He was supposed to be the "project." That’s the word everyone threw around when the Minnesota Vikings traded up to grab J.J. McCarthy at pick number 10. Too young. Too dependent on a run game. Too... Michigan? Then, the meniscus happened. A single preseason game against the Raiders in August 2024, and suddenly the most anticipated rookie season in Twin Cities history was over before it started. People called it a disaster.
But honestly? That "lost" year might have been the best thing that ever happened to the kid’s career.
If you look at the 2025 season that just wrapped up, you see a stat line that looks like a chaotic EKG. 1,632 yards. 11 touchdowns. 12 interceptions. A 9-8 record for the team. It’s messy. It’s also exactly what a 22-year-old quarterback looks like when he's being forged in real-time.
Vikings QB J.J. McCarthy and the "Identity" Crisis
Most people look at a 1:1 touchdown-to-interception ratio and start looking for the "bust" label. That’s lazy. What J.J. McCarthy did in his actual NFL debut against the Bears was nothing short of historic. He didn't just win; he became the first rookie since Steve Young in 1985 to erase a 10-point fourth-quarter deficit in his first start.
The kid has "it." Whatever "it" is.
Kevin O’Connell isn't blind to the flaws, though. He’s been vocal about McCarthy needing to get the ball out faster. There were stretches in November—specifically that brutal loss in Green Bay where he only threw for 87 yards—where he looked completely lost. He was staring down Justin Jefferson like a lovesick teenager. Defensive coordinators aren't stupid. They saw him locking onto his primary read and they feasted.
✨ Don't miss: What Time Did the Cubs Game End Today? The Truth About the Off-Season
But then December hit.
The Resilience You Can't Teach
The most surprising thing about Vikings QB J.J. McCarthy isn't his arm or his legs. It’s his durability—or rather, his lack of it, and how he handles the bounce-back.
In 2025, McCarthy was basically a frequent flyer at the TCO Performance Center training room.
- A high-ankle sprain in Week 2 sidelined him for five games.
- A concussion against the Packers put him in the protocol.
- A hairline fracture in his throwing hand against the Giants ended his regular season a week early.
Seven missed games in one season is a lot. It’s worrying. Yet, every single time he came back, he looked better. After the ankle injury, he returned in Week 9 against the Lions and immediately hung two touchdowns and a rushing score on them in a 27-24 win.
Most young QBs get "the yips" after they get hurt. McCarthy just seems to get annoyed.
🔗 Read more: Jake Ehlinger Sign: The Real Story Behind the College GameDay Controversy
What the Critics Get Wrong About the Michigan System
The biggest knock on McCarthy coming out of college was that Jim Harbaugh hid him. "He only throws 15 times a game," they said. "He's just a game manager."
That narrative died the moment he stepped onto an NFL field. He is a natural-born gunslinger. Sometimes, too much of one. That pick-six against Chicago was a "hero ball" throw that made every Vikings fan in US Bank Stadium want to drink heavily. But he followed it up with a 27-yard laser to Aaron Jones Sr. that few veterans could pull off.
He finished the season as the first player in NFL history to record multiple passing TDs and a rushing TD in three of his first eight games. Think about that. Not Mahomes. Not Allen. The "game manager" from Michigan.
Why 2026 is the Real Litmus Test
Kwesi Adofo-Mensah and Kevin O’Connell just finished their year-end pressers, and the message was loud and clear: they want competition. They’re not just handing J.J. the keys and walking away.
Max Brosmer, the undrafted rookie who stepped in and looked surprisingly competent while McCarthy was healing, is still there. Carson Wentz provided some veteran stability (and a wild 48-10 blowout win over the Bengals), but he's a band-aid.
💡 You might also like: What Really Happened With Nick Chubb: The Injury, The Recovery, and The Houston Twist
The Vikings are likely going to bring in another vet this offseason. Maybe a bridge starter, or at least someone who can push McCarthy in camp.
O’Connell mentioned that McCarthy has only started 10 games out of a possible 34 over the last two years. That is a massive lack of reps. You can't simulate the speed of a disguised blitz from a Brian Flores-style defense in a darkened film room. You have to feel the pocket collapse. You have to feel your hand hit a helmet and know when to take the check-down instead of forcing a fracture.
The Actionable Outlook for the Offseason
So, where does this leave the Vikings? Honestly, in a better spot than the 9-8 record suggests.
If you're a fan or an analyst looking at this roster, here is what actually needs to happen for McCarthy to make "The Leap" in 2026:
- Grip and Rip: The hand injury was a fluke, but the way he recognize pain is a learning moment. He admitted he didn't realize how bad it was until he fumbled against the Giants. He needs to learn that being a "tough guy" can actually hurt the team more than sitting for a series.
- The 2.5-Second Rule: McCarthy's biggest struggle is holding the ball. When he hits his back foot and the ball isn't out, bad things happen. His footwork is erratic when he's forced off his spot. Look for O'Connell to drill "completion-first" mentalities this summer.
- Weight Room Focus: At 219 lbs, he’s not tiny, but he’s taking a beating. He needs to add some "armor" to that frame if he's going to keep playing with a "me vs. them" mentality.
McCarthy is 22 years old. He has the highest winning percentage in college history and already holds a handful of NFL "first-ever" records. The growing pains are real, and they are loud. But the ceiling? It’s still somewhere in the stratosphere.
The Vikings don't need a savior; they just need J.J. to stop trying to be one on every single play. If he can master the boring parts of the position—the check-downs, the throw-aways, the slide—the highlight reel will take care of itself.
Next time you see a box score with two interceptions, look closer. Look at the drive in the final two minutes. Look at how the huddle reacts to him. That's where the future of the North is being built.