C.S. Lewis was once told by his friend J.R.R. Tolkien that his children’s story was a mess. Tolkien, a man who spent decades perfecting the philology and internal consistency of Middle-earth, couldn’t stand how Lewis mashed together Greek fauns, Father Christmas, and talking beavers. He thought the blend was jarring. He was wrong. Decades later, The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe remains a cornerstone of the fantasy genre, not because it’s a perfectly polished piece of world-building, but because it captures a specific kind of childhood longing that most "perfect" books miss entirely.
It's about a wardrobe. Just a big, dusty piece of furniture.
Most people remember the basics: the Pevensie siblings—Peter, Susan, Edmund, and Lucy—get sent to the English countryside to escape the Blitz. They find a portal. They meet a lion. They kill a witch. But if you haven't read it since you were ten, you've probably forgotten how visceral it is. The story isn't just a "charming tale." It’s a story about betrayal, the freezing cold of a perpetual winter, and the specific, sugary lure of Turkish Delight that leads a boy to sell out his family. Honestly, the stakes are higher than we usually give it credit for.
What People Get Wrong About Narnia
There’s a common misconception that Narnia is just a heavy-handed religious allegory. Lewis himself actually hated that term. He preferred to call it a "supposal." He wasn't trying to write a Sunday school lesson; he was asking, "Suppose there was a world like Narnia, and suppose a Christ-like figure entered it—what would happen?"
Because of this, the world feels lived-in. It’s messy.
Take the White Witch, Jadis. She isn't just a generic "bad guy." She is a terrifying psychological manipulator. When she meets Edmund, she doesn't use magic to force him into submission. She uses comfort. She gives him a warm coat and a box of candy. That's a deep, human observation about how people are actually corrupted. It’s not usually through some grand, dramatic choice to be evil; it’s through the desire for one more piece of candy, one more bit of validation, and the feeling that your siblings are looking down on you.
The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe and the Reality of War
We have to talk about the 1940s context. The Pevensies are "evacuees." This wasn't some whimsical plot device Lewis invented; it was the reality for thousands of British children during World War II. They were stripped from their parents and sent to live with strangers in the country to avoid being killed by bombs.
That trauma sits right beneath the surface of the text.
When Lucy crawls into the wardrobe, she isn't just looking for adventure. She’s looking for an escape from a world that has become incomprehensibly violent. The "Always winter but never Christmas" curse isn't just a magical trope. It’s a metaphor for the stagnation and hopelessness of war-torn Europe. When Father Christmas finally shows up, it’s not just a cameo for the kids—it’s a signal that the "long winter" of the war is ending. It’s a sign of life returning to a dead world.
📖 Related: Ashley Johnson: The Last of Us Voice Actress Who Changed Everything
The Problem with Edmund
Edmund Pevensie is, hands down, the most interesting character in the book. Everyone wants to be a Peter or a Lucy, but most of us are Edmunds. He’s spiteful because he’s miserable. He’s the "middle child" archetype pushed to the absolute limit.
His redemption isn't easy, either.
In the 2005 film adaptation directed by Andrew Adamson, they emphasize this by showing his face as he realizes the Witch has no intention of making him a king. In the book, Lewis is even more blunt. Edmund spends a significant portion of the story being treated like a slave by the Witch, watching her turn innocent creatures into stone. The "Deep Magic" that demands his life isn't a fairy tale rule; it’s a legalistic reality of the Narnian universe. It makes the eventual sacrifice of Aslan feel heavy. You feel the weight of it because you know Edmund actually deserved the punishment under the laws of that world.
The Inklings and the Creation of a Legend
Lewis wrote the book at a time when "Children’s Literature" wasn't really a respected category. He was a Don at Oxford. He was supposed to be writing scholarly papers on 16th-century English literature.
The story actually started with a single image: a Faun carrying an umbrella and parcels in a snowy wood.
Lewis had that image in his head since he was sixteen. It took him decades to find the story that went with it. He and J.R.R. Tolkien were part of a writing group called The Inklings. They’d meet at a pub called The Eagle and Child in Oxford (you can still go there today; it's tiny and smells like old wood) and read their drafts to each other. Tolkien’s critiques were legendary. He thought Lewis was too rushed. He thought the world was inconsistent.
But Lewis didn't care about consistency. He cared about the feeling of the story.
Why the Wardrobe is Such a Powerful Symbol
Why a wardrobe? Why not a mirror or a rabbit hole?
