Winter in the apocalypse is a death sentence. Most people think the Cordyceps fungus is the biggest threat when the snow starts falling in The Last of Us, but they’re wrong. It’s the hunger. Honestly, when you first play through the Lakeside Resort chapter, you think you’re just dealing with another group of desperate survivors. Then the curtain pulls back. You realize the Last of Us cannibals aren't just hungry; they are organized, pious, and led by a man who uses faith as a literal meat grinder.
David. That name still carries a lot of weight for anyone who played the 2013 original or watched the HBO adaptation. He isn't a monster because he has spores coming out of his head. He's a monster because he's a math teacher who decided that human steak was the only way to keep his "flock" alive. It’s a pivot from the typical zombie trope. Usually, the threat is mindless. Here, the threat is calculated. It’s a community. That’s what makes the cannibalism in this universe so much more unsettling than your average horror movie—it’s presented as a logistical necessity for a functioning town.
The Silver Lake Reality: How the Cannibalism Actually Worked
The Silver Lake community wasn't some tiny cult hiding in a basement. They were a massive operation. We're talking dozens of families, children, and a complex social hierarchy. To keep that many people fed in the middle of a brutal Colorado winter, David and his right-hand man, James (portrayed by Troy Baker in the show, which was a nice meta-nod), had to implement a "don't ask, don't tell" policy regarding their food sources.
When Ellie first encounters David, he offers her medicine for Joel in exchange for a deer. It feels like a fair trade. It feels human. But the environmental storytelling in the game—the buckets of "meat" in the kitchen, the human ear you can find on a tray—tells a different story. They weren't just scavenging; they were hunting. They hunted "mules," which was their slang for other survivors.
It wasn't just about survival; it was about power
David is a predator in every sense. He doesn't just want to eat; he wants to possess. His interest in Ellie isn't initially about putting her on a dinner plate—he sees a "kindred spirit." He sees another survivor who has a "heart of gold" and a "will to live." This makes the Last of Us cannibals unique. They have a philosophy. David believes that the Cordyceps itself is a divine force because it "secures its future through violence." He models his leadership after a fungus. Think about how messed up that is for a second.
✨ Don't miss: Ben 10 Ultimate Cosmic Destruction: Why This Game Still Hits Different
Comparing the Game and the HBO Show
Naughty Dog did a great job making the game version of the cannibals feel like a boss fight, but the show added a layer of religious trauma that made it feel way more grounded. In the game, David is more of a classic "creepy guy." In the show, Scott Shepherd plays him as a soft-spoken preacher.
- The game focuses on the physical threat. You’re sneaking through a burning restaurant, hearing David’s footsteps on broken glass. It’s pure survival horror.
- The show focuses on the psychological grooming. David uses the Bible to justify feeding a daughter her own father’s remains.
There’s a specific scene in the show where a young girl asks when they can bury her father. David’s response is chillingly vague. He knows the father is already being processed in the back. This isn't just a plot point; it’s a commentary on how easily "civilized" people can slip into depravity when they have a leader who gives them permission to be monsters.
Why We Are Still Obsessed With the Lakeside Resort Chapter
Why does this specific part of the story stick with us more than the Clickers or the Bloaters? It's the betrayal of the social contract. In a world where everything is gone, you expect humans to band together. When Ellie meets David, there’s a flicker of hope. Maybe there are more good people out there? That hope is what he uses to bait the hook.
The Last of Us cannibals represent the ultimate failure of humanity. If you have to stop being human to survive, have you really survived? Ellie’s trauma after the steakhouse fire isn't just because she almost died. It's because she had to become a "beast" to beat the "beast." When she hacks David to pieces, she loses a part of her childhood that she never gets back. Joel holding her and calling her "baby girl" is the only thing that pulls her back from the edge, but the damage is done.
🔗 Read more: Why Batman Arkham City Still Matters More Than Any Other Superhero Game
The Logistics of Desperation
Let's look at the numbers, even though they're grim. A community of 30 to 50 people requires a massive amount of caloric intake. In a frozen wasteland with no crops and dwindling wildlife, the math simply doesn't add up for traditional survival.
- Most of the group didn't even know they were eating people.
- David and James were the "gatekeepers" of the truth.
- They used the "Everything happens for a reason" mantra to shut down any questioning.
This is a classic cult tactic. If you control the information and the food supply, you control the souls. The Last of Us cannibals weren't a group of psychos who liked the taste of flesh; they were a group of terrified people who chose to look the other way so they wouldn't starve. That's a lot more realistic—and a lot scarier—than a cartoon villain.
What Most People Get Wrong About David
A common misconception is that David was always a cannibal. If you listen to the dialogue and read the notes scattered around the resort, it’s implied this was a relatively recent development triggered by a particularly hard winter. They reached a breaking point. They had a choice: die out or cross the line. David made the choice for everyone.
He’s also not "insane" in the clinical sense. He’s highly functional. He’s a strategist. When he tells Ellie that he’s a "man of God," he might actually believe it. He’s rationalized his atrocities as a form of stewardship. That’s the hallmark of the best villains—they think they’re the hero of their own story.
💡 You might also like: Will My Computer Play It? What People Get Wrong About System Requirements
Actionable Insights: Lessons from the Winter Chapter
If you're looking at The Last of Us as a study on human behavior, the cannibal arc offers some pretty heavy takeaways about crisis management and ethics.
- Trust your gut. Ellie knew something was off even when David was being "kind." If someone feels like a predator, they usually are.
- Beware of "Benevolent" Leaders. Anyone who claims to have all the answers in a crisis—especially if those answers involve hurting others for the "greater good"—is a red flag.
- The Cost of Survival. Define your "hard lines" before a crisis hits. David’s group proves that once you cross a moral line for survival, there’s no coming back.
- Environmental Awareness. In the game, players who pay attention to the environment see the truth way before the cutscenes reveal it. Whether in gaming or real life, the "background" details usually tell the real story.
The legacy of the Last of Us cannibals isn't just about the shock value. It’s about the vulnerability of the human spirit. It’s a reminder that the "monsters" in the post-apocalypse aren't just the ones who were bitten; they're the ones who decided that their lives were worth more than their humanity.
To understand the full scope of this tragedy, you should revisit the "Lakeside Resort" chapter in Part I and pay close attention to the ambient dialogue of the townspeople. It paints a much darker picture of a town slowly realizing the price of their dinner. Focus on the notes left behind by mothers in the community; the sheer denial is where the true horror lives. If you’re watching the show, re-watch Episode 8 with a focus on David's pupils—Scott Shepherd’s performance is a masterclass in controlled, predatory stillness.