You know that feeling when you finally get to the West Bluff on Mackinac and realize you’ve left the fudge-scented chaos of Main Street miles behind? That’s where things get interesting. Most people stick to the Grand Hotel or the waterfront B&Bs, but if you keep heading toward the interior, up past the high-end summer "cottages," you hit the Inn at Stonecliffe Mackinac Island MI. It’s basically a massive, century-old Tudor mansion that looks like it was plucked out of the English countryside and dropped onto a limestone bluff overlooking the Straits of Mackinac.
Honestly, for a few years there, Stonecliffe felt a bit like a sleeping giant that needed a serious cup of coffee. It was beautiful, sure, but it felt a little dated compared to the high-end renovations happening elsewhere on the island. That changed recently. A massive $30 million renovation—which wrapped up in early 2024—transformed the property from a "hidden gem for weddings" into arguably the most sophisticated stay on the island. It’s not just a hotel anymore; it’s a 15-acre estate that feels like a private residence.
The Massive Transformation You Probably Didn't Hear About
The Pulte family, who bought the property in 2021, didn't just slap a new coat of paint on the walls. They went deep. They added a general store, a brand new wellness center, and essentially gutted the Mansion and Summer House buildings to bring them into the modern era while keeping that 1904 Gilded Age soul intact.
When you walk into the Mansion now, it smells like expensive wood and fresh lake air. The original leaded glass windows are still there, framing views of the Mackinac Bridge that’ll make you drop your phone. But the rooms? They’ve been stripped of the dusty floral patterns of the 90s. Now, it’s all deep greens, rich leathers, and high-end linens. It feels expensive, but not stuffy.
The Inn at Stonecliffe Mackinac Island MI has always had a location problem—or a location perk, depending on who you ask. It’s two miles from the ferry docks. On an island with no cars, two miles is a trek. You’re either biking up a significant incline or paying for a horse-drawn taxi. This distance is exactly why the recent renovations included so many "stay-put" amenities. They realized that if you're going to be out in the woods, the food and the vibes better be good enough to keep you there.
🔗 Read more: Why Presidio La Bahia Goliad Is The Most Intense History Trip In Texas
Sleeping in the Mansion vs. The Summer House
There’s a real debate among regulars about where to stay. The Mansion is the original 1904 house built for Michael Cudahy. It’s got 16 guest rooms. These are the rooms with the character. Sloping ceilings, weird nooks, and the feeling that you’re staying in a rich Great Uncle’s attic. If you want the "Old Mackinac" vibe, stay here.
Then you have the Summer House. This is a separate building with 32 guest rooms that are much more "hotel-like." They have air conditioning (not always a guarantee on the island), balconies, and kitchenettes. If you have kids who need snacks at 11:00 PM or you just want more floor space, this is the move. Plus, the new 3-bedroom private cottages are the play if you’re traveling with a whole crew. They’re basically luxury homes with full kitchens and wrap-around porches.
What Most People Get Wrong About the Location
People complain about the distance from downtown. They’re wrong. Being away from the "fudgeies"—the day-trippers who swarm the island for three hours and leave—is the entire point of staying at the Inn at Stonecliffe Mackinac Island MI.
When the last ferry leaves at night, the island changes. But at Stonecliffe, it’s even quieter. You hear the wind in the cedars and the distant clip-clop of horses. No bike bells. No crowds. The hotel actually runs a shuttle for guests, which helps bridge the gap, but most people who know the island well choose this spot specifically because it’s the gateway to the "Real Mackinac." You are steps away from the Jewel Golf Course and the best hiking trails on the island, like the crack-in-the-island and the less-traveled interior woods.
💡 You might also like: London to Canterbury Train: What Most People Get Wrong About the Trip
The Food Situation (It Used to Be an Afterthought)
Let’s be real: for a long time, the dining at Stonecliffe was fine, but it wasn't a destination. That’s changed. The new signature restaurant, The 1904, is actually trying. They’re sourcing stuff from the estate's own gardens and local Michigan farms.
