Honestly, the Clickers aren't the scariest thing in Naughty Dog’s universe. Not by a long shot. After you’ve spent hours dodging fungal zombies and Bloaters, you realize the real nightmare of the Cordyceps outbreak isn't the monsters—it's the people who’ve decided that "survival" means eating their neighbors. We’re talking about The Last of Us cannibals, specifically the group led by David in the Silver Lake resort.
It’s a tonal shift that hits like a freight train. Up until the Winter chapter, the enemies are predictable. Hunters want your shoes. The Military wants order. The Infected just want to spread the spores. But David? David wants something much more personal, and he’s built an entire society around a secret so dark it makes the collapse of civilization look like a mercy.
The Reality of David’s Group in Silver Lake
Most players remember the boss fight in the burning steakhouse, but the logistics of the Silver Lake community are what actually make The Last of Us cannibals stay in your head long after the credits roll. This wasn’t just a couple of crazy guys in a basement. It was a functioning town. They had children. They had a schoolhouse. They had a community leader who spoke with the calm, measured tone of a youth pastor.
That’s the brilliance of the writing. David isn’t a screaming maniac. When Ellie first meets him while hunting a deer, he’s helpful. He’s polite. He even gives her medicine for Joel. It’s a masterclass in gaslighting. He presents himself as a man carrying the heavy burden of leadership, trying to feed "hungry mouths" in a harsh winter. The horror comes from the slow realization that the "stew" they’re eating isn't venison. It’s "long pig."
The game’s lead designer, Anthony Newman, and creative director Neil Druckmann have often discussed how the Winter chapter was designed to strip away Ellie’s innocence. It’s the first time she’s truly alone, and she’s hunted by a predator who doesn't just want her meat—he wants her spirit.
Why We Can’t Stop Talking About the "Deer" Scene
There is a specific moment that defines the horror of The Last of Us cannibals. It’s the reveal in the meat locker. When Ellie is captured and locked in a cage, she sees a man being butchered like livestock in the background. It is clinical. It’s efficient. There’s no ritual or cult-like chanting. It’s just "food prep."
This grounded approach makes it feel real. In many post-apocalyptic stories, cannibals are depicted as feral, painted savages. Think Mad Max or The Road. But David’s group looks like your neighbors. They wear flannels and beanies. They worry about the cold. This proximity to "normalcy" is what makes their choice so repulsive. They chose this. They didn't lose their minds; they just recalculated the value of human life.
📖 Related: Siegfried Persona 3 Reload: Why This Strength Persona Still Trivializes the Game
David’s logic is a twisted mirror of Joel’s. Joel does terrible things to protect the people he loves. David does terrible things to "protect" his community. The difference is the lack of a moral line. For David, everything is "everything happens for a reason." He views his encounter with Ellie as fate, a belief system that allows him to justify kidnapping and attempted murder as part of a higher plan. It’s terrifying because you can’t reason with someone who thinks God (or the universe) told them to eat you.
Survival or Psychopathy?
Let’s get into the weeds of the psychology here. Some fans argue that David’s group had no choice. It’s winter. The crops are dead. The game is scarce. If it’s eat or die, what do you do?
But the game explicitly shows us that David is a pedophile and a narcissist. His cannibalism isn't just about calories; it's about power. He enjoys the hunt. He enjoys the fear. The show, featuring a haunting performance by Scott Shepherd (and Troy Baker in a different role), leans even harder into the religious manipulation. It portrays David as a "Teacher" who uses faith to keep his people subservient while he indulges in the most taboo acts imaginable.
The Last of Us Cannibals vs. The Hunters
You might wonder why we single out David’s group when the Pittsburgh Hunters are also pretty brutal. The Hunters are scavengers. They kill for supplies. They are "tourist" hunters. But they don't necessarily view humans as a food source as their primary "industry."
The Silver Lake crew is different. They have a system.
- The Scouting: They send out parties to find "meat."
- The Processing: They have a dedicated area for butchering.
- The Distribution: The meat is fed to the entire town, many of whom might not even know what they are eating—at least at first.
This systemic cannibalism represents the total failure of the social contract. It’s the point of no return. Once a society starts viewing people as resources to be harvested, that society is arguably more "infected" than the people running around with mushrooms growing out of their heads.
