklore that launched a thousand urban legends and one of the first truly viral "scandals" before the internet even really existed.
Honestly, looking at it now, it’s wild how much drama one drawing caused.
The story goes that a disgruntled Disney artist, facing the chopping block or just feeling chaotic, hid a very suggestive shape right in the middle of King Triton’s golden palace. You’ve probably heard the rumors. People claimed it was a deliberate act of rebellion. Others thought it was a subliminal message. But when you actually dig into the history of that specific The Little Mermaid cover, the reality is a lot more mundane—and a lot more interesting for anyone who cares about how animation marketing actually works.
The Phallic Palace: What Really Happened with the Art?
Let’s get the elephant in the room out of the way. If you look at the central spire of the castle on the original 1989 home video release, it looks... questionable. There is no point in denying it. It doesn't look like a standard turret. It looks like something that belongs in an R-rated movie, not a film about a ginger mermaid who wants legs.
For years, the legend was that an animator who was about to be fired drew it as a "parting gift" to the company. It’s a great story. It's the kind of thing you’d whisper to your friends during a sleepover while pausing the tape.
But it's fake.
The truth is that the artist wasn't even a Disney employee. His name is Dan Perri. He was a freelance illustrator. He’s actually a legend in the industry—he designed the opening crawl for Star Wars and the titles for Raging Bull. When he sat down to do the The Little Mermaid cover, he was rushing. He was working under a brutal deadline. He told the Huffington Post in an interview years later that he was working late into the night, and the shapes just... happened.
It wasn't a conspiracy. It was a tired guy trying to finish a palace in the dark.
👉 See also: The Entire History of You: What Most People Get Wrong About the Grain
Disney eventually pulled the cover. They didn't do it immediately, but once the "shouting" started from concerned parents and urban legend trackers, they swapped the art for a much safer version. If you have the original "Black Diamond" edition in your attic, you’re holding a piece of accidental controversy.
Why the Black Diamond Edition Isn't Actually Worth $10,000
While we're on the subject of that The Little Mermaid cover, we need to talk about the eBay madness.
You’ve seen the headlines. "Rare Disney VHS sells for the price of a mid-sized sedan!" It makes for great clickbait. People see that controversial palace art and assume they are sitting on a gold mine. They list their "Black Diamond" copies for $5,000, $10,000, even $25,000.
But here’s the reality check: No one is buying them for that.
The "Black Diamond" logo just meant it was part of the "Walt Disney Classics" collection. They produced millions of them. Millions. Even with the "naughty" cover art, there are so many copies in circulation that the rarity factor is basically zero. If you check "Sold" listings on eBay instead of "Active" ones, you’ll see they usually go for about $5 to $20. Maybe $50 if it’s literally never been opened and the shrink-wrap is pristine.
The value isn't in the plastic. It’s in the memory.
The Evolution of Ariel’s Aesthetic
Disney is obsessed with "the vault." They rotate their movies in and out of availability to create artificial scarcity. Because of this, the The Little Mermaid cover has been redesigned more times than almost any other Disney property.
✨ Don't miss: Shamea Morton and the Real Housewives of Atlanta: What Really Happened to Her Peach
- The 1989 Original: The one with the palace drama.
- The 1998 Re-release: They went for a much softer, more "painted" look. The colors were warmer, and Triton was moved to the background to focus entirely on Ariel and Eric.
- The Platinum Edition (2006): This is where things got digital. The colors became neon. Ariel’s hair started looking less like hair and more like a red silk ribbon.
- The Diamond Edition (2013): Total CGI overhaul for the 2D characters.
Every time they change the cover, they change how we perceive Ariel. In the '89 version, she looked like a curious teenager. By the 2013 version, she looked like a polished pop star.
The Live-Action Shift: Halle Bailey’s New Iconography
We can't talk about the The Little Mermaid cover without mentioning the 2023 live-action shift. This was a massive moment for Disney. The cover art for the 2023 film had to do something the 1989 version didn't: establish a brand-new visual identity for a character everyone thought they already knew.
The 2023 poster and subsequent Blu-ray cover took a "realistic" approach. Instead of the bright, flat blues of the original, they went for deep-sea teals and cinematic lighting. It was a polarizing move. Some fans missed the vibrant "Disney yellow" and "Ariel red," while others loved the ethereal, bioluminescent vibe.
What’s fascinating is how the 2023 The Little Mermaid cover avoids the clutter of the old days. The 1989 art was packed. You had Flounder, Sebastian, Ursula, Triton, Eric, and the palace all fighting for space. The new era is minimalist. It’s just Halle Bailey sitting on a rock, looking up at the surface. It’s about mood, not a character roll-call.
Spotting a Bootleg vs. a Rare Original
If you are actually looking to collect the original The Little Mermaid cover, you have to be careful. Because of the "Banned Cover" hype, some people have actually started printing fake inserts.
- Check the Gloss: Original Disney VHS inserts have a very specific semi-gloss finish. If it looks like it came out of a home inkjet printer on matte paper, it’s a fake.
- The Spine Logo: The "Black Diamond" should be at the very top of the spine.
- The UPC Code: On the back of the 1989 release, the barcode is usually smaller than on later 90s releases.
The Cultural Weight of a VHS Box
It sounds silly to get worked up over a piece of cardboard stuck under some plastic. But the The Little Mermaid cover represents a specific era of parenting and childhood. It was the peak of the "Disney Renaissance."
When you look at that cover, you aren't just seeing a movie. You’re seeing the moment Disney went from a struggling studio to a global titan again. The Little Mermaid saved Disney's animation department. If that movie had flopped, we wouldn't have Beauty and the Beast or The Lion King.
🔗 Read more: Who is Really in the Enola Holmes 2 Cast? A Look at the Faces Behind the Mystery
The cover was our first window into that world.
Even the controversy—the "phallic" palace—is a part of that. It represents a time when we looked closer at things. Before you could Google "Ariel castle controversy," you had to hear it from a cousin or see it for yourself. It created a sense of mystery. It made the movie feel slightly "dangerous" in a way that modern, corporate-sanitized Disney art just doesn't.
Moving Forward: What to Do With Your Old Copies
If you have an old copy of the The Little Mermaid cover sitting in a box, don't throw it away, but don't plan your retirement around it either.
First, verify the edition. Look at the palace. If it’s the original "banned" art, it’s a cool conversation piece. If it’s the revised version from 1990, it’s just a standard VHS.
Second, check the condition. VHS tapes degrade over time. If the tape has white mold spots on the spools (look through the little windows), it's dead. The cover art might be fine, but the movie is gone.
Third, decide on display. Many collectors are now taking the original The Little Mermaid cover inserts out of the bulky plastic cases and framing them. They make for great retro wall art, especially given the vibrant 80s color palette that Disney used back then.
Honestly, the "banned" cover is a reminder that even massive corporations make mistakes. It’s a reminder that behind every "perfect" Disney product, there’s a human artist working a 14-hour shift, just trying to get a palace to look right before the sun comes up.
Stop checking the eBay prices for the $10,000 listings. They aren't real. Instead, appreciate the 1989 The Little Mermaid cover for what it is: a weird, slightly chaotic, and accidentally legendary piece of animation history that defined a generation’s Friday nights.
If you're looking to buy one today for the sake of nostalgia, stick to local thrift stores or "Lot" auctions. You can usually snag the original art for less than the price of a latte. Just make sure you look closely at the spires before you put it on your shelf. Or don't. That’s part of the fun.