You’re standing in a line that snakes around a parking lot in Baldwin Park or maybe a sun-bleached strip mall in Scottsdale. The menu is tiny. It’s been basically the same since Harry and Esther Snyder opened the first drive-thru stand in 1948. Burgers, fries, shakes—that’s it. Or so the plastic light-up board wants you to believe. But the truth is, the hidden In N Out menu is less of a secret and more of a cultural handshake.
It’s a vernacular.
If you just order a cheeseburger, you’re getting a great meal, sure. But you’re missing the customization that makes this place a cult obsession. Most people think they know the "secret" stuff because they’ve heard of Animal Style. Honestly, though? That’s just the tip of the iceberg. There are layers to this system that involve specific grill times, mustard-searing techniques, and cheese-to-meat ratios that would make a Michelin-star chef dizzy.
📖 Related: Mary Oliver Quotes on Nature: Why They Still Hit Different in a Busy World
Why Animal Style is Only the Beginning
Let's get the big one out of the way. Animal Style. It is the undisputed king of the hidden In N Out menu. If you order a burger this way, they cook the patty with mustard on one side, then pile on extra spread, pickles, and those glorious grilled onions. It’s messy. It’s salty. It’s perfect.
But have you ever actually looked at what makes it work?
The "spread" is a proprietary variant of Thousand Island, but it’s the chopped grilled onions that do the heavy lifting. If you’re not a fan of the mess, you can actually ask for "mustard fried" without the extra sauce. This gives you that savory, crusty tang on the beef without turning your wrapper into a soup bowl. It's a nuanced distinction most casual fans miss.
Then there are the fries. Ordering them Animal Style is a rite of passage, but here’s a pro tip: ask for them "well done." In N Out famously uses fresh-cut Kennebec potatoes. Because they aren't double-fried like McDonald’s, they can sometimes get limp and soggy under the weight of cheese and spread. Asking for "light well" or "well done" ensures they actually hold up as a structural vessel for the toppings.
The Engineering of the Burger Build
Most people think the "Double-Double" is the limit. Not even close. While the company famously capped the "X-by-Y" orders years ago—after a legendary 100x100 order in Las Vegas went viral and probably broke a grill cook's spirit—you can still go up to a 4x4. That’s four beef patties and four slices of cheese.
It is a literal mountain of protein.
Customizing the Crunch and Heat
If you want to sound like a local, you need to talk about peppers and toast.
- Chopped Chilies: They use yellow Cascabella peppers. They are hot. Not "fast food hot," but genuinely spicy. You can ask for them chopped into the bottom of any burger.
- Extra Toast: This is the most underrated move on the hidden In N Out menu. They leave the bun on the flat top for a few extra seconds. It creates a moisture barrier so the tomato juice doesn't turn your bread into mush.
- Cold Cheese: Most people want it melted. But some enthusiasts swear by a "cold cheese" burger. The contrast between the searing hot beef and the thick, unmelted American slice is... divisive. But it’s a thing.
The Veggie Option (That Isn't a Salad)
In N Out doesn’t do plant-based meat. They never have. If you’re a vegetarian, you’re looking at a "Grilled Cheese." This isn't just a slice of bread with cheese; it’s a standard burger build—lettuce, tomato, onions, spread—but with two slices of melted cheese instead of meat. It’s surprisingly satisfying because the produce is so fresh.
Then there’s the "Wish Burger" or "Veggie Burger." This is basically just a bun stuffed with salad. It’s the "In N Out for people who aren't hungry" option.
Understanding the "Secret" Language of Fries
The fries are the most controversial part of the experience. Some people hate them. Those people are usually ordering them wrong. Because the potatoes are sliced and dropped immediately into the oil, they have a very high moisture content.
If you want to master the hidden In N Out menu, you have to specify the fry texture:
- Fries Light: They’re pulled early. They are pale, soft, and slightly raw in the middle. Only for the brave or the very specific.
