He’s the kind of guy you’d probably trust at a PTA meeting. Or at least, that's what he wants you to think. In the world of The Last of Us, David isn't just another bandit or a mindless fungus-head. He’s something way worse. He’s the mirror image of a protector, a "father figure" gone completely rotten from the inside out.
Most villains in this universe are just trying to survive. They’re desperate. David? He’s thriving. He enjoys the power. Honestly, even years after the original game dropped in 2013 and the HBO show hit our screens in 2023, fans are still debating the sheer depravity of the Silver Lake leader.
The Preacher vs. The Hunter
If you’ve only seen the show, you know David as the soft-spoken preacher played by Scott Shepherd. He uses the Bible like a leash. It’s effective, too. He keeps a starving community in line by promising them that "everything happens for a reason."
In the game, things are a bit different. Nolan North (the voice of Nathan Drake, believe it or not) voiced David with a calm, almost paternal warmth that makes the eventual reveal feel like a punch to the gut. The game doesn't explicitly lean into the "preacher" angle as hard—though there’s a massive banner in the steakhouse that says "When we are in need he shall provide." You don't need a degree in theology to realize David thinks he is the "he" in that sentence.
The show makes his narcissism overt. The game keeps it simmering under the surface.
✨ Don't miss: Sex Fallout New Vegas: Why Obsidian’s Writing Still Outshines Modern RPGs
That "Venison" Isn't What You Think
Let’s talk about the elephant in the room. Or rather, the human in the stew. Cannibalism is the cornerstone of David’s community. But here’s the kicker: most of his people don’t even know what they’re eating.
- David’s inner circle (including James, played by Troy Baker in the show) are the ones doing the butchering.
- The ledger Joel finds in the game suggests the group was "trading" for weeks with zero luck.
- David "solves" the hunger problem by turning their fallen—and their enemies—into rations.
It’s a sick form of management. By feeding his "flock" human meat without their consent, he’s essentially tainting them. It makes them complicit in a sin they don't even know they're committing. You’ve gotta wonder if the community would have stayed so loyal if they knew Alec wasn't actually buried under the frozen dirt.
Why David is the Ultimate Anti-Joel
The creators, Neil Druckmann and Craig Mazin, have often talked about David being a dark reflection of Joel. Think about it. Both men are leaders. Both are survivors who will do anything to keep their "family" going.
But where Joel’s violence is born from a desire to protect Ellie, David’s "protection" is actually ownership. He doesn't want to save Ellie; he wants to break her. He calls her "special" and "kindred." It’s classic grooming behavior. He sees her survival skills and thinks he’s found a mate or a protege who can finally understand his "will to live."
🔗 Read more: Why the Disney Infinity Star Wars Starter Pack Still Matters for Collectors in 2026
The Fight in the Burning Restaurant
The boss fight in the steakhouse is arguably the most stressful moment in the entire franchise. You’re playing as Ellie. You’re small. You’re hurt. David is stalking you through the shadows, mocking you.
"The fighting is the part I like the most," he tells her.
That line reveals everything. He doesn't want a quick kill. He wants the hunt. When he finally pins Ellie down, the subtext of the game becomes the text of the show. It’s a sexual assault attempt. It’s brutal and hard to watch. But it also leads to Ellie’s most defining moment: taking the machete and hacking him into pieces.
She isn't just killing a villain. She’s killing the last bit of her childhood innocence. When Joel finally grabs her and calls her "baby girl," it’s the only thing that keeps her from completely losing her mind.
💡 You might also like: Grand Theft Auto Games Timeline: Why the Chronology is a Beautiful Mess
What Most People Get Wrong About David
Some fans argue that David was "just doing what he had to" for his people. That’s a load of garbage.
- He’s a narcissist: He views his followers as "sheep" and himself as the shepherd.
- He’s a predator: His interest in Ellie isn't about her "potential" as a hunter; it’s about control.
- He’s a liar: He claims to be a man of faith or logic, but he changes his "beliefs" whenever it suits his needs.
He had a choice. Other communities, like Jackson, found ways to survive without turning into a death cult. David chose the path of least resistance because it put him on a throne.
The Legacy of Silver Lake
David’s impact on Ellie lasts way beyond that snowy winter. In The Last of Us Part II, you can see the scars. She becomes more withdrawn. She struggles with the violence she’s capable of. David showed her the absolute worst version of what a human can become in the apocalypse, and she’s been running from that reflection ever since.
If you’re looking to dive deeper into the lore, keep an eye out for the environmental storytelling in the Silver Lake resort. The "meat ledger" and the discarded clothes of victims tell a much darker story than any cutscene ever could.
Next Steps for TLOU Fans:
If you want to see the nuances of the performance, go back and watch the "behind the scenes" mo-cap footage of Nolan North and Ashley Johnson. It’s wild to see how they built that tension in gray suits with balls glued to them. You should also check out the "Left Behind" DLC if you haven't, as it adds a lot of weight to Ellie's desperation to save Joel before David ever enters the picture.