Everyone has one. You’re at a bar, or a first date, or stuck in a long car ride, and someone asks the dreaded question: "What’s your list of favorite movies?"
Suddenly, your brain wipes itself clean. You forget every film you’ve ever seen. You end up mumbling something about The Godfather because it feels safe, even though you haven't actually watched it since 2014. Picking a "favorite" isn't just about what you enjoy watching on a Sunday afternoon with a bowl of popcorn; it’s a weirdly personal branding exercise. People use these lists to signal who they are, how smart they think they are, and whether they’ve spent too much time on Letterboxd.
Why We Fail at Making a List of Favorite Movies
Most people approach their list of favorite movies all wrong. We get caught between "The Best" and "The Favorite." There is a massive, gaping canyon between those two things. Schindler’s List is objectively one of the greatest films ever made, but is it your favorite? Probably not, unless you enjoy being emotionally devastated every weekend.
Honestly, a real list should be messy. It should have that one weird cult classic that has a 24% on Rotten Tomatoes alongside a Masterpiece with a capital M. If your list is just the IMDb Top 250, you’re boring. If it’s only black-and-white French New Wave films, you’re trying too hard. The sweet spot is the overlap of nostalgia, technical brilliance, and that "I can’t turn this off if it’s on TV" energy.
The "Comfort Movie" Trap
We often confuse quality with comfort. Look at the data from streaming services like Netflix or Max. Year after year, the movies that get the most "rewatch" hours aren't the Oscar winners. They are films like The Mummy (1999) or Mean Girls.
Why? Because a list of favorite movies is often a map of our own history. You love Jurassic Park because you remember the smell of the theater in 1993 and how big those footsteps sounded in the Dolby surround sound. That’s valid. In fact, film critics like Roger Ebert often talked about how movies are "machines that generate empathy." If a movie generates a specific, positive memory for you, it earns its spot. Period.
The Critics vs. The Rest of Us
There’s always a tension between what the "experts" say and what actually sticks in the cultural craw. Take The Shawshank Redemption. When it came out in 1994, it was a box office dud. It barely made its budget back. But through cable TV repetitions and word-of-mouth, it became the permanent #1 on almost every fan-voted list of favorite movies for decades.
📖 Related: Alfonso Cuarón: Why the Harry Potter 3 Director Changed the Wizarding World Forever
On the flip side, look at something like Citizen Kane. It’s the "correct" answer for the greatest movie ever. But how many people actually sit down and watch it for fun? Not many.
The Problem With "Objective" Greatness
The American Film Institute (AFI) updates their lists every so often, and they usually lean heavily on the classics. Casablanca, Singin' in the Rain, Lawrence of Arabia. These are foundational. They taught us how to use cameras and tell stories. But the modern viewer has a different relationship with pacing.
If you're building your own list of favorite movies, don't feel obligated to include the "greats" just because a textbook told you to. If you find 2001: A Space Odyssey boring, don't put it on there. Your list is a reflection of your taste, not a history exam.
How Your Favorites Change as You Age
This is the weirdest part of being a cinephile. Your list of favorite movies at age 17 is almost certainly not your list at age 35.
When you're a teenager, you want movies that feel edgy or profound. You might be obsessed with Fight Club or Donnie Darko. You want to feel like you’ve discovered a secret truth about the world. Then you hit your 30s, you’re tired, you have a mortgage, and suddenly Chef (2014) feels like the greatest achievement in cinematic history because it’s just a guy making sandwiches and being a good dad.
The Evolution of Perspective
Cinema is a mirror. When you watch The Graduate as a kid, you identify with Dustin Hoffman. You feel the angst of not knowing what to do with your life. You watch it as an adult, and you realize everyone in that movie is a mess.
👉 See also: Why the Cast of Hold Your Breath 2024 Makes This Dust Bowl Horror Actually Work
This shifting perspective is why "re-watchability" is the ultimate metric. If a movie gives you something new every time you see it, it’s a lifer. It stays on the list.
The Genre Bias
We have a bad habit of excluding certain genres from our list of favorite movies. Comedy and Horror get the short end of the stick constantly.
Why is a sweeping historical epic considered "better" than a perfectly timed comedy like Airplane!? It takes an incredible amount of craft to make people laugh or scream. Yet, when we think of our "favorites," we often filter out the "low-brow" stuff to sound more sophisticated.
- Horror: Think of Hereditary or The Thing. These aren't just jump scares; they are masterclasses in tension and practical effects.
- Comedy: A movie like Popstar: Never Stop Never Stopping might be more tightly written than many dramas, but it rarely makes the "Favorite" cut in public discussions.
- Action: Mad Max: Fury Road is essentially a silent film told through explosions. It belongs on any serious list.
Stop self-censoring. If Paddington 2 is your favorite movie, scream it from the rooftops. It’s a perfect film.
Building Your Own Canon
If you actually want to sit down and curate a list of favorite movies that feels authentic, you need a system. Not a boring 1-to-10 scale, but a gut-check system.
Ask yourself these three questions:
✨ Don't miss: Is Steven Weber Leaving Chicago Med? What Really Happened With Dean Archer
- If I’m flipping through channels and this is on, do I stop and watch the rest?
- Does this movie represent a specific time in my life I want to remember?
- Do I find myself quoting this movie in everyday conversation?
If the answer to all three is yes, you’ve found a winner.
Avoiding the Recency Bias
We all do it. We see a great new movie—let's say Everything Everywhere All At Once—and we immediately want to put it in the Top 5. Give it time. A true list of favorite movies needs to bake. Wait two years. If you still want to watch it as much as you did the first week, then it’s a permanent fixture.
The Global Perspective
We often get stuck in the Hollywood bubble. But some of the most life-changing entries for a list of favorite movies come from outside the US.
South Korean cinema has been on a tear for two decades. Parasite broke the barrier, but Oldboy (the original, please) and Memories of Murder are essential. Then there’s the Japanese animation of Studio Ghibli. Spirited Away isn't just a "cartoon"; it’s a visual feast that rivals any live-action epic.
Expanding your horizons doesn't just make you look smarter; it literally changes how you see the world. It’s hard to stay stuck in your own head when you’re watching a masterpiece from a culture 6,000 miles away.
Why Your List Matters
Ultimately, your list of favorite movies is a way to connect. It’s a conversation starter. When you share it, you’re giving someone a key to your personality.
It tells them if you’re a romantic, a cynic, a thrill-seeker, or someone who just really likes talking about the "lighting" in Blade Runner 2049. (We get it, the lighting is amazing.)
Don't be afraid to have "guilty pleasures." Actually, scratch that. There’s no such thing as a guilty pleasure in movies. If you like it, you like it. The guilt is just your ego trying to get in the way of your fun.
Actionable Steps for Your Movie Journey
- Audit your watch history: Look at your Letterboxd or Netflix history. What have you actually watched more than three times? Those are your real favorites.
- Ignore the "Must-See" lists for a week: Stop trying to catch up on what's "important" and watch something that genuinely sounds fun.
- Write it down: Keep a physical or digital note of your Top 10. Update it once a year. It’s a fascinating way to track your own personal growth.
- Host a "Favorites" night: Instead of watching a new release, have a friend over to watch their absolute favorite movie that you’ve never seen. It’s the fastest way to understand someone.
- Check out a different decade: If your list is all 2010s and 2020s, go back to the 70s—the "New Hollywood" era. Films like The Long Goodbye or Network feel surprisingly modern.