👉 See also: The Hunt: Mega Edition - Why This Roblox Event Changed Everything
The Impact on Ellie’s Psyche
The encounter with The Last of Us cannibals is the definitive turning point for Ellie. Before David, she was a kid with a switchblade and some puns. After David, she is a survivor who knows exactly how cruel the world is. The way she handles the machete at the end of that chapter isn't "badass"—it’s heartbreaking. She’s hacking away at the personification of human evil.
When Joel finally reaches her and calls her "baby girl," she isn't the same person he left in that basement in Colorado. The cannibals didn't eat her, but they took a piece of her soul. This trauma informs her entire character arc in Part II. It’s why she struggles to trust, and why she’s so prone to outbursts of violence. She learned from the best—or the worst.
Misconceptions About the Winter Chapter
Some people think the cannibals are a large-scale faction like the WLF or the Seraphites. They aren't. They are a localized nightmare. David’s group is relatively small, which makes their impact feel more intimate and claustrophobic.
Another misconception is that David was "good" until the winter got bad. If you listen to the optional dialogue and find the notes scattered around the resort, you get the sense that David was always a predator. The collapse of the world just gave him a playground. He didn't become a monster because of the fungus; the fungus just took away the police and the laws that kept him in check.
Real-World Parallel: The Donner Party
While The Last of Us is fiction, the concept of "survival cannibalism" is rooted in history. The Donner Party is the most famous example, where snowbound pioneers resorted to eating the dead to survive the Sierra Nevada mountains. However, David’s group moves past "survival" into "predatory" cannibalism. They aren't eating the already dead; they are actively hunting the living. This distinction is what moves them from a tragedy to a horror story.
Navigating the Silver Lake Resort
If you are replaying the game or jumping into the remake on PC, pay attention to the environment in the Silver Lake section. The developers put an incredible amount of detail into the "normalcy" of the town.
✨ Don't miss: Why the GTA San Andreas Motorcycle is Still the Best Way to Get Around Los Santos
- The General Store: Look at the empty shelves. It highlights the desperation that led to their "new diet."
- The Photos: You see pictures of the community before things went south. It reminds you that these were regular people once.
- The Meat Tally: There are subtle hints in the ledgers about their "inventory." It's chilling.
The fight against David is unique because it’s a stealth-based boss battle. You can’t overpower him. You’re a teenage girl; he’s a grown man with a machete. You have to use the environment, the broken glass on the floor, and the shadows. It’s a metaphor for the entire experience: the small and the vulnerable trying to survive the hunger of the powerful.
How to Process the Horror
When you're looking back at the legacy of The Last of Us cannibals, it’s best to view them as the ultimate test of the game’s central theme: love vs. survival.
Joel chooses love (in a very complicated, arguably selfish way). David chooses survival at the cost of everything that makes us human. He tells Ellie they are "the same," but they couldn't be more different. Ellie’s violence is born of a need to protect and a reaction to trauma. David’s violence is his nourishment.
If you're looking for more ways to engage with this lore, I highly recommend checking out the "Behind the Scenes" features in the The Last of Us Part I extras menu. Hearing the voice actors discuss the mindset of these characters adds a layer of skin-crawling reality to the whole thing.
Takeaways for your next playthrough:
- Listen to the screams: During the blizzard fight, the dialogue from David’s men reveals their fear and their loyalty to him.
- Check the bodies: The models for the "meat" in the back rooms are uniquely rendered to show the brutality of the process.
- Observe Ellie’s face: After the encounter, her idle animations change. She becomes more withdrawn, less likely to whistle or tell jokes for a long stretch of the game.
The Winter chapter isn't just a level; it's a scar on the story. It’s the moment the game stops being about a road trip and starts being about the dark corners of the human heart. It’s why, ten years later, we are still talking about David. We want to believe we’d never be like him, but the game asks the haunting question: in a world with no food and no hope, how hungry would you have to be to start looking at your friends differently?
Next time you see a deer in the woods in-game, you probably won't just see a target. You'll see the beginning of the end of Ellie’s childhood. That’s the power of good storytelling—it turns a simple mechanic into a psychological weight you have to carry until the final frame.