- Fries Well: Golden brown and crunchy like a potato chip.
- Fries Extra Well: These are basically crackers.
- Cheese Fries: Two slices of melted cheese on top. Simple, but effective.
One thing you should never do? Ask for "Roadkill Fries." Most locations will refuse to do it for food safety and consistency reasons. It’s supposed to be a Flying Dutchman (two patties and cheese) crumbled on top of Animal Fries. Some locations might humor you if it's slow, but don't count on it. Just order a Flying Dutchman and a side of Animal Fries and DIY that masterpiece yourself.
Shakes and Drinks: The Neapolitan Hack
Don't just settle for chocolate.
The "Neapolitan" is the gold standard of the hidden In N Out menu shakes. They layer chocolate, vanilla, and strawberry in one cup. It looks like a sunset and tastes like childhood. If you want something a bit lighter, ask for a "Root Beer Float." It’s half root beer, half vanilla shake. It’s way better than the standard soda.
Also, the "Lemon-Up." It’s a mix of 7-Up and lemonade. It’s crisp, tart, and cuts through the grease of a 3x3 perfectly.
The Flying Dutchman and the Carb-Cutters
For the keto crowd or the "meat purists," there is the Flying Dutchman. Legend says it was named after Guy Snyder, who loved the simple combo. It is just two slices of cheese melted between two beef patties. No bun. No lettuce. No distractions.
If you want it to actually taste like a meal, ask for it "Protein Style." They wrap the whole thing in massive, hand-torn leaves of iceberg lettuce. It’s remarkably clean to eat, considering there’s no bread.
The Onion Tier List
You have four distinct choices for onions, and you can mix and match them.
- Raw Onions: Big, crunchy rings.
- Raw Chopped Onions: For that McDonald's-esque bite but fresher.
- Grilled Onions: Diced and caramelized until they’re jammy.
- Whole Grilled Onions: This is the elite choice. They take a full slice of onion and grill it so it stays intact but gets sweet and charred.
What Most People Get Wrong About the Secret Menu
The biggest misconception is that these items are actually "hidden." In N Out is incredibly proud of their flexibility. They even have a "Not So Secret Menu" section on their actual website. Using these terms isn't about "hacking" the system to save money—it’s about getting exactly what you want.
In N Out is a high-volume machine. The reason they can handle those 20-car deep lines is because the kitchen is organized around these specific modifications. When you say "Double-Double Animal Style, whole grilled onions, chopped chilies, fries well," the person on the headset isn't annoyed. They’re clicking buttons that have been there for decades.
Real-World Strategy for Your Next Visit
If you’re heading there now, here is the move. Go during the "off-peak" hours—usually 2:30 PM to 4:30 PM. The grill isn't as slammed, so your "Extra Toast" or "Fries Well" will actually get the attention it deserves.
Actionable Next Steps:
- Test the Whole Grilled Onion: Next time you order, swap the standard grilled onions for a "Whole Grilled Onion." It changes the structural integrity of the burger and gives you a much better flavor distribution.
- The Dip Move: If you don't want the mess of Animal Fries, ask for "Sides of Spread." They’ll give you those little packets or cups. It’s free, and you can control the sauce-to-fry ratio yourself.
- Check Your Receipt: In N Out is famous for accuracy. If you ordered something complex from the hidden In N Out menu, look at the receipt immediately. They use a shorthand (e.g., "S" for spread, "O" for onions, "Gr" for grilled) that’s easy to double-check before you pull away from the window.
- The Pepper Prep: If you’re getting the chopped chilies, ask for a couple of whole yellow peppers on the side. They come in a little plastic bag. Biting into one between mouthfuls of burger is the authentic Californian way to eat it.
Ordering off the secret menu isn't about being an insider. It’s about realizing that a three-item menu is actually a kit for building the best fast-food meal in the country. Now go get a 3x3 mustard fried and see for yourself.