If you’ve spent any time on the internet in the last few years, you’ve seen the water. Specifically, the glass of water being dumped with reckless abandon over a perfectly good cut of meat. It’s chaotic. It’s disgusting. It’s the I Think You Should Leave sloppy steaks sketch, and honestly, it changed the way we talk about being a "piece of shit."
Tim Robinson has this way of tapping into specific, unspoken social anxieties, but the "Sloppy Steaks" bit from Season 2 of his Netflix show I Think You Should Leave with Tim Robinson hit a different nerve. It wasn't just funny. It became a shorthand for personal growth, or the lack thereof. You have the spiked-up blonde hair, the white Ferrari, and the Truffoni’s reservation. You’re part of a dangerous night.
Why Do We Care So Much About Sloppy Steaks?
The sketch starts at a baby shower. It’s a classic setup for Robinson: a high-pressure social situation where everyone is trying to be "good." The character, played by Robinson, is holding a baby who won't stop crying. He decides it’s because the baby knows he "used to be a piece of shit."
This leads to a flashback of the "Dangerous Nights Crew."
They’re at Truffoni’s. They order steaks. Then, the waiter—played with a perfect level of weary professionalism—warns them: "Please, no sloppy steaks." But as soon as his back is turned, they grab the water carafes. They douse the meat. They shove the soggy, graying beef into their mouths while the staff rushes over to stop them.
It is visceral.
The humor comes from the absurdity of the act, sure, but the heart of the sketch is that line: "People can change." It’s a weirdly poignant message wrapped in a disgusting visual gag. We’ve all been the person with the slicked-back hair at some point, figuratively speaking. We’ve all done something as stupid as making a steak "sloppy" just to feel a momentary thrill of rebellion with our friends.
The Cultural Impact of the Dangerous Nights Crew
You see it everywhere now. Go to a high-end steakhouse and look at the reviews on Yelp or Google Maps. There is a 100% chance someone has commented, "They said no sloppy steaks, but they can't stop you from ordering a steak and a glass of water."
🔗 Read more: The Reality of Sex Movies From Africa: Censorship, Nollywood, and the Digital Underground
It’s a meme that refuses to die because it’s so versatile.
- The Aesthetic: Slicked-back hair (not pushed back), white bathing suits, white Ferraris, Living for New Year's Eve.
- The Language: Using "piece of shit" as a clinical term for a certain phase of your life.
- The Rule Breaking: The idea that a restaurant can have a rule, but they can't actually enforce it if you're fast enough with the water.
Sam Richardson, a frequent collaborator of Robinson’s, has talked in various interviews about how the show’s humor works by pushing a single, tiny idea to its absolute breaking point. The sloppy steak isn’t just a steak; it’s a lifestyle. It’s about the bond of a group of guys who think they’re the coolest people in the world while doing something objectively pathetic.
The Science of the "Sop" (Kinda)
Let's get technical for a second, even though it’s gross. Why would anyone actually do this? In the show, they say it makes the steak "really, really good."
In reality, if you dump water on a steak, you’re destroying the Maillard reaction. That’s the chemical process that gives seared meat its flavor and crust. You’re essentially turning a $50 ribeye into a boiled gray slab of sadness. The texture becomes mushy. The seasoning washes off.
It is the antithesis of "fine dining."
That’s the joke. It’s the ultimate "piece of shit" move because it shows a total lack of respect for the food, the chef, and the establishment. It’s chaos for the sake of chaos. Yet, fans of the show have actually tried it. There are YouTube videos and TikToks of people making I Think You Should Leave sloppy steaks at home or, more boldly, in actual restaurants. Most reports suggest it is, predictably, terrible.
What Most People Get Wrong About the Sketch
A lot of people focus on the meat. They think the "sloppy steak" is the whole point. But if you watch the sketch closely, the real story is about the guy holding the baby. He’s desperate for the grandfather to believe that he’s changed.
💡 You might also like: Alfonso Cuarón: Why the Harry Potter 3 Director Changed the Wizarding World Forever
"I'm worried that the baby thinks people can't change," he says.
