It happened in a basement. No grand sacrifice on a sun-drenched battlefield. No final, poetic words shared with Ellie. Just a cold, concrete floor in Jackson and a golf club. When we talk about The Last of Us game Joel death, we aren’t just talking about a plot point in a sequel; we’re talking about one of the most divisive, agonizing, and fundamentally daring moments in the history of interactive media. It’s been years, and the internet is still screaming about it.
Honestly, that’s exactly what Naughty Dog wanted.
If you played the first game in 2013, Joel Miller wasn't just a protagonist. He was us. We spent fifteen hours crouching in the shadows with him, feeling the weight of his grief for Sarah, and eventually, making the horrific, selfish, beautiful choice to save Ellie at the cost of humanity’s future. So, when The Last of Us Part II arrived in 2020 and took him away within the first two hours, the reaction wasn't just sadness. It was a visceral, ego-shattering rejection. People felt betrayed. But to understand why the game works—or why it failed you—you have to look at the cold, hard mechanics of how Joel lived and how he died.
The Brutal Reality of the Last of Us Game Joel Death
Joel didn’t die because he got "soft." That’s the first misconception fans love to argue about on Reddit or ResetEra. The common complaint is that the Joel from the first game—the hardened survivor who smelled an ambush from a mile away—would never have walked into a room full of strangers and given his name. But that ignores the four years of relative peace he spent in Jackson.
Tommy and Joel had been running patrols. They were recruiting. They were bringing people back to their community. In that moment, during a literal blizzard and a horde of infected, Abby wasn't an enemy; she was a girl who was about to be torn apart by runners. Joel saved her. He followed her back to her group because the alternative was freezing or being eaten. It wasn't a lapse in judgment. It was a moment of humanity that cost him everything.
The scene itself is agonizingly slow. Unlike the quick deaths we see for secondary characters like Jesse later in the game, Joel’s passing is a prolonged execution. Abby Anderson doesn't just want him dead. She wants him broken. The use of a golf club—a weapon that feels mundane yet horrifyingly heavy—was a specific choice by creative director Neil Druckmann. It’s messy. It’s quiet. It’s domestic.
Why the Perspective Shift Was Necessary
Halfway through the game, the floor drops out. You stop playing as Ellie on her quest for vengeance and start playing as Abby. This is where the The Last of Us game Joel death becomes more than just a tragedy; it becomes a mirror.
💡 You might also like: Why Batman Arkham City Still Matters More Than Any Other Superhero Game
We see the hospital in Salt Lake City from Abby’s eyes. We see her father, Jerry Anderson, the surgeon Joel killed to save Ellie. Suddenly, Joel isn't the hero of the story. He’s the monster in someone else’s. He’s the guy who broke the world and murdered a father. Naughty Dog forces you to inhabit the skin of the person you hate most. It’s a psychological experiment that many players simply refused to participate in, and that’s a valid emotional response.
The Narrative Architecture of Grief
Video games usually treat death as a "Game Over" screen. You mess up, you reload, you try again. But you can't reload the story. The permanence of Joel's absence is the primary mechanic of the sequel. Every time you open your inventory as Ellie and see her shaking hands, or every time you play a flashback where Joel is teaching her to play guitar, the loss is reinforced.
- The "Future Days" song by Pearl Jam acts as a tether between the two.
- Ellie’s journal entries shift from observational to obsessive.
- The physical degradation of Ellie—her weight loss, her lost fingers—stems directly from that basement in Jackson.
It’s about the "cycle of violence," sure, but it’s more specifically about how we idolize the people we love. Ellie spent years being angry at Joel for lying to her about the Fireflies. She was just beginning to forgive him. The tragedy isn't just that he died; it's that he died the day after they decided to try and fix things. That’s the part that sticks in your throat. It’s unfair. Life is unfair. The post-apocalypse doesn't give you a scripted goodbye.
