Walk into any gas station in America and you’ll see it. A wall of green and yellow plastic. It’s overwhelming. Most people just grab whatever is cold without thinking, but there is actually a massive, multi-billion dollar chess game happening between Crush, Sprite, Squirt, and Starry.
Honestly, the soda aisle is kind of a mess right now.
For decades, Sprite was the undisputed king of the "un-cola" world. Then PepsiCo decided to kill off Sierra Mist—a brand that had been limping along for years—and replace it with Starry. Suddenly, the marketing budget for lemon-lime surged. But where does that leave a cult favorite like Squirt? Or the fruit-heavy profile of Crush?
It’s not just about sugar and bubbles. It’s about distribution networks, citrus oil ratios, and the fact that our taste buds are changing. People are moving away from the heavy syrupy feel of old-school sodas toward something a bit "crisper." That word—crisp—is basically the holy grail for beverage executives right now.
The Starry vs. Sprite Showdown
Let's get real about Starry. When it launched in early 2023, everyone thought it was just Sierra Mist in a louder can. It wasn't. PepsiCo changed the formula to be more "citrus-forward."
What does that actually mean? It means they upped the acidity to compete directly with Sprite's bite.
Sprite has this specific throat hit. It’s sharp. Since 1961, Coca-Cola has refined that formula to be the perfect palate cleanser. If you’re eating a greasy burger, Sprite cuts through the fat. Starry is trying to do the same thing but with a heavy focus on Gen Z marketing. They use bright, clashing colors and TikTok-friendly aesthetics.
But here is the thing: Sprite has LeBron James and a 60-year head start. According to data from Beverage Digest, Sprite consistently holds a massive chunk of the market share, often ranking as the third or fourth most popular soda in the world, trailing only the big colas. Starry is the underdog, fighting for shelf space that used to be guaranteed.
Why Squirt is the Wildcard
If Sprite is the king and Starry is the challenger, Squirt is the cool indie cousin that everyone forgets is actually a powerhouse.
Squirt is different. It’s not just lemon-lime; it’s grapefruit. That changes everything. Created by Herb Bishop in 1938, Squirt was marketed as a soda that required less sugar because grapefruit is naturally "bright."
👉 See also: The Gospel of Matthew: What Most People Get Wrong About the First Book of the New Testament
You’ve probably noticed that Squirt has a cloudy appearance. That’s because it uses actual grapefruit juice (concentrated, obviously). It gives it a dry, sophisticated finish that you just don’t get from the syrupy sweetness of a Crush Orange or a standard Starry.
In the Southwest and Mexico, Squirt is a religion. It’s the backbone of the Paloma cocktail. While Sprite and Starry fight over who gets to be the "refreshing" choice for teenagers, Squirt quietly dominates the mixer market and the adult demographic that finds standard sodas too cloying.
The Crush Factor: More Than Just Orange
We need to talk about Crush. Most people think "Orange Crush" and stop there. But Crush is actually a massive portfolio owned by Keurig Dr Pepper.
Crush doesn't really try to compete in the "crisp lemon-lime" space directly. Instead, it plays the flavor game. While Crush, Sprite, Squirt, and Starry all live in the same refrigerated case, Crush is there for when you want a treat, not a thirst-quencher.
Crush is heavy. It’s bold. It’s very, very sweet.
The brand started all the way back in 1911 with Clayton J. Powel’s "Ward’s Orange Crush." Today, it serves as the alternative for people who find the lemon-lime category a bit boring. However, in the grand scheme of "citrus" soda wars, Crush is often the baseline. It’s the "fruit" soda that everyone else has to beat.
Flavor Profiles and Carbonation Levels
If you really want to understand the difference, you have to look at the carbonation.
- Sprite: High carbonation, sharp "pointy" bubbles, heavy lemon-lime zest.
- Starry: High carbonation, sweeter finish, more "lime" than "lemon" notes.
- Squirt: Medium carbonation, dry mouthfeel, tart grapefruit acidity.
- Crush: Lower perceived carbonation because the high sugar content masks the "bite," fruit-forward.
The Business of Thirst
Why did Pepsi kill Sierra Mist for Starry? Business is cold. Sierra Mist was seen as "your mom's soda." It was natural, used real sugar for a while, and was generally considered "nice."
"Nice" doesn't sell.
✨ Don't miss: God Willing and the Creek Don't Rise: The True Story Behind the Phrase Most People Get Wrong
PepsiCo saw that Sprite was eating their lunch in the fountain drink sector. When you go to a fast-food joint, the lemon-lime option is almost always Sprite (if it's a Coke fountain) or it was Sierra Mist. But Sierra Mist didn't have the "cool" factor to drive sales. Starry was a calculated, multi-million dollar gamble to reclaim that "crisp" identity.
