If you only know the 2003 movie with Sean Connery, I’m sorry. Honestly. That film took a dense, transgressive, and deeply literary masterpiece and turned it into a generic Victorian superhero romp. It was a mess. But The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen comic is a completely different beast. It’s Alan Moore—the guy behind Watchmen and V for Vendetta—at his most obsessive. He and artist Kevin O'Neill didn't just want to make a "Justice League of the 1890s." They wanted to build a unified theory of every single piece of fiction ever written.
It started in 1999 under DC’s America's Best Comics imprint. The premise sounds simple: the British government, represented by a mysterious "M," recruits a group of literary characters to save the Empire. You've got Mina Murray from Dracula, Allan Quatermain from King Solomon's Mines, Captain Nemo, the Invisible Man (Hawley Griffin), and Dr. Jekyll.
But these aren't heroes. Not really.
Quatermain is a broken opium addict when we meet him. The Invisible Man is a literal rapist and a sociopath. Nemo hates the British Empire with a burning passion. It’s a group of monsters, addicts, and victims forced together because they happen to have "extraordinary" skill sets.
Why the League of Extraordinary Gentlemen comic matters now
Most modern "crossover" events feel like corporate synergy. You put Batman and Superman together because it sells lunchboxes. Alan Moore’s approach was the opposite. He treated fiction as a tangible, physical geography. In the world of The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen comic, if a book was written in the 19th century, those events actually happened.
That means when the League travels through the East End of London, they aren't just in a generic foggy street. They are passing locations from The Mysteries of London or Oliver Twist. It’s a dense, exhausting level of world-building. Kevin O'Neill's art is crucial here. His scratchy, idiosyncratic style looks like it was pulled from a Victorian penny dreadful, but it’s packed with sight gags and "easter eggs" that predated the modern obsession with background details.
You’ll see a poster for a "Sweeney Todd" barber shop in the background of one panel, or a reference to Dr. Moreau in another. It’s not just fanservice. It’s a statement about how fiction shapes our reality.
💡 You might also like: Kiss My Eyes and Lay Me to Sleep: The Dark Folklore of a Viral Lullaby
The controversy you probably didn't hear about
Moore and O'Neill didn't play nice with the properties they used. Since most of these characters were in the public domain, they could do whatever they wanted. This led to some serious friction. In the second volume, Moore used the Martian invasion from H.G. Wells' The War of the Worlds. He depicted the British military's response as incompetent and cruel.
There was also the "Marvelman" incident. At one point, a background character looked a bit too much like a certain trademarked superhero, and the legal teams went nuclear. It’s one of the reasons the series eventually moved away from DC/Wildstorm to independent publishers like Top Shelf and Knockabout. Moore wanted total creative freedom to deconstruct these icons. He wasn't interested in keeping them "brand safe."
Exploring the "Blazing World" and the later volumes
After the first two volumes, which are relatively straightforward Victorian adventures, the series gets... weird. Like, really weird.
Black Dossier was a turning point. It wasn't a traditional comic; it was a mixed-media "sourcebook." It included postcards, a 3D section (with glasses!), and prose stories that tracked the League through the 1950s. This is where Moore introduced the idea that the "League" has existed in different iterations throughout history.
Imagine a 1700s League featuring Prospero from The Tempest. Or a 1980s League that basically mocks James Bond.
Wait, let's talk about the James Bond thing. In The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen comic universe, "Jimmy" Bond is a misogynistic, inept thug who works for a crumbling, totalitarian British government. It is a scathing critique of the "gentleman spy" trope. Moore essentially argues that the heroes we celebrate are often the worst people imaginable if you look at their actions objectively.
📖 Related: Kate Moss Family Guy: What Most People Get Wrong About That Cutaway
The sheer scale of Volume IV: Tempest
The final arc, Tempest, serves as a goodbye to the entire medium of British comics. It’s chaotic. It’s meta-textual. It features characters from obscure 1960s British sci-fi strips and ends the entire universe in a way that is both beautiful and deeply cynical.
