Honestly, the discourse around The Hobbit The Battle of the Five Armies is usually a mess. You’ve probably heard it all before. It’s "too much CGI." It’s "not the book." It’s "a bloated mess." But looking back at the 2014 conclusion to Peter Jackson’s prequel trilogy, there’s a lot more nuance to the film than just the technical fatigue people felt at the time.
It was a weird moment for cinema. Peter Jackson was stepping back into Middle-earth after Guillermo del Toro left the project, and he was basically flying by the seat of his pants. If you watch the behind-the-scenes features, Jackson is open about the fact that he was often winging the script on the day of shooting because the pre-production time just wasn't there. That frantic energy is baked into every frame of the final 144-minute theatrical cut.
The Chaos of Production Meets Middle-earth
You can see the exhaustion. By the time we get to The Hobbit The Battle of the Five Armies, the charm of An Unexpected Journey has been replaced by a grim, kinetic urgency. The film starts with a literal bang—Smaug destroying Lake-town. It’s a sequence that probably should have been the ending of the second movie, The Desolation of Smaug, but instead, it serves as a chaotic cold open that sets the tone for a film that refuses to slow down.
Benedict Cumberbatch’s Smaug is a marvel. Truly. His voice work is dripping with malice, and the visual effects on the dragon remain some of Weta Digital’s best work. But Smaug dies within ten minutes. Then, the movie shifts gears entirely. It becomes a political thriller about gold sickness and ancestral rights, trapped inside a massive war epic.
Thorin Oakenshield, played with incredible intensity by Richard Armitage, becomes the heartbeat of the film. His descent into "dragon sickness" is one of the few places where the movie slows down enough to breathe. Watching him pace the gold-covered floor of Erebor, hearing his voice warp into Smaug’s, is genuinely chilling. It’s a tragic performance that often gets overshadowed by the sheer amount of digital orcs on screen.
What Actually Happens in the Battle?
People complain about the length of the battle. It is long. Very long. But the geography of the fight is actually quite clever once the armies collide. You have the Elves, the Dwarves, the Men of Dale, the Orcs, and then... well, the "fifth" army is often a point of debate. Is it the Eagles? The Wargs? The Goblins from the North? Tolkien’s text says it’s the Wargs, but Jackson leans heavily into the Bolg and Azog rivalry.
📖 Related: Ashley Johnson: The Last of Us Voice Actress Who Changed Everything
The tactical shifts are interesting if you’re a nerd for fantasy warfare. The way the Elven archers jump over the Dwarven shield wall to engage the orcs is a cool visual, even if it makes absolutely no sense from a military standpoint. Why would you give up the protection of a shield wall? Because it looks cool. That’s the Jackson mantra.
Billy Connolly as Dain Ironfoot is a highlight that many forget. Even though he was heavily digitized because of Connolly’s health at the time, his arrival on a war-pig is pure, unadulterated fun. It’s the kind of high-fantasy absurdity that the movie needed more of to balance out the dour tone of Thorin’s internal struggle.
The Romance That Divided Everyone
We have to talk about Kili and Tauriel. Evangeline Lilly has been vocal about how she originally signed on to the project on the condition that there would be no love triangle. Then, during pick-ups and reshoots, the studio insisted on it. It’s perhaps the most glaring example of "studio interference" in the entire trilogy.
Does it work? Not really. But it does give Legolas something to do. Orlando Bloom’s return as Legolas in these films is a double-edged sword. On one hand, he’s a beloved character. On the other, his gravity-defying stunts—like the infamous stone-bridge hop—pushed the "cool factor" into the realm of a video game. It lacked the grounded, gritty feel of the original Lord of the Rings trilogy.
However, the emotional payoff for Kili and Tauriel is actually quite sad. When Tauriel asks why love hurts so much, and Thranduil (Lee Pace, who is incredible in this) tells her "because it was real," it hits home. It’s a moment of genuine humanity in a movie otherwise dominated by pixels.
👉 See also: Archie Bunker's Place Season 1: Why the All in the Family Spin-off Was Weirder Than You Remember
Why the Extended Edition is a Different Beast
If you’ve only seen the theatrical version of The Hobbit The Battle of the Five Armies, you haven't seen the whole movie. The R-rated Extended Edition is a completely different experience. It’s bloodier. It’s weirder. It includes an entire chariot sequence on ice that is genuinely some of the best action Jackson has ever directed.