- The Steakhouse Vibes: It’s leaning into that classic, upscale lodge feel.
- Horsey’s: This is the new casual pub on-site. It’s named after the family’s horse, and it’s where you go for a burger and a beer after a long bike ride.
- The Backyard: This is arguably the best part of the whole renovation. There are fire pits, lawn games, and a pizza oven. On a Tuesday night in July, with the sun setting over the bridge, it’s basically peak Michigan.
The Wellness Shift
Mackinac has never really been a "wellness" destination. It’s been a "eat a pound of sugar and walk it off" destination. But Stonecliffe is trying to pivot that. The new wellness center has a legit gym, sauna, and steam room. They’ve also added two outdoor pools—one for families and one that’s more of a "soak and stare at the view" situation.
The apple orchard on the property is still there, too. It’s one of the oldest on the island. They’ve integrated it into the guest experience more, using the fruit for the kitchen and providing a weirdly peaceful spot to just sit. It sounds cliché, but there’s something about the light in that orchard at 4:00 PM that makes you forget about your email inbox entirely.
Practical Realities of Staying at Stonecliffe
Look, it’s not cheap. Since the 2024 reopening, rates have climbed. You’re paying for the privacy and the brand-new infrastructure. You also have to plan your arrivals. You can't just "pop" downtown for a quick errand. It takes 15-20 minutes by bike or horse.
📖 Related: Things to do in Hanover PA: Why This Snack Capital is More Than Just Pretzels
The Inn at Stonecliffe Mackinac Island MI is also a massive wedding destination. On Saturdays in the summer, the lawn is going to be covered in white chairs and bridesmaids. If you aren't part of the wedding party, it can feel a little like you're crashing someone's big day. If you want the quietest experience, book a mid-week stay.
What You Should Actually Do There
- Rent a bike on-site. Don't bother renting one downtown and hauling your luggage. Stonecliffe has their own fleet.
- Take the "back way" to British Landing. Skip the perimeter road for once. Take the interior trails from the Inn down toward the center of the island. You’ll see the "Skull Cave" and the "Eagle Point Cave" without the crowds.
- Nighttime at the Bridge View. Walk out to the bluff after 10:00 PM. The Mackinac Bridge is lit up, and because there's so little light pollution on that end of the island, the stars are insane.
- Visit the General Store. It’s new. It’s cute. It’s the only place on that side of the island to get a decent cup of coffee or a quick sandwich without heading back to the harbor.
How to Get the Best Value
Booking here is all about timing. The island season is short—May through October. Early June and late September are the sweet spots. The weather is crisp, the lilac bushes are either blooming or the leaves are turning, and the rates are significantly lower than the July peak.
If you're looking for a room, ask for one in the Mansion with a "Bridge View." Some rooms face the woods, which are nice and green, but the bridge view is why you’re here. Also, check for "Grand Opening" or seasonal packages. Since the renovation is still relatively fresh, they’ve been running deals that include breakfast or ferry tickets.
Actionable Next Steps for Your Trip
- Book Your Horse Taxi in Advance: When you arrive at the ferry dock, don't just wait in line. Call the taxi service (906-847-3323) as soon as your ferry leaves St. Ignace or Mackinaw City to minimize your wait time.
- Pack for "Island Formal": While Stonecliffe is more relaxed than the Grand Hotel (no mandatory tuxedo policy after 6:00 PM), people still dress up for dinner at The 1904. Bring a blazer or a nice sundress.
- Download a Trail Map: The interior trails near Stonecliffe are a labyrinth. Use an app like AllTrails or grab a paper map from the front desk before you head out, or you'll end up in someone's backyard three miles away.
- Check the Event Calendar: If there's a corporate buyout or a massive wedding, some public areas might be restricted. A quick call to the front desk before you finalize your dates can save you a lot of headache.
Staying at the Inn at Stonecliffe Mackinac Island MI is finally what it was always supposed to be: a luxury escape that feels like you've actually escaped. It’s not just a hotel on an island; it’s a specific, quiet corner of the world that finally has the amenities to match its view.