O'Neill’s art in these final chapters is a fever dream. He mimics different styles—from 1950s romance comics to psychedelic 70s art. If you're looking for a clean, easy-to-read superhero story, you’re going to hate it. But if you want to see two creators at the end of their careers throwing every single idea they have at the wall, it’s essential reading.
How to actually read the series without getting lost
If you’re diving in for the first time, don’t just buy a random trade paperback. Order matters here because the internal timeline is the whole point.
- Volume 1 & 2: The "classic" era. Start here. It’s the most accessible and contains the core story of the Murray/Quatermain dynamic.
- Black Dossier: This is optional but highly recommended if you like lore. It’s a bridge between the Victorian era and the modern stuff.
- Century (1910, 1969, 2009): This follows the immortal members of the team through the 20th century. It deals with the rise of the Antichrist (who happens to be a very famous boy wizard from another book series—Moore doesn't hold back).
- Nemo Trilogy: These are standalone graphic novels focusing on Nemo's daughter, Janni Dakkar. They are fantastic adventure stories. Heart of Ice is particularly grim and great.
- Volume 4: Tempest: The grand finale.
Is it actually "good" or just "smart"?
This is the big debate among comic fans. Some people find Moore’s later work on The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen comic to be pretentious. They feel like they need a PhD in 19th-century literature just to understand the jokes.
That’s a fair critique.
However, even if you don't recognize every single literary reference, the core emotional arc is surprisingly grounded. It’s about aging. It’s about watching the world you know disappear and being replaced by something colder and more commercial. Mina Murray’s journey from a repressed Victorian woman to an immortal, liberated figure is one of the best long-form character arcs in the medium.
👉 See also: Blink-182 Mark Hoppus: What Most People Get Wrong About His 2026 Comeback
The impact on the industry
Before League, the idea of a "shared universe" was mostly limited to Marvel and DC. Moore showed that you could build a shared universe using the entire history of human storytelling. Without this comic, you probably don't get things like Penny Dreadful or the modern wave of "reimagined" fairy tales.
It also proved that there was a massive market for "literary" comics that weren't just memoirs or political manifestos. You could have a story with a giant Mr. Hyde fighting a tripod from Mars and still have it be a serious commentary on colonialism and gender roles.
Common misconceptions
People often think this is a "Steampunk" comic. It really isn't. While it has some of those aesthetic trappings, Moore is actually quite critical of the romanticized Victorian era. He shows the filth, the racism, and the brutal class divides of the time. It’s "Period Fiction" with a jagged edge.
Another misconception is that it's a team book like the Avengers. In reality, the "League" is almost always falling apart. They betray each other constantly. By the end of the first volume, the team is fractured. By the end of the second, they are essentially enemies. It’s a deconstruction of the very idea of a "team."
Actionable Next Steps for Readers
If you want to experience The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen comic the right way, don't just skim the bubbles.
- Get the "Annotated" versions if possible: There are fan-made sites (like Jess Nevins’ incredible annotations) that break down every single reference in every panel. Reading the comic alongside these notes is like taking a masterclass in literature.
- Pay attention to the back matter: Most issues contain prose stories at the end, like "Allan and the Sundered Veil." These aren't filler; they are crucial bits of world-building that explain how the magic and science of this world function.
- Look at the lettering: Todd Klein, the letterer, uses different fonts and styles for different characters and eras. In a world where digital lettering often feels soulless, his work here is a reminder of how much craft goes into a physical book.
- Track down the Nemo spin-offs first if you're intimidated: The Nemo: Heart of Ice, The Roses of Berlin, and River of Ghosts books are shorter, tighter, and more action-oriented. They serve as a great "gateway drug" to the more complex main series.
The series is now finished. With the passing of Kevin O'Neill in 2022, there will never be more. It stands as a completed, albeit massive and messy, monument to the power of stories. It’s a challenging read, but in an era of "content" that is designed to be forgotten the moment you finish it, The League is something that sticks in your brain, forcing you to look up 1920s German expressionist cinema or obscure Victorian poets just to keep up.