Breaking the Hero Archetype
Most games follow the "Hero’s Journey." Joel already finished his journey in the first game. He went from a broken father to a man who found something to live for. In a traditional narrative, he would have died a "warrior's death" protecting the village. By denying him that, Naughty Dog leaned into the "ludo-narrative" reality of their world. In a world where people die of infections or stray bullets every day, why would Joel be special?
He wasn't special to Abby. He was just a name on a list.
Impact on the Gaming Industry and Culture
The leak of the The Last of Us game Joel death months before the game’s release created a toxic atmosphere that the industry still hasn't quite recovered from. It sparked debates about "woke" storytelling, though Joel’s death had nothing to do with politics and everything to do with the consequences of his actions in the 2013 original.
📖 Related: Will My Computer Play It? What People Get Wrong About System Requirements
What it did prove is that players are deeply, perhaps dangerously, attached to their digital avatars. When Joel died, a part of the audience's childhood or comfort died with him. The game became a lightning rod for discussions on empathy. Can you forgive someone who killed your favorite character? The game bets its entire 30-hour runtime on the hope that you can, or at least that you can understand why they did it.
The Technical Execution of the Scene
From a purely technical standpoint, the acting by Troy Baker (Joel) and Ashley Johnson (Ellie) in that scene is harrowing. Baker has mentioned in interviews that he wanted Joel’s final look at Ellie to be one of recognition and regret, not just pain. Even as his brain is failing, he's looking at the person he loves.
The facial animation, powered by Naughty Dog's proprietary engine, captures the micro-expressions of shock on Ellie's face that make the scene nearly unwatchable for some. It is a masterclass in digital performance, even if the content is repellent.
Misconceptions You Should Stop Believing
There’s a lot of noise surrounding this topic. Let's clear some of it up.
First, Joel wasn't "retconned" into a villain. If you pay attention to the first game, he admits to being a hunter. He admits to killing innocent people. He wasn't a "good guy"; he was a guy we liked. There's a big difference.
Second, the idea that the writers "hated" Joel is absurd. You don't spend seven years developing a sequel centered entirely around a character's legacy if you hate them. Everything Ellie does—every throat she slits and every mile she travels—is because of how much she loved Joel. The game is a 30-hour eulogy.
👉 See also: First Name in Country Crossword: Why These Clues Trip You Up
Third, Abby didn't "win." By the end of the game, she has lost almost all her friends, her community (the WLF), and her physical strength. She is a shell of a person, much like Joel was at the start of the first game.
Moving Forward: What This Means for The Last of Us Part III
If and when a third game arrives, the shadow of The Last of Us game Joel death will still be there. Ellie has finally let go of the physical items—the guitar, the house—but she carries the lessons. The ending of Part II shows her walking away into an uncertain future, finally able to breathe without the weight of the revenge quest.
The next step for the franchise isn't about replacing Joel. You can't. It’s about seeing if Ellie can define herself as something other than "the girl Joel saved" or "the girl who couldn't save Joel."
Actionable Insights for Players and Writers
If you’re still grappling with the narrative choices made in The Last of Us Part II, or if you're a storyteller looking to understand its impact, consider these points:
- Analyze the Perspective: Replay the "Finding Strings" flashback. Notice how Joel is framed. He is soft, funny, and paternal. Then immediately jump to an Abby section. The contrast is where the meaning lives.
- Study the Consequences: The game teaches that every "cool" action in a video game has a ripple effect. Joel killing the doctor was a "press X to win" moment for us, but it was the end of the world for Abby.
- Embrace the Discomfort: Good art should challenge you. If you felt angry, the game succeeded. It made you feel the loss that Ellie felt.
- Look for the Subtext: Watch Joel’s house at the beginning of the game. Look at the books on his nightstand (about surgery and space). He was trying to learn how to relate to Ellie’s interests. The tragedy is in the unfinished business.
The story of Joel Miller didn't end with a whimper; it ended with a bang that shook the entire gaming world. Whether you loved it or hated it, you're still talking about it, and in the world of storytelling, that is the ultimate victory.