👉 See also: Archie Bunker's Place Season 1: Why the All in the Family Spin-off Was Weirder Than You Remember
A wardrobe is a transition point. It’s full of fur coats that smell of mothballs—a very specific, sensory detail that grounds the magic in reality. It’s also a domestic object. Magic isn't something you find on a distant mountaintop in this book; it’s something you find in the spare room of a house where you’re staying.
- It represents the threshold between childhood and adulthood.
- It’s a safe space that becomes a doorway.
- It demands curiosity.
If you don't push past the fur coats, you never find the pine needles. Lewis is telling the reader that the "real world" is much thinner than we think.
The White Witch vs. Aslan: A Study in Power
The power dynamic in The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe is fascinating because Aslan is "not a tame lion." This is the most famous line in the series for a reason.
The Witch represents "power over." She rules through fear, statues, and a secret police force (led by Maugrim the wolf). Her power is brittle. The moment it starts to thaw, she panics. Aslan, on the other hand, represents "power with." He doesn't just show up and roar the Witch into oblivion. He lets the children lead. He lets them fight. He even allows himself to be humiliated and killed at the Stone Table to satisfy a law he didn't even create.
This flipped the script on what a "hero" looked like in 1950.
The Lasting Legacy of the 2005 Movie
While there have been several adaptations (including the BBC version with the very questionable animatronic beavers), the 2005 Disney/Walden Media film changed everything. It brought a "Lord of the Rings" scale to Narnia.
Tilda Swinton’s performance as the White Witch is iconic. She didn't play her as a screaming hag; she played her as cold, regal, and terrifyingly calm. That film solidified the visual language of Narnia for a whole new generation. It made the battle at Beruna feel like a real war, which, as we discussed, was always the underlying subtext of the book.
However, the book still holds details the movies miss. The ending of the book is surprisingly melancholic. The Pevensies grow up in Narnia. They live there for years. They become adults, kings, and queens. They forget their lives in England. Then, they tumble back through the wardrobe and are children again. The "growing up" they did is gone in the eyes of the world, but they carry the weight of those years with them.
✨ Don't miss: Anne Hathaway in The Dark Knight Rises: What Most People Get Wrong
That’s a heavy concept for a kid to wrap their head around.
Practical Ways to Re-Experience Narnia
If you’re looking to dive back into this world, don't just watch the movie and call it a day. The experience of the text is different.
Read the books in the "Original" order. There is a massive debate about whether to read The Magician’s Nephew (the prequel) first or The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe first. Read The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe first. Always. The mystery of the lamp-post in the woods only works if you don't know where it came from yet.
Listen to the Focus on the Family Radio Theatre version. It’s arguably better than the movies. The sound design is incredible, and it features David Suchet as Aslan. It’s a full-cast production that captures the "Englishness" of the story perfectly.
Look at the original Pauline Baynes illustrations. Her line work is what Lewis himself loved. It’s delicate and a bit strange, which fits the tone of the book better than the glossy, modern covers.
Actionable Insights for Fans and Readers
To truly appreciate the depth of this work, you have to look past the surface-level "kids' book" label. Here is how you can engage with the material more deeply:
- Analyze the "Deep Magic": Research the concept of Literary Substitution. Look at how Lewis uses the legal framework of Narnia to explore the idea of grace versus law. It’s more complex than a simple "good vs. evil" battle.
- Explore the Inklings' Connection: Read the letters between C.S. Lewis and J.R.R. Tolkien. Their friendship was fraught with creative tension, and Narnia was a major sticking point for them. Understanding their disagreement helps you see what Lewis was trying to do differently from the "high fantasy" of the era.
- Visit the Real-Life Inspirations: If you ever find yourself in Oxford, visit the University Church of St Mary the Virgin. The door to the vestry has a carving of a lion's head and is flanked by two golden fawns. It’s widely believed to be the visual spark for the characters of Aslan and Mr. Tumnus.
- Consider the Environment: Pay attention to how Lewis uses the weather as a character. The transition from the "Always Winter" to the spring thaw is one of the most celebrated descriptions of seasonal change in literature. It’s a masterclass in using setting to mirror internal character development.
The story of the Pevensies isn't just a relic of the 1950s. It’s a blueprint for how we deal with cold, dark times. It suggests that even when the world feels frozen and "the Witch" seems to be winning, there are forces moving "under the ice" that we can't see yet. As Lewis wrote, "Spring will come again." That's a message that never goes out of style.