The sketch is actually a masterpiece of editing and music. The track that plays during the flashback, "Dangerous Night" by Stephen Andrews, is a genuine banger that perfectly captures that mid-2000s club vibe. It makes the "piece of shit" era look alluring and high-energy, which explains why it’s so hard to leave behind.
It’s also about the distinction between "slicked back" and "pushed back" hair. It’s a tiny detail, but in the world of I Think You Should Leave, those details are everything. Pushed back implies you’re trying. Slicked back implies you’re still in the crew.
The Truffoni’s Factor
Truffoni’s doesn't exist, obviously. But we all know a Truffoni’s. It’s that place with the white tablecloths where you feel like you have to whisper. By introducing the sloppy steak, Robinson is defiling a sacred space of adult "sophistication."
Interestingly, the show’s production designer and the culinary stylists had to make those steaks look specifically "slop-ready." They couldn't just be regular steaks; they had to be able to absorb the water in a way that looked disgusting on camera.
How to Reference Sloppy Steaks Without Being "That Guy"
We’ve reached the point in the meme cycle where just saying "sloppy steaks" is almost too easy. If you want to actually use the reference effectively, you have to dig into the deeper lore.
- Mention the hair. If someone’s hair is looking a little too greasy, they’re a candidate for the Dangerous Nights Crew.
- The Blue Dolphin. Remember, they went to the Blue Dolphin once. It burned down. It’s gone now. John Rovani’s ass out, works with his brother now. These are the deep cuts that prove you’ve actually watched the show and aren't just following a Twitter trend.
- The "Piece of Shit" realization. Use it when you’re looking at old photos of yourself in a cringe-worthy outfit. "Oh yeah, I was a huge piece of shit back then."
The Philosophy of Change
Is it possible to actually change? The show suggests yes, but with a caveat. You’ll always have that "sloppy steak" energy buried somewhere inside you. The baby eventually stops crying and lets the guy hold him, which is the "happy ending."
📖 Related: Why the Cast of Hold Your Breath 2024 Makes This Dust Bowl Horror Actually Work
But the messy, watery ghost of the past is always there.
The enduring popularity of the I Think You Should Leave sloppy steaks meme is a testament to how well Tim Robinson understands the human urge to be a little bit bad. We all want to dump the water sometimes. We all want to ignore the waiter’s plea.
Your Sloppy Steak Action Plan
If you’re planning on hosting an I Think You Should Leave watch party, or you just want to pay homage to the Dangerous Nights Crew, here is how to handle the "sloppy" element without ruining your life or your kitchen.
- Don't actually do it at a restaurant. Seriously. It’s a nightmare for the busboys and it’s disrespectful to the kitchen. Also, it’s 2026; haven't we moved past harassing service workers for "the bit"?
- The "Safe" Sloppy Steak: If you must try it, do it at home with a cheap flank steak. Use warm water so you don't instantly chill the meat. Take the photo, make the joke, and then realize you've just wasted a cow's life for a joke that was funnier when Tim Robinson did it.
- Embrace the "People Can Change" Mantra: Use the sketch as an excuse to forgive yourself for your past mistakes. Whether it was wearing a fedora in 2012 or being a jerk to a waiter, remember that you’re not that person anymore. You’ve pushed your hair back.
- Support the Creators: The best way to keep the spirit of sloppy steaks alive is to keep watching the show and supporting the weird, offbeat comedy that Netflix (surprisingly) continues to fund.
The sloppy steak is more than a food item. It’s a state of mind. It’s a reminder that life is messy, people are ridiculous, and sometimes, the only way to handle a "Dangerous Night" is to lean into the absurdity. Just maybe keep the water in the glass.
Practical Next Steps for the Dangerous Nights Crew
If you want to dive deeper into the ITYSL rabbit hole, your next move should be exploring the "Calico Cut Pants" or "Brian's Hat" sketches. These deal with similar themes of social shame and the desperate need for validation. If you're looking for the music, search for the "I Think You Should Leave" soundtrack on Spotify; the "Dangerous Night" track is a legitimate addition to any workout playlist. Finally, if you're actually going to eat a steak tonight, just use salt and pepper. Leave the water for the plants.