Everyone knows the rhyme. It’s catchy, rhythmic, and completely wrong. "Lizzie Borden took an axe and gave her mother forty whacks." It’s the kind of thing kids chant on playgrounds when they want to feel a little thrill of the macabre. But honestly, if you look at the actual forensic reports from 1892, the numbers don’t even come close. Abby Borden, the stepmother, took about 18 or 19 hits. Her husband, Andrew, took 11. Still horrific? Absolutely. But 40? That’s just Victorian tabloid energy working overtime.
The legend of Lizzie Borden has survived for over a century because it’s the perfect storm of class, gender, and a really bloody mystery that technically remains unsolved. We love a "whodunit," especially one where the main suspect is a Sunday-school-teaching "spinster" who might have hacked her parents to pieces before lunch.
The Morning of the Whacks
August 4, 1892, was a swamp. Fall River, Massachusetts, was suffering through a brutal heatwave. Imagine 90-degree humidity in a house with no indoor plumbing and heavy Victorian wool clothing. It’s enough to make anyone irritable.
Andrew Borden was a wealthy man—worth millions in today’s money—but he was notoriously cheap. He lived in a cramped house on Second Street because it was close to his business, even though he could have easily afforded a mansion on "The Hill." This created a lot of friction. Lizzie and her sister Emma were in their 30s and 40s, essentially stuck in a house they hated with a stepmother they didn't like.
On that Tuesday morning, Andrew went downtown for business. Abby went upstairs to tidy the guest room. Somewhere between 9:00 AM and 10:30 AM, someone cornered Abby in that guest room. They didn't just kill her; they obliterated her. The first blow caught her above the ear, and once she was down, the killer just kept going.
Then, the killer waited.
For nearly an hour and a half, someone stayed in that house while Abby's body lay upstairs. When Andrew came home for an early nap, he laid down on the sofa. He didn't even have time to wake up. The killer struck him 11 times, so violently that one of his eyes was split clean in half.
💡 You might also like: The Recipe Marble Pound Cake Secrets Professional Bakers Don't Usually Share
Why the Police Fumbled the Bag
The investigation was, to put it mildly, a dumpster fire.
The Fall River police were basically playing catch-up from minute one. They didn't even check Lizzie for bloodstains right away because they couldn't wrap their heads around the idea that a "well-bred" woman could do something so primal. They didn't seal the crime scene. Neighbors, doctors, and curious onlookers were wandering in and out of the house, probably trampling over every piece of physical evidence available.
Then there’s the dress.
A few days after the murders, a friend saw Lizzie burning a blue dress in the kitchen stove. Lizzie claimed it was "covered in old paint." If you’re a detective, that’s a massive red flag. But again, she was a Borden. She was a lady. They let it slide for a bit.
When they finally got her to the inquest, Lizzie’s testimony was a mess of contradictions. She said she was in the barn looking for "lead sinkers" for a fishing trip. The barn loft was a literal oven—the police found no footprints in the thick dust on the floor. She also claimed a "messenger" had brought a note for Abby, which is why she didn't check on her. No note was ever found. No messenger ever came forward.
The Trial That Transfixed America
The trial in 1893 was basically the O.J. Simpson trial of the 19th century. People were obsessed.
📖 Related: Why the Man Black Hair Blue Eyes Combo is So Rare (and the Genetics Behind It)
The prosecution had a mountain of circumstantial evidence. They had the "paint-stained" dress. They had a druggist who testified that Lizzie tried to buy prussic acid (a deadly poison) the day before the murders. They had the fact that the house was locked from the inside, meaning an intruder would have had to be a ninja to get in and out unseen.
But the defense had one thing that trumped it all: Victorian gender roles.
The defense lawyer basically asked the jury, "Does she look like a fiend?" He argued that a woman of her social standing was physically and temperamentally incapable of such a crime. And the jury—twelve men who likely couldn't imagine their own daughters or sisters swinging a hatchet—bought it. They acquitted her in about an hour of actual deliberation.
Life After the Verdict: Maplecroft and Ostracism
Most people think Lizzie vanished after the trial. She didn't.
She and Emma inherited their father's fortune and did exactly what he never let them do: they moved to "The Hill." They bought a 14-room mansion called Maplecroft. Lizzie started going by "Lizbeth." She bought a carriage, hired servants, and started living the life of a wealthy socialite.
But Fall River has a long memory.
👉 See also: Chuck E. Cheese in Boca Raton: Why This Location Still Wins Over Parents
She was a pariah. When she went to church, people moved out of her pew. Children threw eggs at her house. She eventually became a recluse, spending her time with theater people and her beloved pets. Interestingly, she and Emma had a massive falling out in 1905—rumored to be over Lizzie’s "bohemian" lifestyle and friendship with actress Nance O'Neil—and they never spoke again. They died days apart in 1927.
What Really Happened?
If you talk to historians today, there are a few leading theories:
- Lizzie did it solo: She had the motive (money and resentment), the opportunity, and the "disposable" clothing.
- The Maid (Bridget Sullivan): Some think she was an accomplice or did it in a fit of rage after being told to wash windows in 90-degree heat while sick. But Bridget had no real motive to kill Andrew.
- The Secret Brother: A wilder theory suggests Andrew had an illegitimate son named William Borden who showed up for his piece of the pie. There's very little evidence for this, though.
Honestly? It was likely Lizzie. The "note" that didn't exist and the burning of the dress are just too convenient.
How to Explore the Legend Today
If you're actually into this stuff, don't just read about it.
- Stay at the Lizzie Borden House: It’s a Bed and Breakfast now in Fall River. You can literally sleep in the room where Abby was killed. It’s creepy, well-preserved, and they serve a breakfast similar to what the Bordens ate that morning (minus the tainted mutton).
- Visit Oak Grove Cemetery: You can see the family plot. Lizzie/Lizbeth is buried just a few feet away from the parents she was accused of murdering.
- Read the Trial Transcripts: The Fall River Historical Society has incredible archives. If you want the real story, skip the movies and read what Bridget Sullivan actually said on the stand.
The legend of Lizzie Borden isn't just about a murder. It's about a moment in time where social status was a better shield than any alibi.
To dig deeper into the forensic side of the case, you should look into the "Handless Hatchet" found in the basement. It was covered in ashes, as if someone had tried to burn off the blood and then broken the handle to hide the evidence. It’s the closest thing the case has to a smoking gun.
Check out the Fall River Historical Society’s virtual exhibits if you can't make the trip in person. They have the most extensive collection of Borden artifacts in the world, including the original crime scene photos that helped reconstruct the house exactly as it was.