- The Chariot Scene: Balin, Dwalin, Fili, and Kili on a goat-drawn chariot. It's ridiculous and violent.
- Bifur's Axe: We finally see the axe in Bifur's head get removed. It’s a small, weird detail that fans of the book appreciated.
- The Funeral: The theatrical cut completely omits the funeral of Thorin, Fili, and Kili. This is a massive mistake. Without the funeral and the crowning of Dain, the movie feels like it just stops. The Extended Edition provides the closure that the story desperately needs.
The inclusion of the funeral scene specifically fixes the pacing of the ending. It allows the audience to mourn with Bilbo. Martin Freeman’s performance as Bilbo Baggins is the glue holding everything together. His "I'm going home" speech to the remaining dwarves is heartbreaking. Freeman manages to portray a hobbit who has seen too much, a far cry from the fussy gentle-hobbit who left the Shire three movies ago.
The Technical Legacy
Looking at the film in 2026, the CGI has aged better than people predicted, but the "High Frame Rate" (HFR) 48fps experiment is mostly a forgotten relic. It made everything look too real, like a stage play, which stripped away the cinematic "magic." If you watch it today on a standard 24fps display, the digital sets of Erebor and Dale look massive and immersive.
The music by Howard Shore remains a masterpiece. He brings back themes from the first two films but twists them into darker, more militaristic versions. The song "The Last Goodbye," performed by Billy Boyd (who played Pippin), is a perfect bridge between the two trilogies. It feels like a final farewell to an era of filmmaking that we probably won't see again—the massive, location-based epic that spent years in production.
Misconceptions About the Ending
A lot of people think the movie ends abruptly because it was supposed to be two films instead of three. That’s partially true. Originally, The Hobbit was a two-film deal. When it was expanded to three, the "Battle" became the focal point of the final installment. This is why the movie feels like one giant third act.
✨ Don't miss: Anne Hathaway in The Dark Knight Rises: What Most People Get Wrong
Another common gripe is the lack of Beorn. In the book, Beorn is a turning point in the battle. In the movie, he gets about ten seconds of screen time. It’s a shame. Mikael Persbrandt brought a scary, feral energy to the character that could have been used more effectively to show the "nature vs. industrialization" theme that Tolkien loved.
Making Sense of the Middle-earth Timeline
To truly appreciate what Jackson was doing, you have to look at how this film bridges to The Fellowship of the Ring. The White Council’s attack on Dol Guldur is a big part of this film. Seeing Galadriel, Elrond, and Saruman take on the Nazgûl is pure fan service, but it’s high-quality fan service. It explains why Sauron is a "lidless eye" in the later films and why he’s so focused on finding the Ring.
Galadriel banishing Sauron is a powerful moment, showcasing Cate Blanchett’s range. It also subtly hints at Saruman’s future betrayal. The way he tells the Council to "leave Sauron to me" is a chilling foreshadowing of his descent into darkness.
Final Verdict on the Battle
Is it a perfect movie? No. Is it a worthy conclusion? Mostly.
The film succeeds because of the characters. Bilbo and Thorin’s relationship is the soul of the story. Everything else—the trolls with catapults on their backs, the giant worms, the Legolas stunts—is just window dressing. If you strip away the noise, it's a story about a small person in a very big, very dangerous world, trying to do the right thing when everyone around him is losing their minds to greed.
Actionable Next Steps for Fans:
- Watch the Extended Edition: If you haven’t, you haven't seen the real movie. The added 20 minutes of character work and the R-rated action change the tone significantly.
- Track the Themes of Greed: Re-watch the scenes in Erebor focusing only on Thorin. Notice how the lighting and his costume change as the "gold sickness" takes hold.
- Compare to the Book: Read the final four chapters of Tolkien's The Hobbit. It’s a quick read and highlights exactly where Jackson stayed true to the spirit and where he went off the rails.
- Check Out the Appendices: The "Making Of" documentaries for this film are arguably better than the movie itself. They provide a raw look at the pressures of big-budget filmmaking.
Ultimately, The Hobbit The Battle of the Five Armies serves as a loud, messy, emotional goodbye to Peter Jackson's Middle-earth. It’s a film that tried to do everything at once and, while it stumbled, it still captured the tragic beauty of Tolkien's world in a way few other directors could.