Let's be real for a second. We’ve all been there, standing in front of the bathroom mirror at 7:00 AM, trying to get that perfect "cool girl" smudge, only to end up looking like we’ve had a very rough night in a rainy city. It’s annoying. Eyeliner is notoriously fickle. But then Huda Kattan—who basically built an empire on the fact that she knows exactly what people want before they do—dropped the Huda Beauty Creamy Kohl Eye Pencil, and the internet collectively lost its mind.
It isn't just another pencil. It feels different the second it touches your skin. You know how some pencils feel like you’re trying to draw on your eyelid with a frozen crayon? This isn't that. It’s hybrid. It’s melty. It’s weirdly pigmented.
Why the Huda Beauty Creamy Kohl Eye Pencil is Winning the Smudge Game
Most "long-wear" liners dry down way too fast. You draw a line, reach for your brush to blend it, and—boom—it’s stuck. It’s permanent. You’re now committed to that shaky line for the next twelve hours. Huda’s formula, specifically the Very Vanta shade (which is an aggressively deep black), gives you a window. You get a few seconds of play. You can smudge it with your finger or a dense brush, and it moves like silk. But once it sets? It’s not going anywhere.
The science behind it is pretty straightforward. It uses a blend of waxes and "crushed" pigments that allow for that initial slip. Professional makeup artists, like Katie Jane Hughes, often talk about the importance of "playtime" in a product. If a product doesn't move, you can't create dimension. The Huda Beauty Creamy Kohl Eye Pencil manages to balance that slippery application with a finish that eventually turns matte and waterproof.
I’ve seen people use this for everything from a tightline to a full-blown editorial wing. It’s versatile. That’s the point. You don't need five different tools when one pencil can basically do the job of a gel pot and a traditional kohl.
The Waterline Test
If you have sensitive eyes, you’re probably skeptical. Most things that claim to be "long-wear" burn like crazy when you put them in your waterline. Honestly, I was surprised. This one is ophthalmologically tested, which is fancy speak for "it won't make your eyes turn bloodshot."
💡 You might also like: Wire brush for cleaning: What most people get wrong about choosing the right bristles
Because it’s so creamy, you don't have to press hard. That's the secret. When you're working on the delicate inner rim of the eye, pressure is the enemy. This pencil just glides. It’s high-impact without the struggle. Some users have noted that if you have exceptionally oily lids, you might still want to set the outer corners with a tiny bit of translucent powder, but for the average person, it stays put remarkably well.
Breaking Down the Shades: Very Vanta and Very Brown
Huda kept it simple. Sometimes brands release thirty shades and it’s overwhelming. Here, we have the essentials. Very Vanta is the blackest black. It’s named after Vantablack, the darkest substance known to man, and while it’s not literally that dark, it’s close enough for your eyelids. It’s moody. It’s intense.
Then there’s Very Brown.
Don't sleep on the brown. If you’re doing a "no-makeup" makeup look, or if you have lighter features, the black can sometimes look a bit harsh for a Tuesday afternoon grocery run. The brown is rich—think dark chocolate, not clay. It gives that "I woke up like this" definition without looking like you’re trying too hard.
What Most People Get Wrong About Application
One major mistake? Sharpening it like a regular pencil.
📖 Related: Images of Thanksgiving Holiday: What Most People Get Wrong
Because the Huda Beauty Creamy Kohl Eye Pencil is so soft, if you use a dull, cheap sharpener, you’re going to eat through the product in a week. You need a sharp, high-quality cosmetic sharpener. And don't overdo it. You don't need a needle-thin point because the formula is designed to be blended out anyway.
Another tip: Work one eye at a time. I know I said it has "playtime," but it’s not infinite. If you draw on both eyes and then try to smudge the first one, you might find it’s already started to "lock." Draw, smudge, repeat.
Comparing it to the Competition
How does it stack up against something like the Victoria Beckham Satin Kajal or the Urban Decay 24/7?
- Victoria Beckham: More expensive, perhaps a bit more "luxury" feel, but the Huda pencil is actually slightly creamier upon first contact.
- Urban Decay: A classic, for sure. But UD can sometimes feel a bit "waxy" after it's been in your drawer for a few months. The Huda formula seems to stay "wet" in the pencil longer.
- Drugstore Alternatives: You can find cheap liners, but they usually lack the pigment density. You end up having to go over the same line four times, which irritates the skin.
Dealing with the "Transfer" Myth
You’ll hear some people complain that kohl liners transfer to their upper lid. This usually happens because of anatomy—if you have hooded eyes, everything transfers. The fix isn't the pencil; it's the prep. Using a tiny bit of eye primer or even just a sweep of bronzer over the lid before you apply the liner creates a barrier. The Huda Beauty Creamy Kohl Eye Pencil is waterproof, but it isn't "oil-proof" (nothing truly is, because oil breaks down makeup). If your lids are an oil slick, give them a quick wipe or prime them first.
Real Talk: The Pros and Cons
Nothing is perfect. Let's be honest about it.
👉 See also: Why Everyone Is Still Obsessing Over Maybelline SuperStay Skin Tint
The biggest "con" is that because it’s so soft, you do have to sharpen it often if you want a precise line. You’re going to go through the pencil faster than a hard, dry pencil. That’s the trade-off for the pigment and the ease of use. It’s a "performance" product. Like a high-end sports car that burns through tires, this pencil burns through its length because it’s giving you so much payoff.
On the "pro" side, the retractable-style pencils often snap or dry out. Since this is a traditional wood-cladded pencil (well, it's a specialized material that sharpens like wood), the airtight seal is better. The product stays fresh.
How to Get the Best Results Tonight
If you’ve just picked up the Huda Beauty Creamy Kohl Eye Pencil, try this: Don't try to draw a perfect line. Instead, make messy little dashes right into the base of your lashes. Take a small, stiff brush—or even a Q-tip if you’re in a pinch—and just wiggle it back and forth. You’ll get this effortless, hazy definition that makes your lashes look twice as thick.
It’s great for the "reverse cat-eye" trend too. You apply it to the lower lash line, pull it out toward the temple, and smudge the top edge. It’s dramatic but takes about thirty seconds.
Step-by-Step for a 60-Second Smokey Eye
- Prep the lid: Swipe a bit of concealer or primer across the lid and set it with a neutral shadow.
- The Base Line: Trace the Huda Beauty Creamy Kohl Eye Pencil along the upper lash line. Don't worry about being neat.
- The Smudge: Use a pencil brush (like the Morphe M213 or a similar dense brush) to blur the top edge of the line upward.
- The Waterline: Run the pencil along the top and bottom inner rims of the eye.
- Final Touch: Add a coat of mascara.
This specific pencil changed the way a lot of people approach their routine because it removed the "fear" factor of liquid liners. You can't really mess it up because it’s designed to be moved around.
To keep your pencil in top shape, always make sure the cap is clicked on tight. Air is the enemy of creamy formulas. If you leave the cap off, the oils will evaporate and you’ll lose that signature glide. Keep it cool, keep it capped, and keep a good sharpener nearby. You’re basically set for any look from a subtle daytime tightline to a full-on grunge aesthetic.
Actionable Next Steps
- Check your sharpener: If it’s over six months old or from a random drugstore brand, replace it with a professional one to avoid wasting the soft core of the kohl.
- Test the "Warm-Up": If you live in a cold climate, scribble the pencil on the back of your hand for two seconds before hitting your eye. This "primes" the waxes for an even smoother application.
- Try the "Very Brown" for Contour: In a pinch, a tiny dot of the brown shade smudged at the very outer corner of the eye can lift the face more naturally than a heavy black wing.