Keurig Dr Pepper (KDP) watches this from the sidelines with Squirt and Crush. They don't have to be number one. They just have to be the best alternative. KDP’s distribution model is fascinating because they often partner with either Pepsi or Coke bottlers depending on the region. This means you might see Squirt in a Coke vending machine in one state and a Pepsi machine in another.
The Health Shift
We can’t ignore the elephant in the room: sugar.
All these brands are panicking because people are drinking less full-sugar soda. This is why you see a massive push for Starry Zero Sugar and Sprite Zero. Squirt Zero Sugar is actually one of the best-reviewed diet sodas on the market because the bitterness of the grapefruit hides the aftertaste of artificial sweeteners like aspartame and ace-K.
Crush has a harder time here. People drink Crush for the indulgence. A "diet" Orange Crush is a harder sell because the whole point of the drink is that thick, syrupy nostalgia.
Which One Should You Actually Drink?
It depends on what you're doing.
If you are eating spicy food, like hot wings or Nashville hot chicken, Sprite is the scientific winner. The high carbonation and lime acidity help wash away the capsaicin.
If you’re mixing a drink, grab the Squirt. The grapefruit oils interact with tequila and gin in a way that lemon-lime simply can't. It adds a layer of complexity.
If you want something that feels "modern" and maybe a bit sweeter, Starry is the play. It’s designed to be a "snack" drink—something you have on its own rather than with a meal.
🔗 Read more: Kiko Japanese Restaurant Plantation: Why This Local Spot Still Wins the Sushi Game
And Crush? Save that for a hot summer day at a BBQ when you want to feel like you’re ten years old again.
Surprising Facts About Your Favorite Bubbles
Did you know that in some parts of the world, Sprite has a significantly different sugar content? In the UK, for instance, Sprite was reformulated to include stevia years ago to avoid the "sugar tax." This changed the flavor profile significantly compared to the American version, which still relies heavily on High Fructose Corn Syrup (HFCS).
Squirt also has a unique history with "cloudiness." Most soda companies try to make their drinks clear because consumers associate clarity with purity. Squirt leaned into the cloud, using it to prove they actually used citrus oils. This was a massive marketing win in the 1950s.
Starry, despite being the "new kid," has already gone through a few minor packaging tweaks. PepsiCo is obsessed with the "visibility" of the can. If you look at a Starry can next to a Sprite can, the Starry green is much more "neon." It’s designed to vibrate against the red of a Coke can or the blue of a Pepsi can to grab your eye in 0.2 seconds.
The Mixology Angle
The "Dirty Soda" trend on TikTok has given new life to Crush, Sprite, Squirt, and Starry.
People are taking Sprite and adding coconut syrup and lime (the "Malibu" style without the booze). Or they take Squirt and add vanilla and cream. These brands aren't just standalone drinks anymore; they are "bases" for DIY mocktails. This shift in consumer behavior is likely what will keep these brands alive as traditional soda consumption drops.
Practical Steps for the Soda Connoisseur
Next time you're standing in front of that cooler, don't just grab the first green can you see. Think about the flavor balance.
- Check the Date: Soda doesn't "expire" in a way that makes you sick, but plastic bottles lose carbonation after about 6-9 months. Always grab from the back of the shelf for the freshest "bite."
- Glass vs. Plastic: If you can find Mexican Sprite or Squirt in glass bottles, buy them. They use cane sugar instead of HFCS, which provides a cleaner finish and doesn't leave that "film" on your teeth.
- Temperature Matters: Sprite and Starry are designed to be consumed at near-freezing temperatures. If they warm up even slightly, the sweetness becomes overpowering. Squirt, however, holds its flavor profile better as it warms because of the grapefruit acidity.
- The Fountain Test: Most fast-food places have "calibrated" machines. McDonald’s is famous for having the best Sprite because they chill the water and the syrup separately before mixing. If you want the "baseline" flavor of any of these brands, try them from a high-volume fountain rather than a can.
The "Lemon-Lime War" isn't ending anytime soon. As long as we keep eating salty snacks and looking for a "crisp" escape, these four brands will continue to tweak their formulas and fight for our attention. Whether you want the sharp bite of a Sprite, the grapefruit tang of a Squirt, the modern sweetness of a Starry, or the bold fruit of a Crush, there's actually a lot of science—and even more marketing—inside those bubbles.
For the best experience, try a side-by-side taste test. It's the only way to truly see how much PepsiCo has moved the needle with Starry compared to the classic Sprite profile. You might find that your loyalty to a specific brand is more about the memory of the taste than the taste itself.