Honestly, if you were watching the score on the Indianapolis Colts game two weeks ago, you probably felt that familiar sting of "almost, but not quite." The final score was 38-30 in favor of the Houston Texans. It wasn't just a loss; it was the exclamation point on a seven-game collapse that saw the Colts tumble from 8-2 playoff darlings to 8-9 spectators.
The game took place on Sunday, January 4, 2026, at NRG Stadium. It’s kinda wild to think about how much was on the line for Houston compared to Indy. For the Texans, it was about securing the No. 5 seed and resting C.J. Stroud. For the Colts, it was about pride.
Breaking Down the Numbers: Indianapolis Colts vs. Houston Texans
The scoreboard doesn't always tell the whole story. You’ve seen 38-30 and figured it was a shootout. It was, sort of. But it was also a game of weird momentum swings and a kicker having the day of his life.
Ka’imi Fairbairn, the Texans' kicker, basically dismantled the Colts single-handedly. He hit six field goals. Six. That’s a career-high for him and a nightmare for Indy’s special teams unit.
The Scoring Timeline
Let's look at how we got to that final score. It wasn't a linear path.
✨ Don't miss: What Place Is The Phillies In: The Real Story Behind the NL East Standings
- First Quarter: Riley Leonard, the rookie QB who’s had a rollercoaster year, connected with Alec Pierce for a massive 66-yard touchdown. Early on, it looked like Indy might actually spoil Houston’s party. The Colts led 7-3.
- Second Quarter: Things got messy. Stroud found Jayden Higgins for an 11-yard score, then ran one in himself after a fumble. Suddenly, the Colts were down 20-10.
- Third Quarter: Riley Leonard showed that dual-threat spark, scampering for a 1-yard TD to put Indy back on top 24-23. The lead changed hands like a hot potato.
- Fourth Quarter: This is where the wheels fell off. With about 12 seconds left, Fairbairn nailed a 43-yarder to put Houston up 32-30.
Then came the "Colts moment" of the year. On the final play, with Indy trying to lateral their way to a miracle, Tommy Togiai scooped up a fumble and returned it for a touchdown. That 17-yard return made the score look wider than it actually was.
Why the Score on the Indianapolis Colts Game Matters
If you’re a fan, you’re looking at that 8-9 record and wondering what happened to the team that started 8-2. They were the talk of the league in October. Riley Leonard looked like the real deal. Jonathan Taylor was shredding defenses.
Taylor actually finished the season with 1,585 yards. He was second in the league. That’s elite. But even a generational talent at running back couldn't stop the bleeding of a seven-game losing streak.
The final score in Houston confirmed one thing: the defense couldn't get off the field when it mattered most. Allowing a team to kick six field goals is essentially an admission that your "bend but don't break" philosophy has officially broken.
🔗 Read more: Huskers vs Michigan State: What Most People Get Wrong About This Big Ten Rivalry
Misconceptions About the Colts’ Performance
People see a 30-point performance and think the offense was clicking. Not exactly. Leonard had some highlight-reel throws—especially to Pierce, who was the deep threat of the day—but the interception to Alijah Huzzie in the fourth quarter was the backbreaker.
It set up the field goal that gave Houston the lead for good.
- Passing: Leonard finished with 270 yards and two touchdowns.
- Rushing: Taylor was held to just 26 yards on 14 carries in the finale. Houston knew they had to stop him to win, and they did.
- Kicking: Blake Grupe did his job, including a 50-yarder, but he was overshadowed by Fairbairn’s historic day.
What's Next for the Colts in 2026?
The score on the Indianapolis Colts game was the last bit of "live" action we'll see for a while. Now the focus shifts to the front office. Chris Ballard and Shane Steichen are both coming back, which has stirred up a lot of debate in the 317 area code.
They’ve already released their 2026 opponents. It’s not going to be a walk in the park. They’ll be facing the AFC North and the NFC East. That means games against the Cowboys, Ravens, and a road trip to see Patrick Mahomes and the Chiefs.
💡 You might also like: NFL Fantasy Pick Em: Why Most Fans Lose Money and How to Actually Win
Key Steps to Improving the Outcome
If the Colts want to see a different score on the board next January, they have to address a few things immediately:
- Red Zone Efficiency: Too many times this season, Indy settled for field goals while their opponents found the end zone.
- Secondary Depth: The defensive backfield was exposed during the seven-game skid. They need a lockdown corner.
- Riley Leonard’s Consistency: He has the "it" factor, but the turnovers in high-pressure moments need to vanish.
The 2025-2026 season is officially in the books. The 38-30 loss to Houston is a bitter pill, especially since it locked the Colts into third place in the AFC South. But with Taylor still in his prime and Leonard getting a full off-season as "the guy," there’s at least a foundation.
Next time you check the score on the Indianapolis Colts game, it’ll likely be in the preseason of August 2026. Until then, it’s all about the draft and free agency. Keep an eye on the defensive tackle market; Indy needs more push up front if they’re going to stop the run better than they did in Houston.
Actionable Insights for Colts Fans:
- Review the Draft Order: With an 8-9 record, the Colts will likely pick in the middle of the first round. Target positions: Cornerback or Defensive Edge.
- Watch the Schedule Release: Expect the full 2026 schedule to drop in May. Mark the Houston home game; it’s going to be a revenge match.
- Monitor Jonathan Taylor’s Recovery: He took a beating this year with 1,500+ yards. His health is the lynchpin for the 2026 season.